39 ms·
It is possible to structure interviews so that: * Every candidate get an almost-identical interview * The interview is not heavily dependent on the investment
by tptacek 3y ago
It is possible to structure interviews so that:
* Every candidate get an almost-identical interview
* The interview is not heavily dependent on the investment or natural aptitude of the interviewer
* Interviews generate data that can be scored by a rubric
* Interviews aren't scored by the interviewer, thus eliminating the intrinsic bias of being in the hot seat with the candidate
It looks different for every role. For instance, for a penetration testing role, I've run standardized interviews that involve generating and prioritizing attack surface lists and hypothetical bug lists. The output isn't "pass/fail", it's the list of places to test, the list of bugs expected, scheduling/testing budgets, and things like that. If I'm delivering the interview to the candidate, I'm presenting the panel of reviewers not my opinions on the candidate, but what they came up with.
The same approach works for general software development (we don't use it here, we have an even fussier process). You can do design exercises, you can work out the dependencies that are going to be needed for a particular complicated project, you can do estimation exercises, you can catalog likely bugs. Review some PRs together. Look at the day-to-day work your team does, and then make the exercise a model of that work.
It's not especially easy to do compared to just sitting down and asking a bunch of questions. Moreover, it's very hard to adopt it as a practice, because you have to trust the rubric (iterating on it over time, but using it enough for it to be meaningful) and not override it based on extrinsic considerations (referrals, misgivings about candidate background, &c).
But the upside is pretty obvious? Once you have it worked out, you get a repeatable process, something that is naturally geared towards iteration and improvement.
Standardize your interviews, generate data, have a panel make the decisions and not the interviewer.
You can still play the interview like D&D if you want!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]