7 ms·
I don't feel that the marketing or curation is problematic really. However: Suppose I want to buy "A Song of Ice and Fire" for my Kindl - a reasonable enough p
by Havoc 15y ago
I don't feel that the marketing or curation is problematic really. However:
Suppose I want to buy "A Song of Ice and Fire" for my Kindl - a reasonable enough proposition in my view. A quick check reveals two problems: Firstly those bits & bytes are somehow more expensive than the massmarket paperback - which is completely ridiculous. Secondly both the individual books and the set have warnings (either by amazon or reviewers) that clearly state that its a criminally bad OCR job.
So essentially the product is overpriced and defective. Doesn't matter under what genre you file that its a crap purchase.
Same thing for the Dune series. So in the mean time I think I'll just side-load books until Amazon sorts their shit out. Hell I'd even look past the overpriced bit if they fix the crap OCR jobs.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoBoth of those issues are the fault of the publisher, not Amazon. The publishers are being dragged kicking and screaming (and whining) into the ebook future, and they're not doing a very good job of serving their customers as a result.
- Havoc 15y agoYou're right, perhaps I shouldn't have mentioned Amazon as the culprit. Nonetheless I feel Amazon is partly to blame since they clearly have the muscle to force the publishers to fix their mess. Besides, how difficult can it be? Find a competent English major, fuel him/her with some red bull, pizza and bit of cash and they'll fix it. Hell, if they had a mechanism to do so the fans of these books (Dune etc) would probably fix it for free.
- nnnnni 15y agoWhat I don't get is WHY a modern book would require OCR to be turned into a digital format. The publisher surely has the original tex (or whatever format the author/editor used) file(s) that can easily be rendered to epub/mobi, right?! If a book predates computers, I can understand OCR, but not for something that's been written in the past ~20 years and is popular enough to not be "lost".
- gwern 15y agoThey may have lost them. They may have a tiny glitch preventing conversion which the dude at the publisher simply can't figure out. Or something. Publishers are as incompetent as anyone else. At ICON this year I got to go to a reading by David Weber (of _Honor Harrington_ etc), and he talked a little about dealing with a publisher and gave 2 examples of global search-and-replaces gone terribly wrong - Barons -> Earls, and Lords -> Knights, which resulted in him proofreading the entire books just to fix the S&R. Turns out publishers apparently don't use revision control either.
- cstross 15y agoPublishing People Are Not Computer People. (Well, most of them. I think Tim O'Reilly might argue the toss :) Authors of novels are even worse. They are in a career that typically doesn't get started until they're in their mid-thirties. So unless they got their start in IT/CS, you're looking at J. Random Middle-Aged Non-Techie. Some of us know what a revision control system is. Most haven't got a clue, and aren't interested.
- stcredzero 15y agoSome of us know what a revision control system is. Most haven't got a clue, and aren't interested. I'd bet a lot of them have seen the RCS-like abilities of Time Machine or Dropbox and been delighted or would react with delight if it those were demonstrated to them. A lot of them still wouldn't have a clue nor be interested, though. If people have built content management systems for publishers like newspapers, someone must have thought of CMS for other publishers with roots in the dead-tree business.
- cstross 15y agoYou're correct, but book publishers aren't used to thinking in those terms. Traditionally, the job results in a static lump of ink on paper. Game over: you sell it, you're done. In some fields it's a little different; text book publishers expect to issue new editions, for example. But those new editions are de facto different books, re-written and re-edited and re-typeset from scratch. Newspapers and magazines need CMSs because they may need to pull or revise stories. Novels ... not so much. Yes, it's good to fix typos. In the world of paper publishing the author gets just one shot at that: the book goes back to be re-flowed for a different page size when it goes from hardcover into A-format paperback, and there's an opportunity to fix snags. This is, obviously, going to change. In fact, I expect the bigger publishers to wake up real soon now and realize that not only do they have to do e-pub related things like drop DRM and fix the broken territorial rights problem, they also need to do internal process-related things -- like set up a CMS, in-source their typesetting, and modify their workflow to allow updates to existing-and-out-there books, rather than viewing the books as a terminal state at the end of a production process. (Reasons why it should change? Well, for one thing it makes possible the issue of "director's cut" versions of a book. Yes, crass commercialism. But it also makes it possible to retarget books on a different audience. It makes it possible to rebundle in-series books in an omnibus edition. It makes it easier for the publisher to directly issue extracts from the book via their website, for promo purposes. Once layout/typesetting stops being a single step and becomes an ongoing process, there's every reason for in-housing it. And that, in turn, will require revision control and archival functions that publishers are currently unfamiliar with.)
- ArcticCelt 15y agoAnd thirdly, you don't own your overpriced defective digital book but only hold a temporary licensee to read it. Of course you can eventually end with nothing once the license provider goes bankrupt or decide to change his business model.
- T-hawk 15y agoPricing an e-book higher than the paperback is not ridiculous. That's capitalism. If technology has enabled a new version of a product that is superior for the customer in convenience or capabilities, the customer will be willing to pay more and the producer has every right to capture that, regardless of what it costs to produce. (Leaving aside OCR quality issues.) This happens all the time. DVDs cost less to produce than VHS but sold for more because customers were willing to pay. TicketMaster can charge its service fee because customers will pay, even though it's certainly lower cost for TM to email PDFs than to staff a physical box office and buy ticket printers. A smart capitalist captures the consumer value he creates, regardless of his own costs.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoConditionally superior in convenience, pluses and minuses in capabilities, definite minus in terms of ownership. Ticketmaster is an effective monopoly, publishers are an effective oligopoly. Neither are exactly capitalism's finest examples.
- cabalamat 15y ago> If technology has enabled a new version of a product that is superior for the customer in convenience or capabilities, the customer will be willing to pay more This might be true if people were rational utility-maximisers. They're not, and people are quite capable of choosing not to buy something if they feel it's a rip off.
- philwelch 15y ago...at which point the price would fall, which it empirically hasn't, implying that customers are, indeed, willing to pay more after all.
- Havoc 15y agoYou are quite right, in that prices are set to whatever the market will bear. You're viewing things from the perspective of an individual price setter though. I was talking more in terms of a bigger picture view: In a competitive market with high net profit margins more competitors should enter the market & undercut the existing prices. Mean that in the long run, the sales price of an item should approach the cost price. Now producing & delivering an additional ebook costs perhaps 1 cent, while producing an additional paper book costs perhaps a dollar. So ebooks should be sold at 1 cent + minor contribution to fixed cost + near zero profit, while paper books should be sold at 1 dollar + minor contribution to fixed cost + near zero profit. i.e. ebooks should be dirty cheap compared to paper books. Yet in practice ebooks are somehow maintaining their prices way beyond what one would expect per economic theory. Little surprise then that various publishers are currently in trouble for price-fixing of ebooks. Courts work slowly though & in the mean time I'm still pissed about the price I'm paying for those (badly OCR'd) bits & bytes.
- hmahncke 15y agoI bought all five volumes for my kindle, and they obviously weren't OCR'd.
- Havoc 15y agoCould you please elaborate? (Pretty please) I see there is a recently published set I didn't see before containing all 5 books: http://www.amazon.com/Song-Ice-Fire-Continues-ebook/dp/B007B5EDEG/ref=sr_1_1?s=digital-text&ie=UTF8&qid=1337011650&sr=1-1 http://www.amazon.com/Song-Ice-Fire-Continues-ebook/dp/B007B... Is that the one that is fine?
- hmahncke 15y agoI don't think I did anything more fancy than google "amazon kindle game of thrones" which took me to http://www.amazon.com/Game-Thrones-Song-Fire-ebook/dp/B000QCS8TW http://www.amazon.com/Game-Thrones-Song-Fire-ebook/dp/B000QC... I didn't buy them as a set - I bought them one by one. Hope that helps. Fun books.
- hmahncke 15y agoThere's something a bit odd about that page/edition - only one review, and just a few likes - the one I bought has thousands of reviews and likes. Could your link be a rip-off, and that's why the OCR was so bad?
- Havoc 15y agoThe previous set was 4 books, this one is 5. Its recently been released. So I'm kinda hoping its got fixed OCR.