5 ms·
I really hope this keeps being optional because otherwise a lot of the authentic value of the videos will be lost. Also, the demo they showed looked like it was
by vasco 15y ago
I really hope this keeps being optional because otherwise a lot of the authentic value of the videos will be lost. Also, the demo they showed looked like it was algorithmically deteriorated to make the change more noticeable. There's shaky hands and then there's parkinsons-level shaking which was what the demo showed...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 15y agoOf course it's optional. You can choose to apply it in the editor if you wish, and can vary how much shaking is removed.
- delinka 15y ago"...algorithmically deteriorated..." Or the person holding the camera was shaking like mad to demonstrate the abilities of the algorithm. Artistically speaking, shake removal is also authenticity removal. But most times, personal videos are shot by people with no eye for framing and stability. And most times, artistic (and professionals) videos are shot with an eye toward these things. I can't foresee a reason not to keep this feature as an option rather than enforcing it on all uploads.
- leviathan 15y agoIf you look carefully, the shakes appear too uniform to be a person shaking the camera. It looks like the camera always "shakes" in a circular motion around the center of the original camera location.
- agumonkey 15y agoProbably a staged setup, inducing a regular shaking pattern, but I think generating rolling shutter algorithmicly would be a stretch for them, so I call physical but maybe voluntary shake.
- platz 15y agoOr maybe it's due to the 'rolling' shutter causing shear stretching as mentioned in the article
- agumonkey 15y agoBut the point is that if they faked shaking algorithmically then the original signal would be shear-free right ?
- kami8845 15y agoit's much easier to record it without much shake and then maximize the effect of their algorithm after the fact instead of recording a bunch of versions with varying degrees of shake. They completely overdid it in my opinion, the example doesn't seem authentic at all to me (though the technology remains cool)
- thrownaway2424 15y agoHaven't you ever seen the Zapruder film?
- sp332 15y agoSometimes you want authentic value, and sometimes motion sickness isn't what you were aiming for in your video. This gives video makers more tools to express their vision. Edit: also what's new here isn't the stabilization, it's that they will fix "rolling shutter" artifacts in each frame as well. Rolling shutter is something photographers generally dislike.
- hmottestad 15y agoIf they used a telephoto lens then the shaking would be much more noticeable. Also the motion hints at someone actually attempting to correct for the movements, but because it's zoomed so far in every movement to counteract the shaking is greatly magnified.