5 ms·
RIP Checkbox, 1990-2009, you were perfect and unambiguous but for some reason smartphone designers hated you.
by bee_rider 3y ago
RIP Checkbox, 1990-2009, you were perfect and unambiguous but for some reason smartphone designers hated you.
- _0ffh 3y agoRight, or use a 3D look or colour or backlight effect to indicate when a toggle is active.
- denton-scratch 3y agoI agree that checkboxes are perfect; but that's because I never try to fill forms on a smartphone. Native browser checkboxes are often unusable on smartphones; too small to hit with a thumb.
- lowboy 3y agoThe checkbox label is often my thumb’s target. A pox on the house of any dev who doesn’t properly use a _for_ attribute.
- bee_rider 3y agoTrue. It seems like an odd historical problem though. We could just render checkboxes bigger or with more white space around them, and make the touch area bigger in any case.
- denton-scratch 3y agoSure, you clould just fix checkboxes. But then you have to deal with select boxes, which also work badly on smartphones. Then you have the modern smartphone-driven practice of using multipart forms, with one field on each part. You can't see the whole form at once; you eventually find out that the very last field is a date-field with three badly-behaved drop-downs that you can't interact with. I just don't try to fill forms on my smartphone. In fact I only use it as a (shock!) phone.
- mywittyname 3y agoProperly designed, the tapping/clicking the text should also trigger the checkbox.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> Properly designed It shouldn't need designing; but I have a suspicion that an unstyled HTML checkbox input doesn't behave like that.
- pfg_ 3y agoIt does as long as you mark the label as being for the checkbox or put the checkbox inside the label, which you are supposed to do.
- wolverine876 3y agoThen it triggers when I scroll - there's no place to click/tap safely. And worse, it can toggle and then scroll off the screen before I notice. Then I end up signed up for their marketing emails! :) Seriously, why not bigger checkboxes?
- kqr 3y agoThis is extra silly because you can make what's effectively a checkbox look really nice and toggle-y. Although this is a bad example it shows that it doesn't have to be a square with a check mark in it: https://www.ranecommercial.com/legacy/hal/MobileHelp/Advanced/Content/Resources/Images/DialogBoxImages/WebControls_ToggleControlBase.png https://www.ranecommercial.com/legacy/hal/MobileHelp/Advance...
- hombre_fatal 3y agoSwitches are already ubiquitous on mobile UIs: https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/toggles https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline... But checkboxes and switches don't always make sense. You don't always have room for e.g. "Light mode <switch>". Every component that you give more room to takes room away from other UI. Rather than look at the obvious cases, the hard part is the periphery of what's obvious.
- alonsonic 3y agoIssue is that modern UX designed moved away from this type of 3D buttons. There was a big transition from UIs using heavy skeuomorphism to a more flat and digital look. To achieve hat you're showing you need some depth to the button. Hard to accomplish with today's design trends.
- AlienRobot 3y agoIt's things like this that make me think the way to make a good UI is to look at what modern UIs do and do the exact opposite. 1. No spacing. 2. Information-heavy cluttered screens. 3. No auto-save. You have to click the save button to save. 4. Colored icons. Colored interfaces. Not "tinted" a hue of black or white. Actual vibrant colors. And not just one color either! Two colors, at least. 5. 3d. 6. Main menus. 7. border-style: ridge;
- FridgeSeal 3y agoPeak UX design was the WinAmp and Windows media player skins of the Windows XP era. They exhibit almost all of these properties, and they were glorious to use.
- pera 3y agoWho created the checkbox widget? System 1 (1984) had check marks on the menu and "x boxes", which are equivalent, but not checkboxes afaik
- bee_rider 3y agoI actually have no idea, I made up 1990 completely, I bet it is way too late. In any case, I guess it is just the digitization of an existing UI element from paper forms, right?
- Someone 3y ago> System 1 (1984) had check marks on the menu and "x boxes", which are equivalent, but not checkboxes afaik I think it had (https://andymatuschak.org/files/papers/Apple%20Human%20Interface%20Guidelines%201987.pdf https://andymatuschak.org/files/papers/Apple%20Human%20Inter..., page 56) I don’t know whether those were the first, but https://skeuomorphic.design/p/from-paper-ballots-to-pixels-tracing https://skeuomorphic.design/p/from-paper-ballots-to-pixels-t... claims they were, in the sense that the Mac made radio buttons different from toggle buttons. Does anybody know in what cultures a checkmark would be inappropriate, as that page claims?
- pera 3y agoThanks, that's a nice pdf: so what I called "x boxes" were actually named "check boxes" (although they didn't use the check mark symbol)
- silon42 3y agoHere are some samples from 1987... (CUA standard) http://toastytech.com/guis/cua1987.html http://toastytech.com/guis/cua1987.html
- klabb3 3y agoYes obviously, because checkboxes need accompanying text, otherwise it’s just a mystery fidget. Text on a small screen is a problem for obvious reasons. The you have the second problem: checkboxes were part of web forms, where you have a submit button. So a whole generation of users were taught the abstraction of “saving” your settings as an explicit gotcha step. The checkbox didn’t do anything on its own. Very likely, Apple wanted to start over with an element that was independent and immediate, in their preference panes. But checkboxes would have worked too, in preferences – but does not solve the in-app problem: The icon toggle buttons are not mobile designers faults – they existed way earlier, primarily known from text editors (think the bold/italics toggles). Who messed them up so badly, I don’t know..
- 83457 3y agoA medical video conference / telehealth system my provider uses has broken the checkbox. In their direct message interface they change the checkbox field label based on whether the box is checked. Unchecked has the label as "Not Urgent" and checked is "Urgent". On multiple occasions I have quickly checked the box, to indicated as not urgent, then clicked send.
- bee_rider 3y agoAt some point bad design becomes almost an art form
- xnx 3y agoIs Jony Ive the Thomas Midgley Jr of the design world? Jony is responsible for iOS 7 which popularized low-usability flat design, as well as the circular iMac mouse and the Macbook's fragile keyboards.