4 ms·
We are not, no matter what 'nirvana thinks... Nirvana never claimed the government would obey the constitution as written - in fact, he claimed it wouldn't. Yo
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
We are not, no matter what 'nirvana thinks...
Nirvana never claimed the government would obey the constitution as written - in fact, he claimed it wouldn't. Your post completely ducks nirvana's question while mocking him and misrepresenting his views.
His question, again: "there are many such crimes that many liberals disagree with: such as the patriot act, the kim dotcom fiasco, airport porno scanners, domestic spying of all kinds, the drug war, even in states that have legalized it, etc. how do you propose to fix this?"
- tptacek 15y agoI'm sorry that I've come across as pointlessly mocking him, but this question doesn't make sense to me. Take for instance the drug war. I don't agree with the drug war. I think criminalization of marijuana is terrible policy. But is it unconstitutional? The Constitution provided a framework within which the citizens of the US were able to elect representatives who passed laws that outlawed marijuana. "Even in States that have legalized it"? That's an objection the Constitution explicitly presages: "This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof; and all treaties made, or which shall be made, under the authority of the United States, shall be the supreme law of the land; and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby". I re-re-read 'nirvana's point, and I think my interpretation is valid and that I haven't misrepresented him. 'nirvana has adopted the idea that much of what the government is doing is illegal because it isn't spelled out in the Constitution (in this one case, because the power to establish a federal police force isn't one of the Enumerated Powers of Congress). That's not how the Constitution works. Could you be more specific, then, about what you're asking me? How do I propose to fix what? The drug war?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe question, as I'd ask more specifically: what philosophical/legal principle can/do "liberals" [1] use to determine what is or is not a legitimate function of the government? For example, many liberals believe that Jim Crow laws or laws giving special privileges to straight married couples (but not gay married couples) should not be permitted even with popular electoral support. I.e., liberals often consider "the citizens of the US were able to elect representatives who X" to be an invalid justification for policy X. The question is, what principle are liberals using to come up with views like this? Another question in the same line of thinking is: is there a principle beyond "I like/dislike this policy" which the courts can use to invalidate laws? (Note that appealing to court precedents and reinterpretations of the constitution doesn't really answer this, since the court can always re-reinterpret or make a new precedent.) [1] I hate phrasing it this way, since the feelings it generates ("I {love/hate} liberals SOOOO MUCH") reduce everyone's IQ by about 15 pts.
- tptacek 15y agoI don't understand. Isn't "Jim Crow laws are unconstitutional" what Brown v. Board of Education decided? The Constitution doesn't provide a black-letter guarantee of education for anyone, and yet the 14th Amendment allowed SCOTUS to hold: Today, education is perhaps the most important function of state and local governments. Compulsory school attendance laws and the great expenditures for education both demonstrate our recognition of the importance of education to our democratic society. It is required in the performance of our most basic public responsibilities, even service in the armed forces. It is the very foundation of good citizenship. Today it is a principal instrument in awakening the child to cultural values, in preparing him for later professional training, and in helping him to adjust normally to his environment. In these days, it is doubtful that any child may reasonably be expected to succeed in life if he is denied the opportunity of an education. Such an opportunity, where the state has undertaken to provide it, is a right which must be made available to all on equal terms. I just don't see where you're going. I'm interested, but I'm not following.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe issue is not what the court decided, unless you believe the court is always correct and what is constitutional changes w.r.t what the court believes. For example, do you believe that in the period from 1896 (Plessy v Fergusen) until 1954 (Brown v Board of Ed), Jim Crow laws were constitutional? If not, you must have some underlying principle that tells you Plessy was incorrect. Or, somewhat tangential to constitutionality, you might have an underlying belief as to what constitutes a legitimate function of the government (e.g., perhaps you believe that regulating same-sex acts is not such a function). The question is, what is that underlying principle (or set of principles)? This is what Nirvana attempted to ask, while unfortunately getting bogged down in other far more boring matters.
- tptacek 15y agoBut it's not just "the Supreme Court decided it and thus it is so" (although when push comes to shove...). It's also that the SCOTUS decisions are a hint book to arguments like this. So, I don't have to reason from first principles to arrive at the conclusion that the 14th Amendment makes "separate but equal" unconstitutional. Brown v. Board lays out the argument that it does. I can't best the argument here in a message board post. Do you think Brown v. Board is one of the cases SCOTUS got wrong? Genuinely curious.
- nirvana 15y ago>I think criminalization of marijuana is terrible policy. But is it unconstitutional? The Constitution provided a framework within which the citizens of the US were able to elect representatives who passed laws that outlawed marijuana. You're not pointlessly mocking me, you're mocking me because mocking me IS THE POINT for you. Otherwise you wouldn't be bringing up arguments that I rebutted in the very first comment. >I re-re-read 'nirvana's point, and I think my interpretation is valid and that I haven't misrepresented him. Then you need some remedial schooling. Show me where these powers are enumerated? You can't so you pretend like the enumerated powers are irrelevant. >That's not how the Constitution works. This is a wish, at best an assertion, and certainly not an argument. But it is a statement of your fascist ideology. You want the government to have absolute power to regulate people's lives to the nth degree-- from their access to the internet to what health care they are allowed to have. The constitution explicitly doesn't allow this, so you pretend like it does. You know this, so you attack me personally, when I point it out. That's all this is. The facts of reality disagree with your ideology, so you engage in ad hominem. And you seem to always show up whenever I say anything mildly political to attack me for the same reasons. You can't tolerate someone who points out the truth. Because, if I were wrong, you would have made an argument. You didn't. You attacked me, not the point.
- tptacek 15y agoYou have a habit of reading personal attacks out of (pointed, perhaps rude) attacks on your arguments. You realize I have no idea who you even are, right?
- chc 15y agoI think the disconnect between you two lies in these areas: 1. Is the federal government empowered to make any law not expressly forbidden by the Constitution? 2. Are there any laws that the states are allowed to make for their own people and territory without being overridden by the federal government? The crux of your comments seems to lie in a practical argument — it's useful to have the government doing this stuff. nirvana's argument is strictly Constitutional, and is not interested in any conveniences that might be offered by bending the law. (For the record, I'm not 100% in agreement with either side here. I'm just trying to synthesize what I see as the difference in where you two are coming from.)
- tptacek 15y agoAs for (1), it seems like answering that question just gets us mired in what "expressly forbidden" means. As for (2), the Constitution settles this directly; laws enacted by the legislative branch of the federal government are the "supreme law of the land".
- cynicalkane 15y agoI know I promised I was done, but it's a day later and the conversation is still on the front page and still continuing. You want to argue about what nirvana thinks--well, nirvana thinks the FBI is unconstitutional. I believe I've shown this to be black-and-white, read-the-document wrong. The power of the executive to enforce the law is explicitly authorized. Okay, maybe there are some interesting questions about the proper scope of the Commerce Clause, but why are we framing this debate according to the terms of someone who has no clue what he's talking about?
- nirvana 15y ago>I believe I've shown this to be black-and-white, read-the-document wrong. No you haven't. You provided two quotes from the constitution, referring to the limited powers I was talking about, and thus your quotes completely support my position. I've pointed this out already. This means either you know that you've failed and all your interested in is adhominem-- which means you're incapable of making an argument here. Or you're simply not bright enough to comprehend the point I'm making, which I've illuminated several times. The problem is, you can't be bothered to read the constitution, and what the constitution says doesn't really matter to your ideology, so you're just going to throw out unsupported nonsense, along with your personal attacks, and act like you've smugly shown me to be wrong. You have utterly failed. Every time you characterize me, its because you can't rebut my point. And you can't rebut my point because my point is correct. Its correct because I've actually read the constitution. You should try it sometime. I'm unlikely to respond because you always post the same stuff, generally ad hominem, and you never defend your points. But your running around and engaging in ad hominem is apparently not embarrassing enough even when others point it out. You and the others doing the same thing destroyed HN, you've made rational discussion impossible.
- cynicalkane 15y agoArticle II, which I quoted, gives the president power to enforce laws. Article I, which I quoted, twice, gives Congress power to legislate this into existence. Article I gives Congress power to legislate any necessary and proper laws for any branch of government. As I have already said. There times, counting now. I even italicized the relevant parts for you when I repeated myself the other time. Also, stop downvoting anyone who contradicts you. To downvote everyone not on your side is against the spirit of this site.