5 ms·
Like most popular science/psychology books, this one has attracted a lot of criticism for making exaggerated claims and for peddling reductive concepts to appea
by Aurornis 3y ago
Like most popular science/psychology books, this one has attracted a lot of criticism for making exaggerated claims and for peddling reductive concepts to appeal to a wider audience.
There’s no denying that massive stress and trauma can have long lasting effects. However, the pop culture definition of trauma and stress have become very diluted. I spent some time working with college students recently and it was remarkable to hear how many of them described common life events as “trauma”: Break ups, failing a class, or even getting yelled at by someone. Something weird happens when they’ve been primed to recognize everything uncomfortable as “trauma” and they’ve been instilled with the belief that it will forever become embedded in their person as baggage.
- ajkjk 3y agoIn my experience it's kinda the opposite. Realizing that stuff was trauma helped move on from it. Until I had a framework for why a fairly-normal-sounding experience was affecting my personality so much, I just felt like I was going crazy. It helped a lot to realize that ruminating on it was how trauma works: its purpose is to figure out how to avoid a recurrence at all costs, including warping one's behavior in aberrant ways.
- DANmode 3y agoInstinctual, evolutionary response. It makes all sorts of sense.
- armatav 3y agoSome people can kill a man, or lose a limb and not suffer traumatic rumination. Some other people lose their favorite toy as an kid and it really does become a deep rumination pattern of traumatic loss for them.
- Aurornis 3y ago> Some other people lose their favorite toy as an kid and it really does become a deep rumination pattern of traumatic loss for them. In this case, the "trauma" is virtually irrelevant, though. The issue is the rumination and pattern of overreaction, which should certainly be addressed. For some, the obsession with "trauma" becomes a way to move the focus to something external, which is therefore out of their control. In your example, too much focus on "trauma" as an explanation for everything could mislead someone into thinking that the loss of the toy is to blame for their situation, whereas they really need to accept that their reaction and pattern of rumination is what needs to be addressed.
- batch12 3y agoI agree that words have meanings. Words like trauma and abuse shouldn’t be used casually or we won't have the language to describe horrific things. However-- having experienced some early childhood difficulties, I have had to make an intentional effort not to downgrade people's experiences and fall into a no true Scotsman trap. I try to remind myself that things like trauma and abuse are experiences that filter through people's minds. It's trauma if they think it is. I do also think though that some people have never experienced the same types of trauma as others so they may not really understand it. If and when they do, they may choose to rank the experiences differently. Edit: updated my ramble
- throwanem 3y ago> It's trauma if they think it is and it impacts them as trauma. This sentence gained a clause before I hit 'reply', and I understand why because it addresses the criticism I intended to make, but I'm still not at all sure I agree with you here. Even the edit implies the assumption that no one is responsible for how they choose to respond to the events of their lives, and that is plausible but requires substantiation not evident here. In particular, I do not think it is necessary for anyone to personally experience 'horrific things' to understand that some things are worse than others, and be glad that what they're dealing with isn't worse - which probably sounds cruel to some, but is in fact quite helpful; maintaining a sense of perspective around the mishaps that attend every human life can in itself go a long way toward responding to them in a way that's well calibrated to their actual severity. In the meantime, not treating 'trauma' as suitable to describe every unfortunate happenstance - a college breakup! Really... - also avoids vitiating the concept, which strikes me as a worthwhile kindness to those who really have been through hell - or those who haven't yet, and will find it easier to come out the other side for there still being social space to accommodate the existence of those who have to recover from, or just find a way to live with, long experience of the genuinely atrocious.
- batch12 3y agoYeah, I've waffled on that because I don't know how to say it how I mean it. I'll try to generalize it but I'm sure I won't get it right. If something has you afraid, it doesnt matter if I think your fear is justified. Me disregarding your emotion doesn't make you lose the fear. I don't disagree with the idea that we are responsible for how we respond to events in our lives. I tell my kids the same thing- nobody can control you unless you let them. You have the power to control how you respond to things. Sometimes it's the only power you have. I don't have to agree that a college breakup is trauma, but it isn't helpful in most cases to point that out when someone thinks it is. Instead, maybe I can just listen the way I would if it were something I thought was more important. Maybe they'll get through it the same way I did given enough time. Edit: >In particular, I do not think it is necessary for anyone to personally experience 'horrific things' to understand that some things are worse than others, Unfortunately I do disagree with you here. I've met too many people that seem incapable of proper empathy or otherwise lack the ability to learn from the mistakes of others. I could agree with swapping anyone with everyone.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoCertainly "trauma" has been diluted. Someone I think who does a really good job of distinguishing actual trauma (something that disrupts development) from acquired entitlement etc is Gabor Mate in "The myth of normal". Would definitely recommend.
- Aurornis 3y ago> Someone I think who does a really good job of distinguishing actual trauma (something that disrupts development) from acquired entitlement etc is Gabor Mate Gabor Mate is extremely charismatic, but IMO he's part of the problem. The last time I listened to a podcast where he was a guest, he pushed the idea that being born could qualify as trauma leading to PTSD in adulthood. He told a story about a patient with mental health issues where he was unable to identify overt trauma until despite going through her life in fine detail. Eventually he concluded that it must have been the experience of being born that was her trauma. This is what I was talking about when someone pushes the "trauma explains everything" angle: When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail. Some of these pseudo-experts may be good at treating trauma, but they take it too far and start trying to describe everything big or small as a trauma.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoIf true that does indeed sound quite ridiculous.
- luxpir 3y agoI may be misremembering, but my recollection is that he talks about the stresses of the parents being passed on from birth. My other vague recollection is that studies exist which prove this phenomenon to be true. A third vague recollection is that his own mother was persecuted due to religion, giving his theories and his reason to pursue them some level of credibility. My memory is not machine-like in its efficiency. I am open to correction. But I believe GP may not be fully stating the facts for their own reasons.
- dnissley 3y agoSee "The rise of therapy-speak": https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/the-rise-of-therapy-speak https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/the-rise-...
- flatline 3y agoAs someone who grew up in the 80s, this type of minimization of personal suffering was the norm. “You don’t know how good you have it” despite real mental and physical health struggles. You either made it to adulthood, cynical and damaged, transformed your suffering into growth on your own, or ended up in some marginalized place like a mental ward. Sometimes a mix of all of the above. I think we can do better. I remember the first time I saw a therapist she thought I may have PTSD. I thought she was nuts and never went back. It took me another decade to realize that my mother was deeply mentally ill and physically and emotionally abusive, it’s just that no one ever talked about or recognized these things as abnormal. My dad was a high functioning alcoholic. I’ve talked to other adults who went through much less than I did and left home and lived on the streets rather than deal with their family situation. But talk to my parents, everything was “fine” and “pretty normal”. I had a “good upbringing” because we were not poor or in trouble with the law. I also had some early sexual encounters that people would jump to classify as child abuse, but they were, from my standpoint, overall positive experiences. I don’t know where to draw the line on what constitutes trauma for someone else. It’s highly subjective. There are always things in life we must just bear. But it’s good to recognize when things are not working and to make what changes we can, and to recognize when things have long lasting impacts, and when they don’t.
- slibhb 3y ago> As someone who grew up in the 80s, this type of minimization of personal suffering was the norm. It's a tricky problem. Some people need help. But there are a lot of people for whom "holding it in" and adopting general-purpose stoic principles are enough. For the latter group, the new openness about mental illness and trauma has been a disaster. Like a lot of things, you can think of this issue in terms of "type 1 and type 2 errors". Ideally we try to minimize both but it seems that we often end up minimizing one and totally ignoring the other.
- bjornsing 3y ago> For the latter group, the new openness about mental illness and trauma has been a disaster. Why so?
- lepus 3y agoFor now it's the term people have adopted to describe a wide range of negative impactful experiences. Usually there's something deeper and older going on in someone when a seemingly minor event causes feelings of "trauma", but sometimes the extreme results of opening that can of worms in someone can be nearly as devastating. The human experience is messy and ultimately hard to keep confined in rigid definitions, but we keep trying.
- shadowbanned4 3y ago[dead]
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoI can absolutely see why break ups, failing a class, and getting yelled at by someone can be traumatic. I’ve had quite traumatic break ups in my youth due to my own attachment and expectations about the relationship and life. If someone had a lot of pressure about academic success growing up, or a lot of hopes attached to good grades, failure could be traumatic. I would hope that the potential for trauma in getting yelled at would be self evident. Trauma doesn’t mean the experience will be forever embedded as “baggage”. It means it’s something we’re carrying with us right now. Something we’ve not fully processed or healed from. I’ve found that identifying and recognizing trauma is part of the healing process. Failing to identify trauma can mean carrying it with you longer - snapping at others when you get too irritated, because someone did so to you and you haven’t processed the emotional trauma of the situation, for example. Or high anxiety at work carried over from the trauma of failing a class, because you haven’t recognized that even after that failure things worked out okay and you’re still carrying the fear of failure. Trauma like many words has degrees. It is similar to the word injury in that sense. Losing your legs in a motorcycle accident is an injury. A sprained wrist is also an injury. Just remember that with trauma it is hard to see how deep it went. Perhaps someone did experience quite strong trauma from something you would manage easily. That’s due to the different lives you lead, and differences in experience, values, and goals. And remember that situations others might handle well could be things you struggle with. Everyone’s experience is their own.
- mock-possum 3y ago> it was remarkable to hear how many of them described common life events as “trauma”: Break ups, failing a class, or even getting yelled at by someone. Isn’t it a bit cruel to dismiss the ups and downs of college life as unworthy of being called ‘traumatic?’ Who are you to make that judgement?
- DANmode 3y agoMany people experience severe health problems related to trauma that other people can shake right off. Humans are a wide spectrum, all good and bad at unique things - and you "can't judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree".
- ronald_raygun 3y ago> Break ups, failing a class, or even getting yelled at by someone I agree a lot of people overblow trauma. However it is worth mentioning, all the things that you mention can be traumatizing, though. Like imagine breaking up with a partner of a few years because they've been serially cheating on you and lying about it. Imagine failing a class when you've been pressured by your parents your entire life to do well in school, and you know this is going to set them off the edge. Imagine being yelled at for 20 minutes in front of the whole class as a tiny kid. Like the question isn't really "is X bad in an objective way" but more "did X create a bunch of problems for so and so that make their life harder in terms of emotions, psychology, etc."
- voisin 3y ago> Like the question isn't really "is X bad in an objective way" but more "did X create a bunch of problems for so and so that make their life harder in terms of emotions, psychology, etc." From the book itself, trauma is more closely defined as “what causes the sympathetic nervous system (fight or flight) to overreact” which then causes the body to have to deal with the excess cortisol released by the overreaction. This can be the accumulation of micro-stressors or individual major events. OP’s dismissal of things due to being “common life events” is simply ridiculous.
- voisin 3y agoI find it ludicrous that you would suggest that the breakup of a close romantic relationship shouldn’t be considered traumatic or qualify as trauma for someone that is of college age, only because of the commonality of occurrence.
- kirse 3y agomany of them described common life events as “trauma” We've experienced a massive dilution in language over the past decade or so. I'm not sure if it's because we're churning out more black & white thinkers or incentivizing folks with a victim mindset, but all sorts of words like *-phobic, gaslighting, trauma, etc. have become significantly overused given their traditional symptomatic markers. It's the language equivalent of WebMD - basically implying that a grab bag of cold symptoms are in fact brain cancer. On one hand it's good that the next generation thinks a breakup is "traumatic", because it means people are experiencing less absolute trauma. On the other hand words have meanings so we can accurately describe the world.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoThe severity of pain of a life event changes with the skilld of a person. 2 children playing and one starts crying because the other broke their toy, is that less intense than an adult breakfing up with the lifelong partner? The answer I thought was yes and over time came to realize that it's probably no. Given that, what you perceive as traumatic is not the same for another person
- Tactile6700 3y agoThe book does distinguish “Big T” & “Little T” trauma. Little T is a helpful concept re the fairly normal life difficulties noted—-validates the pain but keeps it in perspective. Concern about a priming effect is also valid.
- bowsamic 3y agoIdk it wasn’t until I went to my therapist that I realised that my mum leaving at the age of 2 was traumatic and that I have a lot of extreme stress and depressive responses now from that even though I didn’t know it. It’s easy to say “divorce is normal and not traumatic” but I think that normal life events can and do cause trauma