6 ms·
The author misses one big implication of Amazon Prime: it's an invitation to start routing thousands of dollars in annual spending through Amazon. I'm in Canad
by graeme 15y ago
The author misses one big implication of Amazon Prime: it's an invitation to start routing thousands of dollars in annual spending through Amazon.
I'm in Canada. If prime were available here, I would rarely go into a store except for groceries. Most other things I need I would just get shipped to me, much easier that way.
Not everyone in the US has figured out that free delivery of supplies is usually easier than driving to the store. But once amazon gets someone inside their ecosystem, it will be much easier to convince them to route more
and more purchases through amazon.
Given the broad range of amazon's offerings, it's a huge mistake to treat them as a book company, or an e-reader company.
- harlanlewis 15y agoThis. When I need a new pack of dry erase markers, I spend 45 seconds giving Amazon $5. Two days later, I don't have a dry erase marker problem anymore. I don't really know how I feel about the future world that's created by universal delivery like this, but there's something wonderful about every "pick up x at store" chore being reduced to a few moments.
- jayzee 15y agoplease don't do the 'This' thing.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- swombat 15y agoJust do what I do: I reflexively downvote any comment starting with "This[punctuation]". Variations (e.g., used elsewhere in this discussion, "Exactly this.") also get the downvote. If we all do "this", we can perhaps stamp out this annoying habit.
- bmelton 15y agoY'know, it's funny. I also hate "This" as a usage for, well, anything. Reading this comment made me go look to see what moron posted "Exactly this" only to find out it was me. :-( It gets worse too, now that I think about it, in that I responded to a comment about the article without having read the article. I suppose it's contagious? Ug. Now I'm having a crisis. Either way, thanks for pointing out it, however indirectly.
- swombat 15y agoY'know, it's funny. I also hate "This" as a usage for, well, anything. Reading this comment made me go look to see what moron posted "Exactly this" only to find out it was me. :-( Lol, that's gotta suck :-) I'm sure this sort of stuff has happened to me before... If you don't want to follow the "this" herd, don't :-)
- WildUtah 15y agohttp://qcjeph.livejournal.com/110229.html http://qcjeph.livejournal.com/110229.html
- kylebrown 15y ago> I also hate "This" as a usage for, well, anything. For a second there I thought I was trying to parse some javascript.
- meepmorp 15y agoThis?
- psb217 15y agoYes, that.
- mahyarm 15y agoI have the opposite attitude, I reflexively down vote grammar nazism and a lack of flexibility for language change. Languages change organically, people spoke differently 100 years ago even and there is nothing wrong with it. It's like razing people for using the word 'like' instead of 'for example', even though they are functionally identical.
- sigmaxipi 15y agoWhy not? 'This' is just like 'me too' or '+1'. By itself, it's a waste of a comment, but since harlanlewis elaborated, the "This." was just a prologue to the rest of the comment.
- MrMan 15y agoIf the number of votes for a comment were visible people probably wouldn't feel the need to annotate their comments with "this" or "++1". So blame the commenting economy of HN. Or just accept it.
- bmelton 15y agoExactly this - I will often go check up Amazon before I go grocery shopping, because I am a Prime member. Shipping is fast and free. In our area, we sometimes have the option for same day shipping, and products ordered in the morning arrive later that evening. Often, two day shipping results in next-day arrivals. While Amazon isn't something I'd think of for groceries (we don't have "Fresh" in the area), there are things that it works well for -- deodorant, dog foods, that sort of thing, and where ordinarily, shipping costs would keep me from buying things online, Amazon has made that barrier go away entirely. Now I prefer to shop on Amazon wherever I can. Even if the only advantage is one less bag I have to haul from the car to the house, that's often worth it enough for me to buy on Amazon vs. brick and mortar. I won't pay more to shop on Amazon, but for things that are same cost or cheaper, it's usually the way I go, if only to justify my Prime membership.
- bostonvaulter2 15y agoI'm also a Prime member but the main reason I go with them is to reduce risk. It reduces the risk that I will by a faulty product due to the reviews and return policy and it reduces the risk that I will drive to a store and be unable to buy what I originally came for which may necessitate another trip. I also use Amazon for "groceries" just not fresh ones. In the past I've bought snacks, ramen, and peanuts from them.
- MaxGabriel 15y agoThere are great reasons to have Prime like carrying in less groceries, but it's irrational to buy at Amazon to justify your Prime membership because doing so doesn't provide you any additional benefit.
- greyfade 15y agoYes, it does. The added discounts, added features (free video streaming, free MP3s from time to time, free 2-day shipping, occasional free ebooks), and convenience more than make up for the membership cost. It's irrational not to use Amazon when you're a Prime member.
- sliverstorm 15y agoAlthough, one thing that I certainly don't miss from when I was a Prime subscriber- all the boxes, and associated guilt.
- greyfade 15y agoI stopped feeling that way when I hauled another load of boxes out to the recycling bin the other day.
- sliverstorm 15y agoOh, I recycle them, but Prime encouraged me to make individual purchases of what were often tiny items. So, I knew I was using way more box than I ought. Remember, recycling is not perfect. It takes energy, and unlike metals and glass, often the recycled material cannot be reused the same way. As a raw material, it has degraded in quality and utility.
- brianobush 15y agoI used to be on prime, but now just subscribe to items. If you subscribe to many items amazon usually does a really good job sending them out in a single box for any particular month.
- dangrossman 15y agoWhile I've been a Prime subscriber for a few years and do order plenty of things from Amazon, I'm still pretty picky about what I buy from them. Almost universally, items under $25 that ship free with Prime are more expensive than on other websites and in local stores. Especially as you get into sub-$10 items I'd normally get at a grocery store or Wal-Mart/Target/etc. The shipping cost is being built into the price. Stuff that's sub-$10 is either not offered with Prime shipping at all, or is only sold in non-discounted multi-packs. For example, say you need some deodorant. Amazon will gladly sell you some Old Spice Classic... but only in a pack of 6 for $18. I can buy just one at a store for $2.50 or so.
- encoderer 15y agoIn our household, my wife and I are professionals, no kids, quite a large percentage of disposable income and not such a large percentage of disposable time. We have a line item on the budget specifically to outsource things that make sense to outsource. Housekeeping, dog walking, uber cabs, taskrabbits, etc. That's the value of Prime for us. When we need a pack of double-A batteries. Or Listerine. Or razor blades. Whatever it may be. It's a matter of supreme convenience and time-save for us to be able to just click, click, click, done. Especially so because our car sits in the garage most of the time. We can't just pop into target on our way home from work on the train. It would be a separate, special trip just for whatever little thing we need.
- Lewisham 15y agoEven for some goods which are more expensive, once you add in Sales Tax (although that'll be solved soon enough) and gas for the car, and especially a quick time is money calculation, I would bet Amazon is cheaper overall every time.
- nazgulnarsil 15y agodon't forget increased risk of dying. driving is the most dangerous activity most people do daily.
- timbre 15y agoI don't think it's fair to say the author missed this. He seems to be asking precisely if this is the strategy, and if so how well it's working. > Is that Amazon’s real goal with the Kindle -- is Amazon in the device business only to sell Prime subscriptions, which the company sees as a key accelerant for sales across the rest of its site? And if that’s the case, how well is that circuitous business model working out? Is the Kindle helping to sell Prime? And are those Kindle-fueled Prime subscriptions moving more sales across the rest of the company’s inventory?
- graeme 15y agoThat's a good point. I should have said that I think the author missed the implications of increased Prime subscriptions. The fact that other people made comments similar to mine tells me that the author's post read as though he hadn't thought through the long run advantages to having prime members, and how average people (and not just the author) are likely to behave once they realize they can get almost anything shipped to their door. However, you're correct that he did show awareness that this might be amazon's strategy. If he wrote more on this specific point, he might actually agree with everything said here, but have some other doubts we haven't addressed. Who knows.
- timfrietas 15y agoIf prime were available here, I would rarely go into a store except for groceries. Of course, in the Seattle area Amazon offers those, too: http://fresh.amazon.com/ http://fresh.amazon.com/
- BryanB55 15y agoI do the same thing, prime is great. One thing that does make me feel a bit guilty about it though is the amount of packaging wasted when I'm constantly ordering all of these things from Amazon. I usually have a couple boxes stacked up every week, even if it is just a few small items ordered sporadically throughout the month they usually ship in a box about 8x10"... That's a lot of cardboard being used now compared to going to the store... At least that's what is seems like, I haven't actually measured the amount of gasoline and plastic or paper bags used when buying locally. Regardless though, Prime still seems like a great business model if it is working for Amazon. Every time I have to order something online that Amazon doesn't carry I always feel like I'm going back to the stone age having to pay $20 for 4 day shipping.