3 ms·
Not trying to knock the progress here, impressive. As a drummer, 'drum solo' is about as boring as it gets and some weird interspersing sounds. So, it depends o
by gregorvand 3y ago
Not trying to knock the progress here, impressive.
As a drummer, 'drum solo' is about as boring as it gets and some weird interspersing sounds. So, it depends on the intended audience.
FWIW the sound effects also are not 'realistic' to my ear, at the moment.
But again, the progress is huge, well done!
- toxik 3y agoYeah the drum solo really highlights how badly the model missed the point in a drum solo. I'm not a drummer, but this is just not pleasing to hear. Sounds like somebody randomly banging drums more or less in tempo. It does okay with muzak-type things though, which I guess tracks with my expectations.
- ZoomZoomZoom 3y agoAs a drummer, the 'drum solo` was surprisingly interesting to listen to, if you consider it happening over a stable 4/4 pulse. The random-but-not-quite nature of the part makes for very unconventional rhythmic patterns. I'd like to be able to syncopate like this on the spot. Don't ask me to transcribe it. Tempo consistency is great. Extraneous noises and random cymbal tails show the deficiency of the model though.
- redman25 3y agoI think I was more disappointed by the music samples not having any transitions. Most songs have key changes and percussion turnovers.
- pier25 3y agoI agree. It's an impressive effort but it's still very far from being able to generate viable music/sound. There are already millions of library music tracks and sound effects available which sound a lot better. It's going to take a huge investment in gen AI to compete with that and I don't think it makes economic sense (unlike text or images).