4 ms·
Here's another one. This is a classic logic puzzle - usually about ducks. There are two pineapples in front of a pineapple, two pineapples behind a pineapple
by jonplackett 3y ago
Here's another one.
This is a classic logic puzzle - usually about ducks.
There are two pineapples in front of a pineapple, two pineapples behind a pineapple and a pineapple in the middle. How many pineapples are there?
When you use ducks, Gemini can do it, when you use pineapples it cannot and thinks there are 5 instead of 3.
ChatGPT 3.5 and 4 can do it.
The even funnier thing is if you then say to gemini, hey - would the answer be the same if it was ducks? it says NO then there would be 3 ducks and explains why.
Then if you say, but wouldn't the same logic apply to pineapples? It says 'oh yeah!'.
Anyone saying I am just playing with a silly thing, I say no - this is testing reasoning ability and understanding which is the number one thing I want.
ChatGPT appears to have a more generalised ability to reason whereas Gemini is only reciting its training data.
- jonas21 3y agoAs a human, I think the correct answer is 7. This isn't so much a logic puzzle as an ambiguous sentence that can be parsed multiple ways.
- motoxpro 3y agoyeah, as little as 3 at most infinity.
- saberience 3y agoI mean, I thought and still think the answer is five… am I an AI or a human? If the answer is so ambiguous that humans and AI get it wrong, is it really that great of a question?
- huytersd 3y agoThe way I parsed that sentence, I came up with 5.
- fragmede 3y agoHate to break it to you but I did too. Apparently that means we're both LLMs. I coulda sworn I had a whole childhood and everything but apparently I've always been a GPT.
- whatevertrevor 3y agoThis is less of a logic puzzle and more of a riddle. It would be a logic puzzle if the question was around the lines of "What is the least number of pineapples that satisfies these constraints?"