4 ms·
As a heavy user of Flex for my start-up, I have to, heavy-heartedly, agree with the main point of this article. Wake up Macrobe! Ajax, as loose and amorphous a
by swombat 18y ago
As a heavy user of Flex for my start-up, I have to, heavy-heartedly, agree with the main point of this article.
Wake up Macrobe! Ajax, as loose and amorphous and crap as it is still today, is going to eat your lunch!
Flex Builder should be free and open-source and Adobe should encourage people to improve on it. They could steal much of the effort that's currently going into other RIA platforms by being more openly supportive and aggressively marketing that openness. The fact that they don't do that is simply mind-boggling.
- tomsaffell 18y agoI'm in the same position as you, and I agree. The thing I find so puzzling about the Flex Builder pricing is the dissonance in pricing from student to company. For the pro version students pay $0, companies pay $700. I interpret '$0 for students' as 'adoption is more important than direct revenue today'. But if that is so, why charge companies $700? They also have impact on adoption. A MSFT esque 'start-up deal' would seem appropriate if they must have some direct revenue. Or better still, make the standard version free to all. I took part in an interview with Adobe a few months back regarding Flex Builder, specifically on the topic of whether I would buy it. As I said to them then, "it's too much money". Silverlight doesn't do what I need, but if it did, I'd be seriously considering it. Why are there so few free alternatives to Flex Builder? Is it because it's so easy to pirate that no-one has bothered?
- tomsaffell 18y agoWell, I just found Flash Develop today, which at first glance seems to be a decent IDE for Flex and AS. http://www.flashdevelop.org/community/viewforum.php?f=11 http://www.flashdevelop.org/community/viewforum.php?f=11
- mcargian 18y agoCan I ask why you chose Flex over the Ajax approach? What features were only in Flex that you felt this was a better approach?
- swombat 18y agoSeveral reasons, but the key one was that to build the kind of user experience we were aiming for, Ajax would have been a major, major, major nightmare - and probably not even possible (especially 1.5 years ago, but still today). With Flex, we got a very different set of compromises that worked out much better for the users.
- flashgordon 18y agoactually i agree.. if you want a UI that is consistent and easy to build, flex has a few hands up over ajax... ive been using flex builder for linux for a while... and frankly after trying out the windows (fully functional) trial version, i felt the windows version did not justify the price... sure there are a couple of superficial things the windows version has (like the design view - which is "ok").. only gripe is the linux version is still in alpha so feel a bit jibbed and not to mention hesitant paying full price for it... the real issue for me is they are leveraging so much of the eclipse framework to build an IDE, they should have more of an obligation to give it away for free, unlike MS (with its VS products)
- fizx 18y agoSeparate experience, but we chose Flex because the typographic control, while quite broken, still beats HTML/JS. I wrote a WYSIWYG editor for brochures and other printed marketing materials.