4 ms·
IMO another aspect that could have been highlighted is that really rule-enforcement is “part of the game,” despite any attempt to take it out, and people will e
by bee_rider 3y ago
IMO another aspect that could have been highlighted is that really rule-enforcement is “part of the game,” despite any attempt to take it out, and people will engage in strategies that attack the rules.
There are lots of strategies that attack the rules in the pedantry space. One could post odious content that carefully is constructed to not break the rules. Or post odious content that breaks the rules in a manner similar to the rule-breaking of somebody you don’t like, to highlight uneven enforcement. Post rule breaking content, but of a type which is generally non-odious and general not banned. Try to find room to quibble about what exactly justified an exception.
I think the WWII tank is an interesting question. It is clearly a vehicle, so not allowed by the rule. But it is non-functioning, so it isn’t at risk of violating the most likely intentions of the rule (to prevent noise and injuries). It is an unusual artifact in that it is a monument to a war which is generally considered (to a basically unmatched degree) to have been just. If we allow the tank, do we allow an Iraq war or Vietnam war tank? We just need to solve the question of which wars are just, first, I guess, so to enforce our no vehicles bylaw we’ll have to solve all of politics. Or maybe add a “no war related monuments rule” which seems nice until a veterans group wants to donate a couple benches with little plaques on them.
- psychoslave 3y ago>We just need to solve the question of which wars are just, first, I guess, so to enforce our no vehicles bylaw we’ll have to solve all of politics. That one is easy. Just war is the one that bring many benefits to me and my friends (well, whatever you call my social intimate circle), while destroying those other evil dudes that cast some shadow on my stable predictable world resources exploitation, all that only at the cost of nameless plebeian peons. Or said otherwise, war is unjust when it negatively affects "the mighty me who can unleash propaganda to manufacture consent toward whatever fits my agenda".
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoAlso known as “Might makes right”
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> It is clearly a vehicle, so not allowed by the rule. But it is non-functioning If it's non-functioning it can't be a vehicle. Even without thinking deeply about it this seemed obvious to me. Reducing to the absurd, at what point can you strip down a vehicle until it is no longer a vehicle? Down to the powertrain? Down to the axles and wheels? Is a single uninflated tire without a wheel a vehicle?
- vunderba 3y agoTo me, you're not qualifying your definition well enough. For how long does it have to be non-functioning in order to cease being classified as a vehicle? For example, a car that is temporarily in an auto shop for repairs? If your intent is to say that it's no longer classified as a vehicle until it is once again functional, then I think you'll find that your definition deviates pretty significantly from a conventional dictionary definition (a device intended for transport). That's a relatively large desync which will only hinder consistent communications with the vast majority of English speakers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rini17 3y agoThat's irrelevant. Someone leaving broken cars in the park or even only a few parts will certainly be considered a violation by a majority. To your objections they might say - it's littering anyway and we don't want that do we?
- wisty 3y agoThat's littering.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whats_a_quasar 3y agoWell, this sort of illustrates the point, because to me an object that would be a vehicle if it was functioning is clearly still a vehicle. A broken-down vehicle vehicle is still a vehicle, even if it's non-functioning. A car doesn't stop being a vehicle while it's in the shop. Perhaps there is another category for vehicles which are irreparably damaged and will never function again. But even then, I want to define it as a broken vehicle, a sub-type of a vehicle.