3 ms·
This is a problem, agreed, but I’m not sure if it’s the problem with iOS devices. I doubt that being able to install Linux on their iPhones would address many
by lxgr 3y ago
This is a problem, agreed, but I’m not sure if it’s the problem with iOS devices.
I doubt that being able to install Linux on their iPhones would address many of the complaints against Apple: Many people do like using iOS, after all, just not Apple’s tight control over (sandboxes!) application-layer software running on it.
For example, I use a Mac, and I’d be furious if Apple were to prevent sideloading of unsigned binaries there on macOS, even though I could always run Asahi Linux (using an officially blessed bootloader signature path).
- anfilt 3y agoThe thing is via Asahi Linux you could use it to boot a modified version of MacOS that would allow sideloading in this scenario. The ability for you to still do that is there even if more difficult. A full locked down boot rom takes that right away altogether unless you can find a bug in the process to jail break it. This is why locked down hardware is such a problem in my honest opinion. My point being apple should not have the right of exclusion after they sell the hardware. The owner should. Apple does not have to make the OS easy to side load on because modern copyright is it's own mess. If the boot rom is completely locked down they are violating your property rights. Further if the owner has access to the keys of their boot ROM they still have ultimate say. Now to take full advantage of that it may not be easy since it's low level code, but you could still take advantage of code some else wrote in such an instance, and considering how popular apple devices someone probably will. Heck jail breaks exist and a lot people applying them never have written such code themselves. They just want to get out the box apple put them in to customize things and install other software.
- lxgr 3y ago> via Asahi Linux you could use it to boot a modified version of MacOS that would allow sideloading in this scenario. [...] Further if the owner has access to the keys of their boot ROM they still have ultimate say. Not if they use attestation! Locking down the bootloader and being able to implement DRM in a hardware-assisted sandbox supporting attestation are largely orthogonal. You can have full hardware access to your OS, but the measurements would still differ depending on how you kick off your boot chain, and Apple could just refuse to deliver certain iOS features to you on a modified OS.
- Ajedi32 3y agoCorrect, I'm not just talking about alternative OSs. I specifically had application-layer software in mind when I wrote that comment. iOS prevents users from installing applications or app stores not approved (digitally signed) by Apple. Solve that problem, and Apple wouldn't have any leverage to force application developers to pay per-install in the first place.