You say Gemini “nailed it”, but that’s just because it guessed what you were thinking, not because it knew the right answer. For example, it’s equally valid to

You say Gemini “nailed it”, but that’s just because it guessed what you were thinking, not because it knew the right answer. For example, it’s equally valid to say that Tabitha likes small foods since cookies are small and cakes are large, and lamb is the smaller younger version of sheep — also known as mutton. Hence she likes cherries because they’re smaller… or taste better… or her uncle abused her with a pear… or whatever. You haven’t actually asked a logic question where there is a clear and unambiguous answer that can be derived using formal methods starting from clearly stated axioms. If you gave this question to a bunch of humans, they would give you inconsistent guesses as well — not because they’re wrong but because the question has no single right answer.