4 ms·
FAA says 737 MAX operator discovered loose bolts in rudder system in December
- s3r3nity 3y agoIs there anyone with an actuarial / risk management background in this community that could explain how this is going to impact industry insurance rates? e.g. is Boeing going to have astronomically high costs? Are airlines with 737 Max's going to also have to pay more? etc. etc.
- ars 3y agoInsurance cares more about actual crashes. Of which there have not been a lot. If anything all this attention should reduce insurance costs, since the planes will now be even more reliable than before. Insurance does not care about the appearance of risk, or bad press.
- ThrowawayTestr 3y agoI think two crashes in less than a year is a lot.
- s3r3nity 3y agoI’m not sure this is true. You can buy insurance on virtually any potential loss risk, like how celebrities can buy insurance for body parts: they obviously haven’t lost said parts, but that doesn’t mean the insurer charges $0.
- ars 3y agoOther humans however, have lost body parts, so the risk is known. They don't charge $0, but they don't charge very much either.
- SoftTalker 3y agoInsurance rates are largely based on actual loss experience, maybe 737 MAX will cost a bit more in light of recent events, but 737 and other Boeing models have been flying for decades and are a very safe airplanes overall with a very well-known loss risk profile.
- cratermoon 3y ago> 737 and other Boeing models have been flying for decades and are a very safe airplanes overall with a very well-known loss risk profile. This is the catch, though. The 737 MAX is a 737 in name only. It's a bit of a ship of Theseus design, because Boeing management didn't want to take on the cost and time to build a new plane from the ground up. The company was under pressure from the A321neo and wanted something fast. Certifying a new aircraft also takes time and money. By altering a 737 Boeing was able to claim it was still a 737 and retain the type certificate and, important for the airlines buying it, not have to retrain pilots on a new type. Like many other things in creaky corners of the commercial passenger airline industry, the foundation is from the 1960s. Solid and appropriate for the time, it's now aged and unsuitable for modern applications. Like building an extra story on a house with a foundation made for a single story, the compounded risks introduce so many unknowns as to make it impossible to calculate the real risks. Insurance companies should look at the MAX again and consider whether or not it deserves to be classed in the same risk profile as the 737 type.
- avalys 3y agoThis is old news, this occurred in December and was covered extensively at the time. This article is covering some FAA follow-up as if it is a newly reported issue.
- diggan 3y ago> This article is covering some FAA follow-up as if it is a newly reported issue. The second paragraph in the article literally contains "from an operator in December of last year"
- system2 3y agoYes, this also makes the title extremely clickbait.
- dang 3y agoWe've put December in the title above. Thanks!
- rootusrootus 3y agoI think now that these are becoming hot news, we should get some context. I.e. is this a somewhat routine occurrence that gets found and addressed? It seems unlikely that anyone builds absolutely perfect airplanes, which is why we have so many checklists and inspections, in addition to designs that are tolerant of faults. My monkey brain would like to know what normal looks like, before it gets all spun up...
- dylan604 3y agoThere's a comment from people that do not like sky diving along the lines of "why would I jump out of a perfectly good airplane?" The typical response from pilots or mechanics is "there's no such thing as a perfectly good airplane".
- rootusrootus 3y agoWe also used say "because the door was open!", which is more humorous now in light of the recent Alaska Airlines flight than it used to be.
- DriverDaily 3y ago737 Max is going to end up being one of the safest planes to fly in. Every inch of every plane combed over, every engineering decision re-examined, every system and sensor double-checked for redundancy and reliability, the pilots alert for any sign of problems.
- josemanuel 3y agoDo you really believe that?
- likeabbas 3y agoEngineering can’t always combat a poor integral structure.
- bootlooped 3y agoIf that's true why wasn't it already made the safest after the two Max 8 crashes that killed everybody on board.
- ducttapecrown 3y agoBecause they kept letting Boeing do (or not do) the inspections?
- diggan 3y ago> 737 Max is going to end up being one of the safest planes to fly in It already has two crashes under its belt, compared to other models that never had any crashes (like the A380). But I guess if we put the disclaimer "From today on!" then it might be accurate.
- pdpi 3y agoHopefully the whole 737 MAX fiasco will lead to Boeing understanding that their current strategy is penny-wise but pound-foolish. At some point the extra money from cutting corners will be completely eclipsed by the monetary and reputational damage from all this chaos.
- cptskippy 3y agoUntil executive compensation is tied to long term performance this won't happen. They are free to institute policies that will cripple or kill a company and then jump ship and find greener pastures.
- FredPret 3y agoI wonder how this could be made to work. Maybe huge stock grants that vest over a very long period. And maybe stock owners shouldn’t hire non-engineers to run their aircraft firm.
- cptskippy 3y ago> And maybe stock owners shouldn’t hire non-engineers to run their aircraft firm. Stock owners are part of the problem. Stock is traded regularly and there's nothing forcing the owner of a stock to remain the owner. Stock owners expect short term growth and quarterly returns, this motivates them to hire executives who will deliver. As soon as the company shows any signs of weakness they can either break it up or cash out and abandon it. * And the problem has been exacerbated by the Stock Market and the ease and speed with which stocks can be bought and sold.
- FredPret 3y agoStock owners are responsible for everything that happen to their company. The buck stops with the owners. But short-termers usually end up transferring their capital to long-termers. I bet the majority of investors are short-termers, but the majority of the capital is in long-term hands.
- 3y ago
- pcdoodle 3y agoRudder is optional anyways, thanks MSFS 5.0 :)
- vundercind 3y agoIt’s definitely a far less serious problem than losing, say, elevator control.
- TriangleEdge 3y agoI find the phenomena of viral news interesting. I assume most people in the USA don't want to think about the engineering of planes. In Canada, as of this writing, car theft news has become viral, but car theft is not new or unusual. My question is: do all social beings have attention surges? Are attention surges required to be social? Flocks of birds and schools of fish all react in unison to input from a few I suppose.