4 ms·
>They're deliberately forgoing those options and deleting it. You don't have a loss until you attempt to generate revenue and find that the revenue is less than
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
>They're deliberately forgoing those options and deleting it. You don't have a loss until you attempt to generate revenue and find that the revenue is less than your expenses. If you just throw your product away, that's not a loss.
That is exactly how it works. You already spent X on an asset. If you throw the asset away, then you just have deductible expenses.
Same for the widget factory. You can deduct the material and factory expense of making of making defective widgets. If you trash them, you write down the value of your assets.
>But we shouldn't have a tax law that does that, because that's a huge waste of society's resources (materials for the widgets, fuel for the incinerator, people's time and labor).
This is the crux of things. Those arent society's resources, and never were. They are resources of the warner Bros and the widget factory.
Tax law isnt and shouldn't be about forcing people to do what you want. If someone wants to waste their time and resources, that is their choice.
It seems like this whole thread is people angry that they dont own the property of others, and get to control them.
- imgabe 3y agoNobody is stopping them from wasting their time and resources. They are free to waste them as much as they want. It's just not a tax-deductible business expense to do so. There is a difference between "we won't allow you to do something" vs. "we won't subsidize you to do something". It's one thing to want to waste your resources, it's another thing to demand that everyone else pay you to do so. What's to stop the CEO from building a mansion with the company's resources and selling it to himself for $1? Then having the company write it off as a loss? Oops! It was just a bad business decision and the company lost money. Oh well! We can't stop them from wasting their resources if they want to!
- s1artibartfast 3y agoFundamental to the whole premise of taxes is that they are applied to net profit. If a company spends $1 to make $10, they get taxed on $9. If they spend $8 to make $10, they get taxed on $2. Nobody is giving warner bros money. They arent getting a cash tax refund. They just spent more money and made less profit. If they wanted to make zero profit, and pay zero taxes, that is their choice! If a commpany wants to sell houses at a loss, that is legal, and happens all the time. If they are self dealing, the shareholders could have an issue with it, or the IRS if the CEO doesn't report it. Guess what, Companies DO give CEOs many millions of dollars of salary and stock. Every bit of that is tax deductible expense for the company. >Oh well! We can't stop them from wasting their resources if they want to! It is literally none of your business because they aren't your resources! It is like complaining your neighbors have fun on Sunday instead of working and paying more taxes.
- imgabe 3y ago> Fundamental to the whole premise of taxes is that they are applied to net profit. If a company spends $1 to make $10, they get taxed on $9. If they spend $8 to make $10, they get taxed on $2. Yes, the key word there is net profit, and the ways to calculate net profit for tax purposes are prescribed by law. Not every single penny a company spends is automatically a deductible business expense. Some things are, some things partially are, some have to be amortized over time, some are not deductible at all. There's thousands of pages of tax law delineating this and it is not in the slightest without precedent to declare a particular expense non-deductible.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSo there is a moral argument for what an ideal world should be like, and legal argument for what the rules are. From the moral perspective, it is clear that WB clearly had real expenses. They spent money, bought rights, and tons of workers were paid good money. Now you pivot to the legal argument. The current law clearly supports what Warner Bros is doing, so that doesnt help you either. like I said before. It seems like this entire thing boils down to a control issue. you dont like how WB is running their company and doing with their property. It isnt you business, both figuratively and literally.
- imgabe 3y ago> From the moral perspective, it is clear that WB clearly had real expenses. They spent money, bought rights, and tons of workers were paid good money. Yes, they had expenses. You seem to have a very very rudimentary understanding of accounting and have conflated expenses with losses. An expense is not a loss. If you buy a factory for $1 million, you didn't lose $1 million dollars. You now have an asset, a factory, that is worth approximately $1 million. You don't get to go to the IRS and say "I lost $1 million dollars this year because I bought a factory". The IRS will tell you, no you didn't. You still have your $1 million, it's just now in the form of a factory instead of cash. Likewise, WB spent money and created an asset, a film. That film has a market value. Maybe they don't like the film, but that doesn't change the reality that it's worth something. We know approximately how much it's worth because several other companies made offers to buy it. Instead WB wants to lie and say it isn't worth anything. So, no I don't like how they are running their company when they want to lie and cheat to get out of paying the taxes they owe. You can't buy a factory for $1 million and then turn around and say "yeah, it's not worth anything anymore", and you shouldn't be able to say a movie isn't worth anything when it very clearly is. We do not gain anything by enabling companies or anyone to deny reality.
- arpa 3y agoMaybe at some size corporations _should_ become public entities to avoid dragon disease and only those corporations having the means of production. After all, they did grow enormously big by consuming public resources and labor.
- MrNeon 3y agoNeither the resources or the labor are public.
- Applejinx 3y agoTaxation is literally and entirely about wresting resources from individuals to serve the larger needs of a society that individuals are unlikely to address. It's literally there to serve infrastructure and rebalancing needs without which the individuals end up sitting in ruined playpens, drowning in their own filth and unable to do commerce with anybody else. Never mind about when the 'individual' is a corporate entity that rightly or wrongly thinks itself obligated to chase the most ruinous short-term strategy it can find, as a matter of fiduciary duty. That just exaggerates what already happens with ambitious human individuals. Tax law is only and solely about forcing people to do what you want, starting with the very concept that people will never want long term thinking or cooperation in any significant way. (in fact, people will want cooperation, but sociopaths, human or corporate, will tend to stomp all over the cooperation-wanting people, wreck their stuff, then want a tax write-off because the stuff they wrecked is now broken)