6 ms·
I'm not really sure how I should feel about this. I'd like medicine to be affordable by everyone. However, what I mainly get out of the article is that a compan
by melling 15y ago
I'm not really sure how I should feel about this. I'd like medicine to be affordable by everyone. However, what I mainly get out of the article is that a company with little or no R&D is simply reducing the price on drugs, which for them is mostly profit anyway. The drugs themselves are cheap to produce, right?
Somehow, I think we'd all benefit if we could get these companies involved in developing better medicines. Maybe reduce the price by 50% then take that additional pool of money and invest it into research within India, for example.
Another idea...We always hear how great the IIT's are, which I believe they are. Let's turn them into great research universities.
[Update]
It's interesting to see my post get upvoted and downvoted, which most won't see. My suggestions don't really seem that divisive. I simply think getting more people working on the problem with funding from existing sales seems like a better idea than just reducing drug costs. Additionally, I think involving other institutions rather than sending the money back to Big Pharma, might provide different insights into solving the problems.
- kiba 15y agoThrowing money at the problem may not necessarily speed up research or give us more results.
- pyre 15y agoHow else would you pay for top-calibur talent to sold the problem?
- bilbo0s 15y agoI believe what kiba is intimating is that no matter how much you pay... some drugs and diseases are just hard to come up with solutions for. To give an example everyone is fairly familiar with... even if you paid USD100 Million per research position to get a cancer vaccine, I'm not certain you would get it any faster than if you paid USD200000 per position. Or USD100000. It's just REALLY hard to come up with.
- melling 15y agoBut what I was suggesting was putting more people on the problem, not offering more per position. In fact, the research done in India would cost less than in the US.
- kiba 15y agoFigure out a way to speed up the research process itself. We can't afford to wait 10 to 20 years. Many lives will be lost during those time period. Yes, research take time. Yes, medical research is extraordinary hard. It still doesn't excuse our slowness. We need to look at fighting diseases as a war, not a scientific exploration project. Science is good, but solutions are better. We don't need to understand in extreme details how cancer work, we just need a way to defeat cancer.
- melling 15y agoAdd more cores or make the existing ones faster? I said add more cores. If you can think of a way to make each core faster, that's great. In the meantime, getting more people on the problem should help. [Update] Please include include links that discuss the "better" method that you are describing. It sounds like you just want to "reinvent/disrupt" the process without actually having a plan.
- kiba 15y agoYou should instead dedicate newer core into process optimization. We want to find a cure in 9 years, then 8 years, 7 years, 6 years, and so on. With each passing year, medical research should be progressing even faster. We don't want to wait ten years for a slightly higher chance of a cure appearing. We want a higher chance of a cure in a much shorter time period. Please include include links that discuss the "better" method that you are describing. It sounds like you just want to "reinvent/disrupt" the process without actually having a plan. It's not a "plan", or a "method". It's a goal. You could start with a small. Figure out what people are doing that should be done by robots or computers. What mistakes people are making that delay the whole research process? Are the bureaucrats holding up the approval for no good reason? How much time you spent fighting politics versus getting things done? The key insight is this: Speeds absolutely matter in medicine. One more day you wait for a cure, somebody die. If speed is not one of your nation's research goal, it should be.
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoThis sounds like a very naive view of biological systems. The complexity of the most complex thing computer science has created (I would argue that is the Internet) is still trivially simple compared to the brain. What that means is the search space is huge, much larger than any space I've dealt with in computer science. However, there may be something to what you are saying (I don't know enough about medical research to know whether they are already doing this or not). In public key cryptography, you have a huge key space to try if you want to brute force a key (2^64 for a 64 bit key, unsurprisingly). However, you can break a 64 bit key in about 2^40 operations if you use the right technique [1]. Are we spending enough time looking for those techniques? I certainly hope so. There are a lot of smart people in medicine. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meet-in-the-middle_attack http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meet-in-the-middle_attack
- pradocchia 15y agoThat's a fashionable yet very narrow framing of the matter. If you insist on this formulation, then indeed many many problems are insoluble.
- mnazim 15y agoIITs have failed to deliver in research and development. In my very humble opinion, they have transformed in glorified employment exchanges main emphasis being on fetching a 7 figure paycheck after 4 years.
- melling 15y agoI still think the opportunity is there. I've seen several specials on the IITs, and they are a very well respected institution both in and out India. In addition, I think people generally realize that the educational system should offer more. I'll offer up Aamir Khan and friends as anecdotal evidence. :-) Great movie. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3_Idiots http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3_Idiots
- mayanksinghal 15y agoI actually hated that movie. While the message that 'One should pursue his/her own dream' was neat, the portrayal was bad. It showed that Engineering education in India sucks largely because of orthodox bad teachers who lack vision. It portrayed it is alright to play bad hurtful pranks (though a joke, but unfortunately immaturity is still prevails in college students). The professors were shown in such bad light and without any emotions that even suicides don't make them change their facial expressions. They really took it to the extreme, it was sad because it might have demotivated some people.
- denzil_correa 15y ago> It showed that Engineering education in India sucks largely because of orthodox bad teachers who lack vision. And pray, you being from IIT what makes you qualified enough to show this statement is wrong? I'm not saying the portrayal of the movie was correct but to make a sweeping generalizable statement above ; one needs to be part of a setup other than IITs.
- mayanksinghal 15y agoI didn't make that generalization - I was commenting on the sweeping generalization that was made in the movie. I know some very great teachers who do not teach at IITs. My parents are college professors and at least 4 aunts/uncles of mine are also in teaching profession. While I agree that a lot of educational institutes in India suffer from under-qualified or uninspired teaching - I do not believe that it is the core reason of all that is wrong with the education system. My being an IITian actually contributes less to this belief of mine than my school teachers in a small town. It did get reinforced here but I have always had some great teachers.
- spiffworks 15y agoAs someone who once worked at an IIT, money is not lacking, imagination is.
- mayanksinghal 15y agoTeaching, I suppose. Which IIT?