4 ms·
> Biology does not act like a computer. You cannot reduce biology to an operating system Nobody is doing that. Analogies are drawing rough outlines in the thou
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
> Biology does not act like a computer. You cannot reduce biology to an operating system
Nobody is doing that. Analogies are drawing rough outlines in the thought-space[0], they aren't a definition. As such, they are helpful.
--
[0] - Or latent space, if I want to make an analogy inside the analogy apologia.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fabian2k 3y agoI don't think the programming analogies are helpful here, they seem to cause a serious amount of confusion. The basic idea isn't so bad, but too many people seem to try and push them much, much further than they can work. For a developer this analogy also implies a lot of assumptions that they know to be true for code that are simply wrong for biology.
- theGnuMe 3y agoOne can view the cell as an information processing entity. If we agree with that view then it can be analyzed as an abstract computational process. If you are upset about using the word 'computational' then consider it to be a dynamical process. We can then use mathematics to analyze this system. In any event, genes (programming instructions) encode proteins (applications) that run in the cell (operating system). Now biology is weird and has multiple feedback steps, some of which we probably do not even know yet, but the basic approach is solid.
- fabian2k 3y agoThose analogies imply things that simply aren't true. Genes and proteins aren't digital, they are real entities with physical and chemical properties that affect everything they do. Of course you can model various aspects of cells mathematically. But that doesn't require any analogies to software.
- theGnuMe 3y agoThere's no requirement that a computer or computational process be 'digital'. Analog computers exist, in fact, the first computers were analog. At any rate digital (0,1) strings aren't that different than DNA strings (A, T, C, G) and just because we have 4 characters in the alphabet doesn't mean you can't analyze it as an abstract computational process. You can also discretize the concentration of molecules such that above a threshold switch like behavior occurs (gene turns on or off). Also people have done experiments where they program DNA to perform computations to solve various problems like the traveling salesman problem. This is a direct application of using biology to solve a "digital problem" https://www.nature.com/articles/news000113-10 https://www.nature.com/articles/news000113-10 So here we have an example of an artificial logical problem encoded into DNA and solved using biology. That means biology can simulate computational algorithms.
- FrustratedMonky 3y ago"model various aspects of cells mathematically" I think a lot of people here will equate software/programming to mathematically modeling. Saying you can model/math it, but not use software analogies, is just really trying to split hairs, since models/math is also software.
- getoffmycase 3y agoThe fundamentals of biology are not difficult to grasp. Evolution, DNA -> RNA -> Protein, basic cell signalling, etc are all really easy to grasp with just the tiniest bit of effort. There's really no place for bad analogies, especially such a misleading one. Sorry to bite your head off, but the reason that I'm passionate about this topic is, and I'm not joking, young earth Creationism. An analogy like the grandparent is something simple to grasp by many people, and then the Creationists can quickly turn around and say, "Well you see how biology is like a computer; somebody built a computer; therefore, God created us in six days, 6000 years ago."
- silent_cal 3y ago[flagged]
- getoffmycase 3y agoWhat are the proper qualifications to criticize evolution?
- jononomo 3y agoWell, you could start by reading these books: 1. Darwin on Trial by Phillip E. Johnson 2. The Stairway To Life: An Origin-Of-Life Reality Check by Tan & Stadler 3. Darwin's Doubt by Stephen C. Meyer
- gaganyaan 3y agoYou could, but you shouldn't. Picking up any basic science book would be better use of your time.
- jibal 3y agoThose are by people not qualified to criticize evolution.
- silent_cal 3y ago
- Viliam1234 3y agoHow exactly is the analogy "DNA: file.c" helpful to answer the question from the article "Where did DNA come from?"?