4 ms·
RSS is still pretty great
- kevincox 3y ago> For example, there is really no way to tell aggregators that you changed an article's path. Of course there is, just change the URL. Both Atom and RSS have the concept of an "entry ID" which should never change, but anything else in the entry can just be updated (other than the published date I guess). However this is easy to misunderstand because in RSS it is optional and in Atom people frequently use the URL as the ID and then accidently change that URL which according to the protocol is actually creating a new set of entries unrelated to the old ones. In fact in the author's case it is very likely if they added items back to their feed with the old ID and new URL Feedly would update it. Although there is no way to undo duplicates and you shouldn't add back an entry that was removed from the feed (as it will appear new to subscribers that didn't know about the entry previously).
- 6510 3y agoNever change the article path without a redirect. If I honor you with a well deserved link to your article in a section that requires the context, insights and perspective you provide it should not be made into a mistake to be avoided next time. I should not have to do the work for you - because I wont.
- vdaea 3y agoThat's why when I write something that I think will be read for years to come I use archive links to link to other pages.
- 6510 3y agoI keep thinking I should archive everything but only link to it if the target goes missing. Could check every time it is clicked or scan for dead links. For a while I put magnet links under youtube videos. Got a mail from someone looking for a video for a long time. He found many pages with the deleted video on them, including mine.
- aendruk 3y agoYou’re preaching about the wrong issue. Arranging an HTTP redirect on your server won’t deduplicate records with mismanaged IDs in the aggregator.
- ho4 3y agoRSS is great and I can't imagine what my life would've been if I were to scan the news feeds on each individual site that I have included in my RSS feed. However, the text rendering feature is rather useless for the resources that are greedy for views, clicks and other analytics, as they simply truncate the body of the article, leaving you no choice but to open the original url to read the rest of it. For my use case in particular, a full title is enough, but I was rather bummed initially that the promised "read all articles rendered in the same style with no distractions that existed on the original website" never worked out.
- bazil376 3y ago>leaving you no choice but to open the original url This is auto-unsubscribe territory for me.
- adhamsalama 3y agoSome RSS readers have the ability to scrap the article in that case.
- garspin 3y ago> as they simply truncate the body of the article, leaving you no choice but to open the original url to read the rest of it Inoreader has a 'Load Full Content' button above every (shortened) feed item. It retrieves the original in full & displays it in clear text (no ads and little html formatting). I discovered the button by accidently clicking it - it's an unintuitive steaming coffee cup.
- Tomte 3y agobazqux is similar! They have a depiction of a couch prominently in the toolbar, and zero describing text. And also no documentation. I needed to open the site on the desktop to get an indication for that (as a hover text).
- corobo 3y agoI like the iOS client Unread for this. You can set it feed by feed to either display the feed content as-is or have it parse each article reader-mode slash Instapaper style and show that instead of the feed text I imagine others do this too, keep an eye out for it as a feature! Very handy :)
- peterkonsz 3y agoNo matter how much people want to proclaim RSS is "dead" there is actually no way to kill it. It is decentralized. No one owns it. If we keep publishing RSS feeds, it still lives.
- al_borland 3y agoIts death can be from sites deciding it’s no longer worth supporting, when they do a redesign. I can see this happening if a bunch of young front end devs are put in change of the full redesign. I’m currently on a project where the front end has all the control and none of them seem to know anything about computers or tech in general. It seems like they all went to an 8 week boot camp and got a job. It has been very frustrating.
- rpmisms 3y agoOn behalf of front-end devs, I'm sorry. I'm not an amazing FE dev, cut my teeth on Rails projects and weird PHP, but the lack of simple thinking in the frontend world hurts my soul. I need to switch...
- al_borland 3y agoI’m sure there are FE devs who aren’t like this, it’s just been my experience over the last 3 years. I don’t mean to be disparaging, I’m just frustrated. To add to the issues, the FE team has a dedicated QA team, we don’t have any QA for the backend, we just need to do it ourselves. But the QA team doesn’t know what they are even looking at (they’ve never spoken to us). They make sure the UI does UI things, but don’t understand the goal of what it should accomplish, so we (the backend devs) end up needing to do a significant amount of the FE QA, as what they are looking to release is just bad.
- rpmisms 3y agoNo, don't apologize, you're right. Frontend should be a junior's intro to backend, and I will advocate for this forever. Senior FE devs should be the competent ones who really like FE. > the FE team has a dedicated QA team What a headache. Should be unified.
- sliken 3y agoI have 50 or so RSS feeds, a few went stale, I thought the URL had changed. Turns out they are just not publishing. It's pretty rare to find a site I want without being able to find a RSS feed for it.
- charcircuit 3y agoTwitter addresses a bunch of the downsides of RSS that were listed. The author's criticism of Twitter seems to be that it is too easy for people to use, that it is too helpful in finding you things to read, and that if offers a way to reply to posts. These seem like a net benefit to me and if you don't want to see replies then don't click into a tweet.
- beautron 3y agoBut Twitter doesn't address many of the downsides of social media that were listed, or many of the upsides of RSS that were listed.
- Tommy430 3y ago> But Twitter doesn't address many of the downsides of social media that were listed, or many of the upsides of RSS that were listed. Seriously. You even have to log in just to view or search stuff.
- charcircuit 3y agoLogging in makes it easy to sync your feed between devices. Making account is quick and easy.
- herewulf 3y agoBut Twitter is just one website. Must we have an account at _every_ website?
- _-_-__-_-_- 3y agoI’ve used multiple rss readers over the years. I would read them for a few months and then stop because news reading would become a habit. I’ve ended up using bookmark folders in Firefox and visiting the sites I like once every few months when I can focus on them. Where rss still gets the most use from me is podcasting. It’s open and human readable and it’s great to dump an opml file into a new player or catcher and have episodes download and start listening instantly.
- gfody 3y agoI use rss for youtube and it's been great but lately a lot of "shorts" stuff has been junking up the feeds.
- al_borland 3y agoDoes this still work? This post from a couple weeks ago was saying they were down. Was this a temporary outage, not a removal? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39179446 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39179446 I like the idea of moving some of the channels I actually like to RSS.
- Hamuko 3y agoI'm subscribed to a YouTube playlist RSS feed and it last updated on Saturday.
- dugite-code 3y agoYes it still works, I use it daily. They have had a couple of instances of downtime in the last year, a lot more the Youtube itself, but still very reliable. They removed the OPML export from the subscription manager unfortunately.
- tarf 3y agoIf you're using https://newsboat.org https://newsboat.org, you can add a filter (killfile) to remedy this: ignore-article "*" "title =~ \"#shorts\"" ignore-article "*" "content =~ \"#shorts\"" Not perfect though, since it only ignores videos with hashtag '#shorts' in title or description and not all shorts includes that hashtag.
- dugite-code 3y agoBest as I can tell there is no difference between Shorts and full length videos when coming from the RSS feed. It even loads in the full player on the website when following the url. The best I've come up with is to use youtube-dl to get the duration and if it's shorter then 60s drop the item.
- 3y ago
- luuurker 3y agoI use it almost every day, mostly to follow new content. For a while I used social media (facebook, twitter, etc), but that stopped working well for me when algorithms started deciding what I was supposed to see. On top of this, the "drama" I was seeing and wasting my time on, ads, privacy concerns, etc, made leave social media and go back to RSS. For this use case, it's much better than social media, even when sites decide to only include a paragraph or two to force me to visit the website.
- senectus1 3y agoI could not be happier with my self hosted FreshRSS. It's a major way i stay in touch without having to doom scroll
- cknight 3y agoThis is what I am using, with the FeedMe app on Android so I can read wherever I am. Works well.
- acidburnNSA 3y agoWhat does FeedMe offer that's better than the freshrss mobile web view?
- heresie-dabord 3y agoWhy not provide a URL for your recommendation? https://github.com/FreshRSS/FreshRSS https://github.com/FreshRSS/FreshRSS
- tapirl 3y agoThe main problem with RSS is there might be a large quantity of (useless) traffic produced by subscribers to a personal website which is update with a low frequency. There were some services to fix this problem, but most of them have all been (deliberately) closed now.
- dugite-code 3y ago> there might be a large quantity of (useless) traffic RSS has update hints in the form of skipHours, skipDays and TTL to let clients know if you expect to be publishing regularly or not. Also most RSS feeds are just links with a tiny amount of text. A large youtube channel produces a feed file in the 30KB range for example. Unlikely you'll ever exhaust your transfer quota at any provider with that size of data. Quite easy to CDN that file as well.
- pixelesque 3y agoDoes Atom support this? It looks like it might be RSS-only?
- dugite-code 3y agoTechnically yes, although it may not be respected. > Elements from other namespaces may be included pretty much anywhere. This means that most RSS 1.0 and RSS 2.0 modules may be used in Atom. https://validator.w3.org/feed/docs/atom.html#extensibility https://validator.w3.org/feed/docs/atom.html#extensibility I believe this wasn't included because you can just set the Expires header on the web server to control cache times.
- tapirl 3y agoSome RSS clients just ignore the hints.
- graeme 3y agoFor anyone not using rss and wondering whether to get into it and how, this is what worked for me over the past year. I used to have 4-6 sites I would check regularly. A couple occasionally had a news update article I liked reading. A couple were “firehose” sites for a hobby which produced 4-20 articles per day. Hard to keep up with on web without feeling overwhelmed. I got NetNewsWire which has a good sync system across machines. Then I put the occasional news articles in one folder and the firehose feeds in another. (If a site has no obvious rss, paste in the homepage. NetNewsWire seems to figure it out) It now takes 2-3 min per day to look over the firehouses. Can scan, read the ones I want, mark the rest as done. For the news/essay sites, no longer any need to check a site periodically to see “is there an update?” It all just comes in when published. In a world where habit transformation is hard, this one stuck. Consistently has led me to read more of the stuff I wanted to keep up with, while spending less time and energy around actually finding it.
- jwells89 3y agoNetNewsWire is excellent. Clean, responsive, blends into the desktop, and doesn't have memory leak issues like so many macOS RSS readers do. I wish all software could be like it. https://netnewswire.com/ https://netnewswire.com/
- nntwozz 3y agoIt just turned 21, time flies! https://netnewswire.blog/2024/02/11/netnewswire-turns.html https://netnewswire.blog/2024/02/11/netnewswire-turns.html
- ents 3y agoAppreciate the mini-guide here, inspired me to give nnw and rss in general a place in my day again rather than just checking the sites manually.
- graeme 3y agoGlad to help! I should have added I started light, then added in some more stuff once I had a working system. I had tried RSS years ago and my feed then was unwieldy enough I never checked it. This attempt is smaller and stuck
- johnnyapol 3y agoI love RSS. I take a bit of an unconventional approach and use Discord as my RSS reader. I run a self hosted instance of MonitoRSS (https://github.com/synzen/MonitoRSS https://github.com/synzen/MonitoRSS). I have a server with just me and my bot instance and I tend to group my feeds into categories and channels (effectively creating a tab system per subscription or group of subscriptions). I have Discord installed on my laptop, phone, and desktop so this means that I can easily look at all my subscribed feeds wherever it's convenient for me. When I'm not set to "do not disturb", I even get push notifications on my devices when content is posted to feeds that go to channels I haven't muted. I think the only real downside of the setup is some days I am very busy and don't check the server that often, so I'll come back to a large backlog of things to read and I'll end up missing or under-appreciating some gems.
- dugite-code 3y ago> Finally, and one of the biggest issues with RSS, is that it's not very intuitive to non-tech savvy individuals. Back when Google reader was a thing this wasn't true. Your browser auto-themed and provided subscribing options for your configured reader. It's a true shame that Firefox gave up supporting RSS out of the box to match Chrome's stance on the subject
- pockybum522 3y ago07-01-2013, never forget.
- brokenmachine 3y agoThere's so many google dates to not forget, I've started forgetting them all.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoThere's always a handy reminder here [0]. [0] https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/
- 6510 3y agoRSS can do that too!
- WA 3y ago2013-07-01 ISO 07/01/2013 US 01.07.2013 Rest Pick one, but not the abomination you posted, thanks.
- andyjohnson0 3y ago> never forget Honestly I'm pretty much over this now and ready to move on with my life :p There are plenty of good rss readers out there - many of them created because Google left the space. I think that this diversity and decentralisation is a net positive for the world.
- 3y ago
- maxglute 3y agoWaiting for a selfhost options with feedly pro features. Web scraping (limited) for sites that doesn't have RSS. Filters through dupes. AI priority filters to for specific topics/subjects.
- moepstar 3y agoYay RSS :) A habit (useful one, i might add) i'll never get rid of :) Quick PSA here: if you ever want (or need) to filter a RSS feed to get rid of adverts, random rants of a certain topic you don't want to read about - there's RSS Bridge [1] which lets you do that. It also provides some bridges that let you subscribe to sites that don't even have an RSS feed via scraping, or YouTube channels or .... It's pretty much a swiss army knife for RSS (no affiliation, just a happy, self-hosting, user!) [1] https://github.com/RSS-Bridge/rss-bridge https://github.com/RSS-Bridge/rss-bridge
- troad 3y agoJust a heads up that YouTube channels do generally have RSS feeds; e.g.: https://www.youtube.com/feeds/videos.xml?user=NFL https://www.youtube.com/feeds/videos.xml?user=NFL or https://www.youtube.com/feeds/videos.xml?channel_id=UC8WAaaW2FnctRI9coYJoUdA https://www.youtube.com/feeds/videos.xml?channel_id=UC8WAaaW... But RSS Bridge does look very neat!
- kevincox 3y agoJust paste the channel URL until your reader and it should find the feed automatically. YouTube has the proper discovery metadata set up.
- corobo 3y agoOh good, they're back! There was concern a little while ago that Google had killed off the YouTube RSS feeds https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39179446 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39179446 Click saver: 2 weeks ago YouTube channel RSS feeds were returning a 404 response (It looks like they actually came back while that thread was still active)
- troad 3y agoIt's a fair point - Google cannot be relied upon to continue providing this kind of open access indefinitely. I noticed my RSS reader hitting those 404s at the time, and I promptly started looking into the Piped / Invidious infrastructure, thinking Google is pulling up the drawbridge (a la Reddit, Twitter, etc). Then YT RSS came back and I stopped, but I really should switch my feeds away from Google anyway.
- pipeline_peak 3y agoGathering accurate publication dates is the only problem I’ve faced with RSS. Some of these channels flat out don’t give them to you at all. Instead, I have to either resort to polling methods or archive data. I’m open to better solutions
- benzible 3y agoRelated, from Molly White's excellent review of Chris Dixon's Read Write Own [1]: > RSS is dead, he repeats endlessly throughout the book.[...] It's profoundly weird to read RSS's obituary as a person who checks her very-much-still-alive feed reader several times a day to get everything from cryptocurrency news to dinner ideas, and who rarely encounters a website that doesn't provide a functional feed. [1] https://www.citationneeded.news/review-read-write-own-by-chris-dixon/ https://www.citationneeded.news/review-read-write-own-by-chr...
- jeroenhd 3y agoThis little footnote made the obituary of RSS even more hilarious: > As it happens, Dixon's very own website has a functioning RSS feed. He may not even realize this, as RSS is so ubiquitous that many website and blog software products either build it in by default, or make it easy to add with simple plugins.
- acdha 3y agoI think that’s especially relevant given the context of that review. Chris Dixon is regurgitating a bunch of blockchain sales points because he has major investments in the space–a fact he’s not quick to share with readers–and needs to talk them up before he can exit. It’s worth asking whether he gives RSS the opposite treatment because he never figured out a way to get VC-scale returns out of a technology which isn’t amenable to gatekeeping.
- manujindal28392 3y agoFor a person who is not a techie, we find it really difficult to navigate and use RSS
- WelcomeShorty 3y agohttps://theoldreader.com/ https://theoldreader.com/ Just toss in a site you like, it'll (try to) find the RSS feed, and you're done. I have about 50 sites added in the old reader, and it makes following them easy.
- KronisLV 3y agoI remember the thread where people shared their blogs on HN. Then, someone aggregated all of the feeds they could find in an OPML file, from which I built a site that shows an aggregation of some of the latest blog posts: https://hn-blogs.kronis.dev/ https://hn-blogs.kronis.dev/ I think RSS is pretty cool! Not many people know this, but even Thunderbird has a built in RSS feed reader, so I don't even need a separate program: https://blog.thunderbird.net/2022/05/thunderbird-rss-feeds-guide-favorite-content-to-the-inbox/ https://blog.thunderbird.net/2022/05/thunderbird-rss-feeds-g...
- mapreduce 3y agoDo you mean this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36575081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36575081
- carrozo 3y agothis was really cool. there should be a monthly "which blogs got updated this month?" post on HN like the hiring/wants to be hired posts.
- KronisLV 3y agoYep, that's the thread the data came from, would be cool to get more up to date data some time. I'm not sure whether enough people start new blogs for it to be a monthly thing, but once or twice per year would be neat!
- clircle 3y agoI actually find that for most feeds, I dislike chronological sorting. It is a good default, but I prefer to have rules that promote certain authors and keywords. For example, on my Arxiv feeds, I promote certain keywords, and "autoread" everything else. On news feeds, I promote articles about my specific area of the city. I use Gnus to create my own recommendation engine to do this.
- Tommy430 3y agoRSS is still pretty great indeed. It's just that the big tech and social media services want you to believe that it's "dead" just to keep you hooked and addicted into their system as possible.
- kevinfiol 3y agoWoohoo, I love RSS. I feel this is a good a time as any to share Bubo RSS [0] by George Mandis, as well as my personal fork [1]. In essence, all it really is is a build script that reads your RSS feeds from a JSON file, and builds a static site as 1 HTML file and 1 CSS file. You can then run the script at whatever interval you want (basically however often you want to update your "feed"). I do this using Github Actions and publishing to Github Pages [2]. Anyway, its awesome and I've been doing this for a few years now. [0] https://github.com/georgemandis/bubo-rss https://github.com/georgemandis/bubo-rss [1] https://github.com/kevinfiol/rss-reader https://github.com/kevinfiol/rss-reader [2] https://kevinfiol.com/reader https://kevinfiol.com/reader
- zenlot 3y agoJust opened this via Miniflux