3 ms·
I thought STIR/SHAKEN was deployed now. How can someone still call 911 with a fake number without it showing up as a fake number? Aren't PSAPs seeing the attest
by Animats 3y ago
I thought STIR/SHAKEN was deployed now. How can someone still call 911 with a fake number without it showing up as a fake number? Aren't PSAPs seeing the attestation level of the call? A local call that doesn't have an "A" attestation level is very suspicious.
Although this is supposed to be deployed throughout the US telephony network by now, apparently the public safety answering points are not up to speed yet.
Background: "NENA Spoofing Mitigation Information Document"[1]
[1] https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.nena.org/resource/resmgr/standards/nena-inf-043.2-2022_spoofing.pdf https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.nena.org/resource/resmgr/standards...
- sneak 3y agoCops are easy to fool because of CYA security posture. Nobody wants to be on the hook for ignoring an active shooter.
- mdhb 3y agoUnless there’s actual confirmed danger it seems https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uvalde_school_shooting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uvalde_school_shooting
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoThey were one step up from rent-a-cops who got a thrill from intimidating 6th graders.
- 20after4 3y agoSo average cops then?
- manishsharan 3y agoUvalde ? Who's on the hook there?
- jpollock 3y agoSwatters don't call 911, they call the non-emergency lines.
- DebtDeflation 3y agoThat in itself should be a red flag. Someone is in a hostage situation or dealing with an active shooter and instead of just dialing 911 they took the time to locate the non-emergency line and call that?
- wolverine876 3y agoYou might be greatly overestimating technology budgets and skills in city government. What does it take to use STIR/SHAKEN on their end?
- valleyer 3y agoThat's not required. If the telcos implement STIR/SHAKEN as it's been described, then a "swat" call can later (by investigators) be traced back to a human being who can be prosecuted and jailed. That will serve as sufficient deterrent in most cases.
- Atotalnoob 3y agoI mean they went out to this dudes house 40 times Including 4 times in 1 day I don’t think they did much thinking
- Geisterde 3y agoNo no, you dont understand, you just over*estimate their techno skills, having to remember that you already laid seige to some poor fuck at breakfast brunch and lunch is just too much, the appropriate response is coming to dinner too!
- Atreiden 3y agoAnd after dinner, it's time for the injust desserts
- wkat4242 3y agoPayphone. Burner phone. Just grabbing someone's phone on the street.. Always plenty of ways. Here in Europe you can call 112 even without a SIM card. This is done because during a crash etc the SIM card may get dislodged.
- Hamuko 3y agoPretty sure they can do that in the US too. Jordan Turpin called the cops on her parents from a phone without a SIM card.
- hamandcheese 3y agoAll of those things are traceable back to a specific geographic location.
- bryans 3y agoHaving a GPS location doesn't mean you have a suspect. Unless the person called from their own property (zero chance) or didn't move locations at all after making the call (very unlikely), it would require a substantial investigation that most departments aren't able or willing to do, because the odds of catching someone would be extremely low.
- snovv_crash 3y agoNo, but it means that an apparent eyewitness to a hostage situation who isn't at the location they claim to be shouldn't be believed.
- u320 3y agoIt'll even work without coverage in some situations, since roaming is always on for emergency calls, even in your home country.
- ipveesix 3y agoSituation in Belgium: you cannot get a sim without ID/Passport. When you remove your sim, the network provider still knows your imei. So they ask the providers for which sim was used with this imei, and usually find the prankster this way. Sadly, police don’t always show up when you call 112. Even in serious situations.
- kelnos 3y agoI would think the swatters would just buy a cheap burner phone with cash for these calls. They don't even need a SIM card; in the US, at least, a SIM isn't required to make emergency calls.
- jopsen 3y agoBuying a burner phone would certainly make the $40 swatting service a lot less profitable. Having to be geographically present in the same city, might increase the risk and cost a LOT.
- implements 3y ago(As a PSA for anyone with an emergency phone in the UK) You now need a valid SIM to ring 999 in the UK as they were getting too many nuisance calls - but any network will roam the call if reception is bad on your own one.
- LarsAlereon 3y agoUnfortunately there's still lots of reasons a legitimate call wouldn't have attestation, including if it passed over a legacy non-SIP link at any point. That's increasingly rare, but not rare enough to flag or block calls without attestation except within a network you know is pure IP. Even then you get edge cases like forwarded calls that people expect to work even when they don't do them right.
- owenversteeg 3y agoSo is there any sort of real deadline or end in sight for spam/scam calls here? Can someone please legislate that if your call does not have attestation then it gets immediately blackholed? Give a deadline and if you aren't compliant then your phone doesn't work. At this point I could not care less if this causes legacy systems or whatever exactly to break; if it kills a few businesses then so be it. Everyone I know in the US has a constant background of spam calls that makes the phone system almost worthless in many cases. We cannot allow critical infrastructure to be held hostage by a few holdouts.