4 ms·
The question, as I'd ask more specifically: what philosophical/legal principle can/do "liberals" [1] use to determine what is or is not a legitimate function of
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
The question, as I'd ask more specifically: what philosophical/legal principle can/do "liberals" [1] use to determine what is or is not a legitimate function of the government?
For example, many liberals believe that Jim Crow laws or laws giving special privileges to straight married couples (but not gay married couples) should not be permitted even with popular electoral support. I.e., liberals often consider "the citizens of the US were able to elect representatives who X" to be an invalid justification for policy X.
The question is, what principle are liberals using to come up with views like this? Another question in the same line of thinking is: is there a principle beyond "I like/dislike this policy" which the courts can use to invalidate laws? (Note that appealing to court precedents and reinterpretations of the constitution doesn't really answer this, since the court can always re-reinterpret or make a new precedent.)
[1] I hate phrasing it this way, since the feelings it generates ("I {love/hate} liberals SOOOO MUCH") reduce everyone's IQ by about 15 pts.
- tptacek 15y agoI don't understand. Isn't "Jim Crow laws are unconstitutional" what Brown v. Board of Education decided? The Constitution doesn't provide a black-letter guarantee of education for anyone, and yet the 14th Amendment allowed SCOTUS to hold: Today, education is perhaps the most important function of state and local governments. Compulsory school attendance laws and the great expenditures for education both demonstrate our recognition of the importance of education to our democratic society. It is required in the performance of our most basic public responsibilities, even service in the armed forces. It is the very foundation of good citizenship. Today it is a principal instrument in awakening the child to cultural values, in preparing him for later professional training, and in helping him to adjust normally to his environment. In these days, it is doubtful that any child may reasonably be expected to succeed in life if he is denied the opportunity of an education. Such an opportunity, where the state has undertaken to provide it, is a right which must be made available to all on equal terms. I just don't see where you're going. I'm interested, but I'm not following.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe issue is not what the court decided, unless you believe the court is always correct and what is constitutional changes w.r.t what the court believes. For example, do you believe that in the period from 1896 (Plessy v Fergusen) until 1954 (Brown v Board of Ed), Jim Crow laws were constitutional? If not, you must have some underlying principle that tells you Plessy was incorrect. Or, somewhat tangential to constitutionality, you might have an underlying belief as to what constitutes a legitimate function of the government (e.g., perhaps you believe that regulating same-sex acts is not such a function). The question is, what is that underlying principle (or set of principles)? This is what Nirvana attempted to ask, while unfortunately getting bogged down in other far more boring matters.
- tptacek 15y agoBut it's not just "the Supreme Court decided it and thus it is so" (although when push comes to shove...). It's also that the SCOTUS decisions are a hint book to arguments like this. So, I don't have to reason from first principles to arrive at the conclusion that the 14th Amendment makes "separate but equal" unconstitutional. Brown v. Board lays out the argument that it does. I can't best the argument here in a message board post. Do you think Brown v. Board is one of the cases SCOTUS got wrong? Genuinely curious.
- barry-cotter 15y agoDo you think Brown v. Board is one of the cases SCOTUS got wrong? Genuinely curious. I'm not yummyfajitas nor am I speaking for him. I believe he's looking for a principle somewhere that links people's moral outrage and the law. People either have their principles or they have the law. If people are having an argument about what is moral the law is irrelevant, if they're having an argument about what is moral the law is irrelevant. A consistent argument would be either legal or moral. Any argument that treats the law as having moral weight is assigning some kind of quasi-sacred status to it. Either the PATRIOT Act is legal therefore it is right is an argument that has some weight however tiny XOR it doesn't. Why do you think But it's not just "the Supreme Court decided it and thus it is so" (although when push comes to shove...). It's also that the SCOTUS decisions are a hint book to arguments like this. They're just some political appointees who're mostly very, very smart. The important bit is the political appointees though. If you just assume Republican appointees vote Republican and Democrats Democrat on any given policy position you don't go far wrong. What moral weight can that have?