5 ms·
> why Bush 43 was supportive of China joining the WTO. First, It was Clinton, Bush 1, and Bush 2. Secondly, this was because of how (then much richer) Indones
by alephnerd 3y ago
> why Bush 43 was supportive of China joining the WTO.
First, It was Clinton, Bush 1, and Bush 2.
Secondly, this was because of how (then much richer) Indonesia, Philippines, South Korea, Thailand, Brazil, Mexico, Turkiye, and Eastern Europe democratized in the 1980s-90s.
With those priors, it made sense to assume that economic integration and growth leads to calls for democracy.
The jury's still out on this btw - China's median income in the 2020s is still 33-50% that of Thailand's, Mexico's, Poland's, Serbia's, and Turkiye's in the 2020s and these countries are still in the process of democratizing.
> didn't slam the door shut on China after Tienanmen Square
PRC was sanctioned by the US and the west in the 1990s in the aftermath of the massacre. This was why ascension happened so late.
People forget that before the 2000s, most foreign investors to China were mostly from South East Asia and Taiwan.
Western countries didn't enter until the mid-2000s.
- eunos 3y ago> China's median income in the 2020s is still 33-50% that of Thailand's, Mexico's, Poland's, and Turkiye's in the 2020s and these countries are still in the process of democratizing Uhh no https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/thailand/annual-household-income-per-capita https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/thailand/annual-househ... Regarding "democratization" I'd say again that the most effective killers of Chinese democracy movement are Pompeo and Trump.
- alephnerd 3y agoCEIC's data is incorrect. LET ME REPEAT. CIEC has data transformation issues. The median household income in Thailand is around $7,000 [0] versus around $4,000 [1] in China - both are government provided statistics. > Regarding "democratization" I'd say again that the most effective killers of Chinese democracy movement are Pompeo and Trump In a way, but more so the economic stagnation and massive inequality towards the end of the Hu Jintao era as the Bo Xilai scandal proved. [0] - http://statbbi.nso.go.th/staticreport/page/sector/th/08.aspx http://statbbi.nso.go.th/staticreport/page/sector/th/08.aspx [1] - https://www.stats.gov.cn/english/PressRelease/202201/t20220118_1826649.html https://www.stats.gov.cn/english/PressRelease/202201/t202201...
- eunos 3y agoIf you read the link from Chinese govt statistic it says that it is DISPOSABLE. "In 2021, the per capita disposable income of residents in China reached 35,128 yuan, a nominal increase of 9.1 percent over the previous year".
- alephnerd 3y agoIf you read Thai it's disposable as well [0]. There are so many data transformation problems on CEIC that I don't trust it. For example with Malaysia and Latvia This is why I equally distrust Statisa for similar reasons. Use primary sources instead of secondary sources as they say. [0] - https://www.nso.go.th/nsoweb/storage/survey_detail/2023/20231018103954_32528.pdf https://www.nso.go.th/nsoweb/storage/survey_detail/2023/2023...
- Aunche 3y agoI don't read Thai, but both Google and ChatGPT translate รายได้โดยเฉลี่ยต่อเดือนต่อครัวเรือน รายจังหวัด พ.ศ. as "average monthly household income" rather than median. I find it rather difficult to believe that median incomes are Thailand because prices seem lower in Bangkok than even a tier 3 city in China.
- alephnerd 3y agoThai to English translation via Google Translate is utter trash for some reason, but here's the Disposable Income stats the Thai Govt provided [0] and matches the data I provided above. Also, Thai B1/2 refusal rates are significantly lower than Chinese B1/2 rates (B1/2 is largely judged based on economic capacity) and Thailand doesn't even have an exit pass requirement. Also, Thai citizens can travel to SK and JP visa free but Chinese can't, which further proves the point. > prices seem lower in Bangkok than even a tier 3 city in China Because of housing. After the Housing Market crash happened in 1997 due to overbuilding, Thailand has a severe deflationary period similar to what China is facing today. Most Western FMCGs in ASEAN are also manufactured in Thailand and don't have a luxury tax (0% in Thailand versus 30-40% in China), which has helped keep prices low. This and the large Chinese Thai community is why Thailand became a popular tourist destination for middle class Chinese before COVID [0] - https://www.nso.go.th/nsoweb/storage/survey_detail/2023/20231018103954_32528.pdf https://www.nso.go.th/nsoweb/storage/survey_detail/2023/2023...
- some_random 3y agoSo in 1989 there was this event called the Tiananmen Square massacre where an unknown number (probably in the thousands) of pro-democracy student protesters were killed by the PLA. This is what really kicked off the modern anti-democratic political repression in China. To the best of my knowledge neither Pompeo nor Trump were involved, but I guess you never know!
- lenerdenator 3y agoCorrelation is not causation. There's been this idea that a shift towards market economics _caused_ the collapse of the authoritarian regimes in the countries you mentioned. It is simply _correlated_ with it. If there were causation, China would be an economic backwater to this day, and my iPhone would have been made in Romania. The fact is, a large plurality of those holding capital today is not in favor of a market economy. Markets are hard. You have to compete. You have to keep customers happy. You have to constantly find the next big thing. You stand to lose a lot because everything I just mentioned includes a lot of risk by nature. These holders of capital are in fact far more in line with feudalism. Feudalism merged holders of monetary and political power into one entity: all of the economic value and capital were held by lords, who also had the ability to use the force of the state to marshal means of production to make more economic value for them at the exclusion of those who wanted to compete with the lords, or peasants/serfs who wanted more of the value they produced. This is why many modern capital holders _love_ the People's Republic of China: they get to do what they want with the non-human means of production, and the CCP will use its authoritarian regime to make sure that the human means of production doesn't cause too much trouble. When Obama asked Steve Jobs why Apple didn't make the iPhone in the US, Jobs basically stated (and I'm paraphrasing here) that American producers wouldn't do whatever it took to make him happy. If he had a change he wanted on a piece of hardware, he could tell his suppliers to make it so immediately. There would be no dealing with labor unions, no dealing with environmental regulations, no dealing with health and safety. The CCP won't do that because these capital holders cut them in on the revenue at the expense of the society the CCP rules over.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Correlation is not causation. 100% in agreement with you. Though by every single measure, China in 2023 hasn't reached the economic inflection point that Taiwan, South Korea, etc hit in the late 1980s-90s. The key commonality between those countries that became democracies and those that didn't was inequality and economic stagnation. Those that worked on rapidly decreasing inequality saw broad support for maintaining a Liberal instead of Illiberal Democracy (Eg. Taiwan, South Korean, Poland recently, etc) whereas those who saw economic stagnation after proto-democratization fell to Illiberal Democracy or Authoritarianism (Eg. Hungary, Russia, Turkiye, Thailand, etc). This is because of the "devil you know" fallacy that becomes justified if democracy or proto-democracy hasn't return any results. China is in a weird position where it's able to compete with Advanced Economies in certain fields, but by most standards is still a developing country. You can have Beijing have first world level standards, but Tibet have living standards comparable to the poorer states of India. > modern capital holders _love_ the People's Republic of China: they get to do what they want with the non-human means of production Then why move manufacturing to less authoritarian Mexico, India, Thailand, etc or equally authoritarian Vietnam?!? Why not continue manufacturing in North Korea like South Korean companies used to do? This is a fallacy that ignores the reality of operational margins and capacity.