5 ms·
The loss of things I took for granted
- aszantu 3y agotapped out at "Motivated by bigotry", good luck with whatever you're fighting for
- antod 3y agoI wonder if they included that pretty much irrelevant book banning bit at the beginning to prove their point about people being unable to concentrate long enough to actually read anything? Nah, probably not. If you had read further, it was mainly about a bunch of other stuff. I can't really remember what though, so I'm proving their point too.
- jprd 3y agoNot banning books? Which, at least in modern history, has always been fueled by bigotry? I'm not sure that was a super opinionated take considering the subject, and I'm not sure I can think of another motivating factor unless you are scared of knowledge in general. The Church attacking Galileo was bigotry. It is kind of a thing. Do you feel there are other good-faith reasons that justify these efforts? Are you just frustrated at hearing that word?
- User23 3y agoGalileo was like an employee who publicly and loudly called the CEO of the most powerful NGO in his country and that his company got rules and procedures from, in the parlance of our times, a fucking idiot. Bigotry wasn’t the issue.
- umvi 3y agoThere's a difference between banning things (including books) for use in schools and the federal government declaring certain books illegal. We are dealing mostly with the former here. California doesn't want its schools reading Huck Finn and To Kill a Mocking Bird, Florida doesn't want its schools reading Gender Queer. Anyway, that's all mostly a red herring. There's nothing stopping kids in either state from going to a public library to check them out and read them.
- FireBeyond 3y agoIf the books are banned in school, if teachers are forbidden from mentioning them, do you think the number of kids who know of their existence to go up, or down? That's not to mention that, emboldened by their success in school libraries in some areas, these same people are now going after public libraries, too.
- Kye 3y agoThey're coming for the libraries, too.
- taway_6PplYu5 3y ago> There's a difference between banning things (including books) for use in schools and the federal government declaring certain books illegal. Perhaps. But there is a law in Florida making it a felony for the teacher to have that book in the classroom.
- umvi 3y agoThat does seem heavy handed. But think of it this way - how would you feel if your elementary schooler's teacher had a prominent copy of "Mein Kampf" in their classroom and told any kids who enquired about it to read it when they were older because it is one of their favorite books? I personally wouldn't have a problem with it since I know that simply reading a book does not a Nazi make. But some parents might understandably object to that and agitate for laws of the land to ban that. And if you are highly religious as Florida (apparently) is, books like "Gender Queer" teach principles that are diametrically opposed to your religious beliefs (namely that the nuclear family is God's approved way of rearing a family, gender is not a social construct but an immutable piece of identity ingrained into your soul, etc.)
- FireBeyond 3y ago> how would you feel if your elementary schooler's teacher had a prominent copy of "Mein Kampf" in their classroom and told any kids who enquired about it to read it when they were older because it is one of their favorite books? I personally wouldn't have a problem with it since I know that simply reading a book does not a Nazi make. There's a difference between espousing a principle of "the more you read, the better your education", and "Mein Kampf is my favorite book". Given how badly it is actually written, and the central theme is "Adolf Hitler: How I Became An Antisemite", I'd wager that the union of people who see it as a favorite book AND are not neonazi antisemites is almost infinitesimally small.
- aszantu 3y agothere's probably reasons to ban these books. Banned because of bigotry doesn't really go deep there and it's trying to prime my opinion is what I believe.
- snakeyjake 3y agoFrom "Of Mice and Men" to "Maus" to "any book even slightly uncritical of LGTB youth" every book ban has been motivated by bigotry. They may cloak their bigotry in morality or patriotism or whatever but it's still bigotry.
- Kye 3y agoPeople are often surprised to learn one of those famous Nazi book burning photos was of the collection at the era's equivalent of a queer center. That fact is rarely conveyed along with the narratives about censorship that go with it. It's an example of how even being factual can be misleading. It's a fact that they were Nazis doing censorship, but the facts that are omitted reveal a lot about who's sharing it: either they don't know, or they don't want you to know.
- phoe-krk 3y agoLet's play devil's advocate for a moment. Reading used to be necessary, since most of media was produced in written form, therefore consuming any sort of media mandated the ability to read it. In the video-centric world of 21st century, where most media is produced and consumed on television and Internet via visuals and spoken language, why do you even need to be able to read? What's the need that the ability to read would resolve that cannot be resolved in other, simpler and/or more rewarding ways?
- fifticon 3y agoI was going to reply, but ipython wrote it already, better. However, understanding his reply requires the ability to read it correctly. Notice that we are not having the hackernews discussions as a long list of small video clips. People who have not learned to read on a professional level, have a hard time grasping the volume, depth and speed with which you can transfer knowledge through text, using that developed skill. It is trivially true that a person who has not learned to read well, learns faster by watching videos. But this is not an argument for videos being the most capable mechanism, only the more initially accessible. You may be able to start running before I can saddle my horse, but once it is saddled, my horse will outrun your running start. There is obviously areas in which video, 3d and computer systems/models surpass what a book can present, but outside those areas, the information in the world belongs to books,or the computer equivalent thereof. It is not about old books. It is about that written text is our strongest tool yet to present and capture a large connected set of ideas into a consistent argument, and similarly to RECEIVE such an argument. If you think a youtube video will do 'just as well', you probably need to read some more books :-) At work, I dread whenever I have to develop software for which I cant find written documentation, but must rely on random youtube guides sketchily explaining bits of it like and subscribe.
- fifticon 3y agoI have a further, simpler argument. Movies. Ever notice that movie adaptations of books often suck? Well, there are some that don't. When shortstories are made into movies, it often works better. This is because the amount of content that fits in a shortstory, matches with what you can cover in a 90minute movie. If you try to communicate the contents of a book that takes 8 hours to read,to video, that video will be much longer than 8 hours. So, yes, possibly, you could turn your 8 hour reading assignment into a 40 hour video watching assignment. However, I don't know how you will manage your note-taking, now that you have given up on reading? Abandoning reading is abandoning our ability to organise and maintain knowledge, which we do with words and letters assembled and grasped with ability.
- Scubabear68 3y agoI agree phones and Covid play a big part in reading ability decline. But the last reason mentioned is a big one too. Curriculums have moved away from proven teaching techniques into psuedo science at the same time public schools focus less and less on teaching, and more on being social institutions. Moving away from phonics, dumbing down math, practically ignoring science. Coupled with the increasingly common practice of grade inflation, kids are hitting college woefully unprepared. The best decision my wife and I have made in our lives was to get our kids into private school 18 months ago. The difference is like night and day.
- couchand 3y agoThis hasn't been our experience. Our public school kids are learning things we never would have dreamed of at their age. I distinctly remember being surpised at the worksheets on platonic solids that my kindergartener was assigned.
- whoknowsidont 3y agoI'd be interested to know where you live vs where the parent poster lives.
- Scubabear68 3y agoYes, location is everything. I live in NJ in the United States. Public schools here are all over the place, housing prices in towns with good school districts is remarkably higher than those with poor ones. Sadly we live in a town with a poor one.
- flerchin 3y agoThis has been my experience too. Educational standards are _not lower_ for math and reading than they were when I attended American public schools a generation ago. (by definition, because my children are in it now.)
- adamhartenz 3y agoThis comment definitely sounds like someone yelling at the clouds. The fact it starts with "I agree" is a red flag. These are stats and facts that can be looked up. There is nothing to "agree" or "disagree" with. We know that reading for kids (an adults) increased by a significant amount during lockdowns. We know that kids write and read a lot more, in the form of social messages to friends using there phone than any previous generation. We know that the world in changed, and these young kids are kinder, and more socially aware than any of us ever were. Our generation is all about written communication, but for them, video chat is a new normal. That could be in the workplace, but also social media. Short form videos have completely replaced what we used to do on message boards or forums. That is for the general population though. The top academics are doing just as good or better than the top academics from any other older generations. Even though it seems like the Flynn Effect tells us otherwise, that is not the whole story. Anyway. I am always skeptical of old people saying anything negative about younger generations. Because it almost always turns out to be untrue.
- inSenCite 3y agoI wonder how much of this is the same/different across the world. Are academics seeing the same behavioural pattern in emea / apac?
- happytiger 3y agoI think this professor has lot the plot by pinning this most recent decline on COVID and whatnot. This has been a much longer decline. The pandemic and social media on phones are not the reason long form content is dying, though if one of those is to bear responsibility it would be social media. But it’s the death of individual passion in the teaching professions at the lower grade levels that is the direct result of common core that has a major, ongoing role in the disengagement of students from school. It’s remarkable to sit and work with my teenagers on their homework these days. Almost all of their assignments are readily referenced online in common flash cards and study guides, and so much of the homework is droll repetition. But what strikes me is that there is no relief like there was in my time. There is no “now read chapters 3-7 of this book” in any of her homework. The passages, when there is reading, is assigned by packet and accompanied by some packaged lesson that requires you to fill in the blanks on the point of the reading, it’s key characters, and it’s learned themes and elements. It is perfect educational material put together by panels of experts and crafted to achieve the highest standardized level of understanding for most students. And it’s incredibly, sincerely uninspiring and frequently boring. I often spend time with my kids talking to them about subjects like ancient history, philosophy, writing, poetry, math and science in ways that are stimulating and it’s a constant refrain, “I wish school were this interesting.” We pick a theme a few times a week for dinner and have discussions with friends and family on that subject. Recently this has included subjects like demographics, geology, quantum mechanics, deep space research, sustainable energy, etc. Anyone can pick the subject. School fails to be interesting, and we are in one of the better schools in our area. The kids are bored to tears and the format of school is incredibly unpleasant for kids that actually want to learn. This school won’t even let the kids take college classes and apply them, despite being less than five minutes from a UC and 20 minutes from a junior college. They can’t give me a good explanation as to why: they just say it’s against their policy. So, we do our best to keep kids interested in reading and learning, but it’s fighting against their mandatory education to do so. And I really think the school, despite their best efforts, is failing these kids. And I blame common core. More than anything else. When I sit down with teachers the better of them confide sometimes that they are really not happy with how they have to teach, but they have to teach that way and have little flexibility in customizing things in their classrooms. They have become “presenters” of material developed far away in academic laboratories, and while they are still teaching they are far removed from any innovation in curriculum. And without that control, they really aren’t able to overcome the gigantic bureaucracy of the educational apparatus.
- vages 3y agoThis trend seems to have no borders. Norwegian students are worse at math, reading comprehension and science than ever: https://www-nrk-no.translate.goog/nyheter/pisa-undersokelsen_-darligste-matteresultat-malt-i-norge-1.16665354?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en-US&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://www-nrk-no.translate.goog/nyheter/pisa-undersokelsen... The pandemic, “studying for the test” and smartphones are the three most common scapegoats here too. A summary of the situation can be found in this (paywalled) article: https://www.morgenbladet.no/aktuelt/kommentar/2023/12/15/hvem-drepte-den-norske-skolen/ https://www.morgenbladet.no/aktuelt/kommentar/2023/12/15/hve... My money is on technology or other global causes. The decline started before the pandemic, and a decline in many countries at once cannot be attributed to Norwegian government policies.