3 ms·
As a general rule human notions of "efficiency" that lead to straightening water channels, draining wetlands, clearing mangroves, replacing river basins with co
by defrost 3y ago
As a general rule human notions of "efficiency" that lead to straightening water channels, draining wetlands, clearing mangroves, replacing river basins with concrete, etc have downsides that can often be severe down the track a few decades.
Every specific case is a bit different, of course.
That said, removing a meander can improve boat navigation, but it reduces total water contact with shore line interface, filtering effect of weeds, opportunities for water way animal breeding locations, increases flow rates, etc.
The downsides can be loss of habitat and species, more polluted water, faster water in flood times leading to stronger gouging effects, banks bursting etc.
Wetland habitats clean and filter water, near the ocean and large lakes they reduce storm surges, etc.
Where rivers drain into oceans or lakes with different water properties (oceans have higher salt levels) banking at the river mouth reduces backwash from the larger body up into the river and preserves the distinct water types which can benefit fish species, water based plants and animals, etc.
It's a swings and roundabouts problem domain.
- bomewish 3y agoI love HN.
- dylan604 3y agoI love how LA just paved its river, and then questions why there's so much run off. Like, where did you expect the water to go when you've paved everything? My city got tired of the river flooding the downtown area, so decided to reroute the river. Of course, they made it much straighter than it would naturally form. So nearly a century later, they started to go back and add in bends and areas for the water to pool in areas. It has done a lot in a positive direction.
- nimbius 3y agothe US at the start of the 20th century was sort of a shit-wreck of works projects to impose manifest destiny on whatever part of nature that happened to irk us that day. the LA river is what it is today for the same reason anzo borrego has no more natural water, the salton sea is a boiling chemical pit, and the east coast was a toxic dump up until the nineties with things like the love canal projects. The river flooded in 1938, tearing out bridges and trestles. It killed more than 100 people, trapped movie stars on their San Fernando Valley ranches, and forced a three-day delay in the Oscars. The water tore away the Warner Brothers studio’s prop department. That flood wrote the real river’s death warrant. It was the Depression; L.A. needed jobs, not a killer river. The river was timbered and troughed and cemented over, mile after mile. Only in parts of its 51-mile bed would it assert itself and remain persistently unpaveable: for about three miles around Atwater Village, and along more than two miles at the broad reach of the Sepulveda dam wildlife area. It took 20 years and 3.5 million barrels of cement, and now we have a paved river as a testament to the hubris of man. fwiw, it did not solve the floods this year.
- bglazer 3y agoThis is very well written and the last paragraph really drives home what a disaster this is
- card_zero 3y agoSeem needlessly harsh to humans, is there some less hubristic animal? The other animals don't even know the word, and they'd pave over rivers too if they even were capable of having bad ideas, I mean it's not like beavers or termites are exercising wise restraint.
- defrost 3y agoBeavers are arguably beneficial to the bigger picture in their area, they don't make concreate waterways, they make large shallow lakes with lots of boggy areas. Hellish for humans to walk about and navigate, sure. Very good for temperature stabilisations, wetland life, water retention in areas that would otherwise drain and dry out, etc.
- card_zero 3y agoDefinitely, beavers are excellent, but not on purpose. When we say "human hubris" we're thinking of ourselves as bad for being able to think of things. Bacteria, by comparison, cause less havoc, but that's because their activities are limited by what's evolutionarily adaptive. They caused a mass extinction once, but that was a couple of billion years ago. None of the other creatures are being deliberately good. Neither are humans, on the whole, but at least it troubles our minds sometimes.
- xkcd-sucks 3y agoAlso arguably bad in some places they're edging out the locals (South America) or contributing to greenhouse gas emissions (the warming Arctic), if you believe in "invasive species" (some people don't)
- lazide 3y ago
- metabagel 3y agoThe L.A. River was paved before WW2. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-03-01/why-we-turned-the-la-river-into-a-freeway-for-water https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-03-01/why-we-t... For some time now, Los Angeles and Orange County have been in the process of adding soil and plants to the bottoms of the concrete channels. Here’s the website for the L.A. river revitalization. https://lariver.org/ https://lariver.org/