3 ms·
How does building dense housing lead to higher housing costs? That seems unintuitive to me.
by simonw 3y ago
How does building dense housing lead to higher housing costs? That seems unintuitive to me.
- yterdy 3y agoDevil's advocate: induced demand. Density increases interactions which are the economic point of cities, and why cities are wealthier than suburbs/rural areas (when suburbs/rural areas aren't juiced by subsidies and loans). Wealthier cities attract migration, migration increases demand for units. That said, my personal belief is that prices are completely decoupled from demand and are more reflective of a desperation to keep them high for... other reasons.
- epistasis 3y ago(Keeping in mind that you are playing devils advocate, and that none of this is directed at you personally) Induced demand for highways: sure. Well proven. Happens every single time. Induced demand for housing? Gonna need to see some hard evidence on the time scales, etc. Housing is very different from highways. People can go from using zero freeway miles to 50 freeway miles a day, if there's slightly cheaper housing further out. It's this drop in pricing that drives demand. For housing, the increase in demand comes from having, presumable, more amenities, making the dense living more desirable. The change in time for amenities to develop is on the order of years, however. It takes a long time for businesses to develop, build customer bases, etc. And in that time, it's possible to build more housing. Housing scales far far far better than freeways. It's easy to double, triple, quintuple, and even 10x or more the density from single detached units. Freeways don't scale like that.
- cyberax 3y ago> Induced demand for housing? Gonna need to see some hard evidence on the time scales, etc. Seattle: grew the number of units by 25% within the last 12 years. SF: only 5% within that timeframe. Their price growth curve is nearly identical. > Housing scales far far far better than freeways. It's easy to double, triple, quintuple, and even 10x or more the density from single detached units. LOL, no. You have no idea how much city infrastructure costs. > Freeways don't scale like that. One mile of subway in Manhattan now costs more than 1000 miles of a 6-lane freeway.
- yterdy 3y agoI mean... The very existence of wealthy cities is a sort of proof. Remember that for America to temporarily be one of the few examples where dense cities were less wealthy than spread-out suburbs and exurbs, we had to combine massive subsidies and financing with good old-fashioned racism. What I don't agree with from GP is the idea of real increases in housing costs for those already in cities. The rising tide lifts most boats, if density isn't being unduly suppressed. So, density increases housing value but also the wealth of city-dwellers, relative to everyone else. Supply keeps up with demand, except where we won't let it. >the increase in demand comes from having, presumable, more amenities Not necessarily. It can also come from the increased opportunity for exposure to people and culture.
- crooked-v 3y agoThis kind of anti-logic usually goes along with arguments like "well, they keep building lots of units and prices haven't gone down, so obviously it's useless to do anything but enact rent control for current residents and give the middle finger to anyone else who ever wants to live in that place", while ignoring that prices can't go down until we catch up on the literally decades of underbuilding in most US metro areas.
- jeffbee 3y agoPrices do go down though. A new building in Oakland just got written down by the joint venture REIT that built it, in their filing they blame "historically high levels of new housing on the market". Rents in Oakland are down about 25% in real dollars from their peak in 2019.
- zozbot234 3y agoYes, but it's also Oakland - not really the most desirable place in the neighborhood. That's actually the kind of place where prices would be most likely to drop if you just increase density across the board. (Which is not a bad thing if you're overly worried about the detrimental effects of gentrification!)
- jeffbee 3y agoPeople who say that are speaking from ignorance. These new buildings are ludicrously valuable. The newest, tallest in Oakland is worth > $500 million and the rents are $2k to $4k, and it's > 90% occupied. There are tons of jobs and demand for these homes.
- epistasis 3y agoPlenty of places with far worse reputations than Oakland are not dropping in prices, because they didn't build. Any place will drop in prices if you keep on building in advance of demand. Gentrification is more likely to come from lack of building than building. That's the story all throughout California and every other wealthy area in the US: extreme gentrification through lack of new housing. Its not the new housing that drives up prices, it's the lack of it.
- zozbot234 3y agoIf living in a denser place turns out to be more desirable due to better jobs and/or amenities, the demand effect can be so strong that it more than offsets the increased supply. But that's actually a very good thing; it means that dense housing is unlocking even more value than you might have expected it to.
- hayst4ck 3y agoDense housing creates highly walk-able cities with extremely good public transportation. Furthermore, high density foot traffic creates improved economies of scale for businesses. Economies of scale might shift society to one where you don't need to cook at home because good inexpensive food is everywhere. Businesses themselves benefit from high concentrations of skilled workers in more condensed areas. The total cost of commuting for society diminishes. Public works also benefit because more people can benefit from every dollar spent. Dense living lets people take advantage of the economies of scale of the businesses and infrastructure around them. The end result of dense housing is a highly desirable place to live, in other words, increased demand for housing, locally. This can be seen in housing prices in NYC, Taipei, Seoul, Tokyo, Hong Kong, Singapore, etc. So it is not dense housing that makes housing costs drop, it is dense housing built in excess of demand... But incumbent property owners will resist that tooth and nail because if production of housing can satisfy demand, their capital investments (and very often sole vehicle of retirement income) will decrease in value. When a person's wealth decreases, they desire political change. So housing policy that results in lower housing costs is extremely unpopular among those with power (education, money, time, etc.).
- cyberax 3y ago> How does building dense housing lead to higher housing costs? That seems unintuitive to me. By creating a denser unit, you're forcing (via economic forces) more people to move closer to denser areas. This in turn makes these areas more attractive for employers, making it easier to do business. This in turn makes dense areas more attractive for employees, so they are willing to pay more to live closer to dense areas. Result: density increases, and prices rise along with it. And an additional toxic component: the population is basically not growing anymore. It's nearly a zero-sum game now, so each new dense unit means one more dilapidated house in Kansas as its occupants had to move to find a job.
- cyberax 3y agoHere's a great post from a person living in Tokyo: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39331618 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39331618