11 ms·
A seafood firm wants to farm octopus. Activists say they're too smart for that
- weregiraffe 3y agoAre they smarter than pigs?
- mouse_ 3y agoPigs are pretty smart, too.
- corethree 3y agoSmarter then dogs. The criteria for edibility is mainly ugliness vs. Cuteness. Octopuses are recently getting more media attention with that movie about the diver that made friends with one so they are getting cuter. Try farm raising and eating baby penguins you'll get the same reaction even though penguins are dumb AF. It has nothing to do with intelligence.
- irrational 3y agoYou bring up a good point about penguins. They and chickens are both birds, so why are we finally eating chickens but not penguins? Cuteness definitely plays a role.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoChickens have been domesticated a long time ago because they were around, flightless, and easy to breed. You won't even see a penguin until you reach high latitudes and they eat fish... Even if they both tasted good (which I have no idea) very obvious practical reasons would explain the difference.
- corethree 3y agoThat's the practicality for why thing are the way they are. My argument is about starting up a baby penguin slaughterhouse in the north pole right now and how much activist resistance you will get versus a crocodile meat slaughter house in Florida.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoDemand and economic viability. Likely the usual explanation.
- boring_twenties 3y agoI'm pretty sure there are no crocodiles in Florida, only alligators.
- dendrite9 3y agoThere are crocodiles but they are less common than alligators. https://myfwc.com/wildlifehabitats/profiles/reptiles/american-crocodile/ https://myfwc.com/wildlifehabitats/profiles/reptiles/america...
- boring_twenties 3y agoOh wow, another reason to be terrified to go to Florida :)
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoFor some reason I think penguins would taste very rich and gamey. I think I'm imagining this due to their cold resistance implying large amounts of fat. Anyone know?
- corethree 3y agoLots of umami. Especially the baby ones that still have fur. I get hungry just thinking about it. The adults get too muscular from all the torpedoing through the water.
- FinnKuhn 3y agoBecause penguins can't be kept where most humans live due to temperature.
- corethree 3y agoIt's ok. It can be like wagyu. Imported fresh baby penguin meat straight from the north pole.
- irrational 3y agoSouth pole. Penguins life in Antarctica and regions thereabouts while polar bears live in the Arctic.
- corethree 3y agoIt's like Himalayan sea salt. It's just marketing jargon.
- salad-tycoon 3y agoBuffalo wings, white chocolate, spotted dick, monkey bread, impossible meat, and the worst: Kraft Parmesan (it’s actually saw dust, partly).
- randerson 3y agoNot true for all species. The African penguin can be found along the south western coastline of Africa.
- tialaramex 3y agoMy only rationale for why it's OK for me to eat pigs is that the pigs would definitely eat me if the opportunity arose, and in this respect they are different from say, cows, or indeed octopuses, which show no inclination to consume human meat. If you (as sometimes happens to farmers) drop dead in a pig sty after not long the pigs will eat you because you're food and they're hungry.
- collingreen 3y agoCats will do this too; do you support eating house cats?
- rangerelf 3y agoDo you?
- tialaramex 3y agoI think cats would taste awful but if other people want to eat cats I have no objection that wouldn't just as well apply to my consumption of pork.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoI've had some friends/family spend time in Haiti. Feral "domestic" cats are a delicacy and the hunt itself is part of the enjoyment.
- ultrarunner 3y agoThis argument has appeared multiple times in this thread, and I'm genuinely curious: if pigs' behavior demonstrates to you that their status is low enough to warrant their treatment, why does adopting that behavior seem like a reasonable reaction? Or would you find a pig killing and eating a human to be a morally neutral incident that, while maybe not preferable, has no ultimate weight to consider?
- tialaramex 3y ago
- PrimeMcFly 3y ago> Smarter then dogs. Certainly not. I'm not sure why this myth keeps propagating.
- corethree 3y agohttps://www.dogster.com/lifestyle/are-pigs-smarter-than-dogs https://www.dogster.com/lifestyle/are-pigs-smarter-than-dogs
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoThe source of the myth, perhaps?
- corethree 3y agoOr your statement is a myth and you're one of the sources.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoAnd maybe the moon is made of cheese :) That aside, if you would stop spreading the myth, that would be better for everybody.
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoBest reason to go back!
- corethree 3y agoWell no you're the one spreading the myth. Stop. Thanks. Also being quite rude and dismissive as well. No thanks.
- PrimeMcFly 3y ago> Well no you're the one spreading the myth Sigh. No. Pigs are not more intelligent than dogs. That's flat out misinformation, and you are propagating misinformation, i.e. spreading a myth every time you repeat that false information. I don't think I'm being rude, although I don't have a lot of patient for people that willfully spread misinformation. Maybe, just maybe, do some more research other than believing what the first link in your Google search results brings up.
- tekla 3y agoI wonder if its easier to grow octopus flesh vs meat. Meat has the issue of all the blood vessels and stuff, but my off the head take seems that octopus might avoid that sort of issue?
- davedx 3y agoOctopus tentacles are semiautonomous
- boring_twenties 3y agoYeah, I went to a Korean place serving "live octopus." They bring it out and cut it up with scissors in front of you. The individual pieces of tentacle continue to move and flex. If you don't chew them real good they will try to suction to your throat (and possibly choke you to death). Turnabout is fair play, I guess
- alwa 3y agoOctopus flesh has the issue of containing the majority of the octopus’ neurons [0]. Life is weird. [0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-mind-of-an-octopus/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-mind-of-an-oc...
- surgical_fire 3y agoI wonder is this is what makes octopus meat tasty.
- davedx 3y agoUgh what next, farm chimpanzees for their meat?
- webkike 3y agoI mean, they aren’t farmed for meat but monkey farms do exist: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2024/01/28/monkey-farm-breeding-medical-science-research/72339272007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2024/01/28/monkey...
- alwa 3y agoNot to be low-effort, but you know Soylent Green is people, right? I always was a little mystified at their choice of name over at the actual Soylent meal replacement company. And their choice to feature their green Soylent product as the main banner on their webpage.
- AlwaysRock 3y agoI always thought it was kind of tongue in cheek.
- collingreen 3y agoIt is; they even made a limited edition joke product that leaned all the way in called "Soylent Green - as good as humanly possible". I love sharing them on hiking trips although they are more funny than tasty.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoWe don't eat chimps much. We do eat a lot of octopuses.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoTake too long to reach maturity. Many octopuses live just a year or two. Takes no time to get to maturity. Anyway, whales and dolphins eat them too.
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoI always wince when I see octopus on a menu. Or on a plate.
- hasty_pudding 3y agoNot trying to be a SJW but a drove an 18 wheeler for a year and would pick up meat from slaughter houses and the way they treat those animals is god forsakenly bad.They put hundreds of chickens in a room and spray water with electrical current into it. The cows would come in on trucks just terrified with the walls covered in their own feces. Not even going to get started on the conditions in which they are raised. It made me really cut down on my meat eating and pay the extra for local farm raised meat. Im not even against eating meat! I just think the mass industrialization of slaughter is messed up. If you look at almost every menu though its like 90% meat so the amount of meat we consume on America is remarkable. Capitalism is really good at hiding horrible abuse of people and animals behind a veneer of civilization and the abstraction of a blameless neutral currency.
- jjtheblunt 3y agoCapitalism isn’t unique by any means in that correct observation
- hasty_pudding 3y agoCurrency abstracts abuse into a neutral system of value and capitalism/industrialism enables this at a massive scale.
- hasty_pudding 3y agoSame thing happens with drug cartel money
- chr-s 3y agoUnfortunately, your local farm raised meat might still go to that big slaughterhouse. It's expensive for small farmers to run their own on-site USDA inspected slaughterhouse. Also, the chickens you eat are still likely suffering for much of their lives even if raised on a local farm. The best thing that could happen to broiler chickens is for them to go extinct.
- lupire 3y ago
- s_dev 3y agoThe real problem is that nearly all seafood is unsustainable. Even when using euphemisms like 'farms' make us thing it's somewhat contained to one place and we just throw them some food pellets manufactured from vegetables in another factory. The reality of salmon farms for instance is that for every 1kg of farmed Salmon it takes 20kg of wild fish to feed them to maturity.
- maxglute 3y agoThere's a lot of shit ton of algaes blooming due to climate change. Wonder if that can be sourced as protein / feed.
- lawlessone 3y agoA lot of those algae are poisonous.
- seunosewa 3y agoThe ocean food web rests on algae. Every creature in the sea eats algae indirectly. Every wild-caught fish.
- jprete 3y agoThat's not a reasonable way to think about it in this context. If a small fish eats algae that is poisonous to us, it's likely able to metabolize the poison and not itself be poisonous to its predators or to us.
- maxglute 3y agoSo poisonous that they can't be industrially processed? Or no one has bothered to try for feedstock. Genuinely curious.
- pvaldes 3y agoSo poisonous that when cattle is feed with it daily, its grow is stunted
- SirWart 3y agoI visited an experimental octopus farm in Hawaii once, expecting to come away feeling guilty about eating octopus since I had heard so much about how smart they are. It ended up having the opposite effect, since I learned that they only live 2 years and aren't social creatures. This is opposite of every other intelligent creature that we know of, and so I'm extremely skeptical of claims of their intelligence. They might show sophisticated behavior, but so do a lot of insects like ants and we know they aren't intelligent. EDIT: sorry, when I say intelligent, I mean as intelligent as animals that we generally do not eat. I believe they are less intelligent than livestock, but can learn behaviors like most animals.
- jjtheblunt 3y agoWhat? How do we know whatever is not intelligent?
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoBy studying behavior and neurology.
- pvaldes 3y agoIf is dead and cooked is dumber than a stone at that moment, so we can eat it
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoThey are absolutely intelligent, there is no question. I've owned several. The way they can earn to communicate and solve puzzles puts them in the same category as crows, apes, elephants dolphins, etc.
- lp4vn 3y ago>This is opposite of every other intelligent creature that we know of, and so I'm extremely skeptical of claims of their intelligence. Octopuses can demonstrably learn: scientists put food inside a pot with a lid and gave the pot to an octopus. If my memory doesn't fail me, in the first attempt the octopus took 2 hours to open the lid and in the second one it took 5 minutes.
- jpmattia 3y agoThe older I get, the less I want anything sentient on my plate.
- demondemidi 3y agoI never used to care, but I feel the same way as I ease into my 6th decade.
- Ekaros 3y agoI on other hand am still saddened at this age that I can't get dog or cat meat here...
- dbspin 3y agoI'm genuinely curious, is this just edgy humour, or is there any culture that regularly eats cat?
- Ekaros 3y agoIs it really any different from any other animal? So why would it not have possibility to be on plate? After all one of my life bucket lists is to taste as many species as possible...
- steve_adams_86 3y agoThis is exactly why I don't want to eat them. As an animal, yes, I can identify that they are in fact like other animals; they are like me, for instance. I don't want to eat things like me, because I don't want to be eaten. That's why it's not possible to put a cat on my plate. That logic goes both ways, and the variables in the equation are values-based.
- mrguyorama 3y agoFunny because those cats and dogs would happily eat you. Not in a "cats eat their dead owners sense" but in the sense that dogs and cats are pretty un-discerning when they are hungry. The real reason to not eat cats and dogs is that they are mediocre food
- BowBun 3y agoI don't think it's reasonable to draw an arbitrary line while farming other animals is allowed. We have and do eat octopus, and that isn't changing. They're more likely to go extinct if unfettered consumption isn't offset by farming.
- seadan83 3y agoSalmon farms turn out to be bad news. Profit motive has them being packed in, the "run-off" is too concentrated and poisons the surrounding water. The fish themselves are unhealthy and their meat bad. Further, sometimes salmon escape the farm in waters where they are not native. In effect, letting tens of thousands of an invasive species loose. I'm sure some salmon farms are sustainable, but the reputation for industrial fish farming has gone to crap. An octopus farm probably would not allow each individual to have their own little home and space to search for and collect shiny rocks. Industrial farming of animals tends to not go very well in the long run.
- BowBun 3y agoThose are very good points, and totally agree that large-scale farming today of nearly any food source is perverted to the point of being awful. I'd like to see a balance between clear regulation for humane treatment of animals _before_ abuse becomes rampant, and security for new food sources to be developed as we inevitably need them in the future.
- yndoendo 3y agoThey are also great for finding out if a person is an extremist. Example, to find out if someone is infatuated with say Elon Musk. Just make the statement, "You know that an octopus has more brains than Elon Musk". Their emotions take hold and they will go off and as now they don't person so and so is smarter. Yet it is 100% true that an octopus as more brains than any living human. One for each tentacle and an main, 9 brains total. Where a human as one or two, depending whom you are speaking with. https://neuroscience.stanford.edu/news/your-gut-second-brain https://neuroscience.stanford.edu/news/your-gut-second-brain
- solardev 3y agoThey're probably smart enough that we could train them to farm each other. Split them into two groups, give them limited food, and make them duke it out in underwater coliseums. Winners get to raise the next generation, losers become sushi :( Hell, attach some livestreaming, raise some money, sic a few LLMs on them... we can probably learn to talk to them in a decade, teach them to ride dolphins, then invite them onto land to manage other livestock, or fight on UFC...
- nerpderp82 3y agoBut that is what we do at the FAANGs
- TylerE 3y agoI’ve seen videos that show frightening intelligence. The biggest limiting factor is that they don’t live very long… 2 years is well past Middle Aged. I’ve read reports of pet octopi that are so curious they climb out of Their tank to explore or be nearer their owner… and can’t get back in, which is fatal on a fairly short time frame
- burnished 3y agoThe Seattle aquarium had a weird issue with fish going missing for some time (weeks? Months?), the culprit was their octopus letting itself out at night and returning before morning.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoToshio from Startide Rising comes to mind. I recall another story featuring an octopus bred for intelligence who manages an octopus-only landing vehicle on Titan or something, she smuggles her babies up and then they reproduce in the habitat and...I can't recall how it ends!
- ssfrr 3y agoSounds like Stephen baxter’s Manifold: Time. She’s a squid not an octopus, but same idea. Great book!
- mcculley 3y agoI do not care how smart they are. I want to know if they suffer.
- youcantcook 3y ago[dead]
- wedernoch 3y agoI often think the same about people I (get to) know
- stri8ed 3y agoIt's impossible to prove.
- azemetre 3y agoIs it? Watching animals attack other animals, suffering seems very likely. What’s the reason why science would dismiss it? That the animal doesn’t fill out a survey afterwards?
- lupire 3y agoYou can't even prove if humans suffer. What is suffering?
- m1n7 3y agoIf I were to make dinner out of you, you'd probably agree that that's suffering—no need to get more philosophical than that.
- efitz 3y agoWe know that octopuses and many other animals are intelligent. We don't know for certain if anything nonhuman is sentient. Scientists and activist groups have been designing frameworks for sentience and tests to measure it. This paper [1] (about crabs, but discusses octopuses) has a very interesting section talking about defining and measuring sentience. It was used to support a recent bill in the UK [2] attempting to reduce cruelty to sentient animals. Octopuses measured very high in their testing. [1] https://www.lse.ac.uk/News/News-Assets/PDFs/2021/Sentience-in-Cephalopod-Molluscs-and-Decapod-Crustaceans-Final-Report-November-2021.pdf https://www.lse.ac.uk/News/News-Assets/PDFs/2021/Sentience-i... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_Welfare_(Sentience)_Act_2022 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_Welfare_(Sentience)_Act...
- dweinus 3y agoRight. Maybe it is hard to prove, but the choice to eat them is a life-or-death decision. I am going to opt for tofu. Given that "sentience" is roughly the ability to have feelings, it seems very hard to believe most animals are not sentient. Spend a day with a cat or on a farm and you will witness emotions. Do octopuses have feelings? The paper is pretty confident: "There is very strong evidence of sentience in octopods". It seems likely to me that animals that are distant from humans are harder for us to understand, but still sentient.
- PrimeMcFly 3y ago> We know that octopuses and many other animals are intelligent. We don't know for certain if anything nonhuman is sentient. You are mixing up terms. All animals are sentient. Not all animals are intelligent. Only very few animals appear to be sapient. Octopuses are certainly one of the few animals that appear to be beyond a reasonable doubt.
- shaneofalltrad 3y agoThe confusion is how Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022 determines this, with the wrong definition of sentient to determine legalities, even seeing news articles describing it as so, for example https://www.gov.uk/government/news/animals-to-be-formally-recognised-as-sentient-beings-in-domestic-law https://www.gov.uk/government/news/animals-to-be-formally-re...
- scythe 3y agoThere's something I don't really understand in this discussion, and though it looks like it's already been flagged, I suppose I'll try my luck anyway. The question "is it ethical to farm octopus?" sounds to me a little like the question "should we allow primates to vote?". Obviously, we allow some primates to vote. "Octopus" does not describe a single species, or a single genus, or even a single family, but in fact an entire order of animals. "Primate", as you might recall, is also an order. I.e. we should expect the octopodans to be roughly as diverse, behaviorally and anatomically, as the primates. So: what gives? How can we generalize the observations of one or two kinds of octopus to hundreds of distantly related species?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoIs it ethical to farm primates?
- errantwalker 3y ago“The Thing cannot be described - there is no language for such abysms of shrieking and immemorial lunacy, such eldritch contradictions of all matter, force, and cosmic order. A mountain walked or stumbled. If I say that my somewhat extravagant imagination yielded simultaneous pictures of an octopus, a dragon, and a human caricature, I shall not be unfaithful to the spirit of the thing. A pulpy, tentacled head surmounted a grotesque and scaly body with rudimentary wings; but it was the general outline of the whole which made it most shockingly frightful.” Master BRUNCH. Pulpo a la Gallega (Polbo á feira)
- x-n2o 3y agoSign the petition: https://chng.it/pxLVCmWnGj https://chng.it/pxLVCmWnGj
- teeray 3y agoThis sounds like the setup for a horror movie. Deep Blue Sea, but octopi.
- lagrange77 3y agoYes, or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Swarm_(Sch%C3%A4tzing_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Swarm_(Sch%C3%A4tzing_nove...
- pvaldes 3y agoI wouldn't discard the alternative possibility that we should choose to ignore "activists". After all, people may have a hidden agenda, conflicts of interest, or be simply a bunch of uneducated morons craving for attention. Why to choose them as figure of authority at the same level of researchers that proven real effort searching for truth and spent ten years acquiring real knowledge? Oh, Is for the promises of violence. I see.
- lazyasciiart 3y agoWhat makes you dismiss the years of effort put in by researchers who are quoted supporting the activists?
- pvaldes 3y ago1) To start the science that they use is normally of subpar quality. Sometimes even fake. I can't see why two decades of sociology articles about how playing violin to octopuses make them more lively, should count more than two decades of biology articles looking for cures again each octopus disease known and found by farmers. One of this approaches helped greatly to reduce pain in octopuses, the other just wasted our time. 2) They cherry-pick facts relentlessly. Evidence that goes against their agenda are systematically ignored and the authors mocked. They have a tunnel vision about the themes or interpret the facts as is better for them. See point 1. 3) They pick random facts to push random taboos on some organisms, but declare other similar organisms moral to eat Just because they rank lower in their personal preferences or cultures. Cricket pie anyone? 4) They attribute malice or incompetence to their targets by default People trying to domesticate octopuses "moved by greed". Maybe they want to help alleviate famine? We don't speak about this. Only our acts are pure, they say, while keep asking for money. 5) As their science is weak, they are unable to foresee the holes in their plan, or the collateral damages of their acts. 6) Even worse, they know but choose to ignore the consequences After researchers spend their time informing them again and again of the collateral effects that their actions will have, they proclaim that is for a bigger cause and couldnn't care less about the consequences. They act by a sort of pseudo-religious ideology with random dogmas that can't be changed a Milimeter, even after proven false. Check the history of grey squirrel in Italy, or racoons on Japan. 7) They never, ever, will offer help to fix their own ecological disasters After they cause economical damages of millions of dollars and waste the time of everybody, then shrug and just change their target. 8) They are prone to be deceived and manipulated from outer agents with their own agendas, that treat them as disposable. People "against oil", are happy to be economically supported by oil companies. Are we sure that this activists aren't funded by <nice company killing lots of wild octopuses> to boycott <evil company farming domesticated octopuses>? or by somebody aiming to gain time to build their own farms?. I wouldn't bet my money against this.
- euroderf 3y agoAnyone wrestling with these issues could usefully read Animal Liberation by Pete Singer. He delves into many varieties of abstinence from speciesism (as he calls it).
- tiberious726 3y ago"Philosophy and Animal Life" is a collection of essays from the recent hard-hitters in English speaking philosophy
- Havoc 3y agoThe whole too smart thing seems so arbitrary to me. Like this animal can solve a puzzle thus it can't be farmed. The other animal can't. But if we scare/hurt them they both react in fear/pain. IQs are we talking here? Suduko? Puzzle? Open a door? Use a tool? Care for its youngs? Stand under roof when it rains? I can wrap my head around both stances (eat animals freely or full veg only)...bit this arbirary line in sand approach I struggle with. May as well go with an arbitrary "this one is cute so we won't eat it" approach
- lm28469 3y agoPeople arguing that would be happy if no animals were farmed at all. The opposite argument is equally dumb, you wouldn't legalize crack because beer is a drug and beer is legal
- foofie 3y ago> People arguing that would be happy if no animals were farmed at all. This. It's a propaganda angle to try to get non-activists to support their group's demands by adding a spin to their claims that makes it more engaging. The same blend of propaganda also includes things like showing a picture of a pig showing only its eyes, devised to underline their similarities with human eyes. They then proceed to draw a parallel between slaughtering pigs and humans. Another take is portraying cattle as pets, and you wouldn't kill your own pets now would you? In the end it's just propaganda to try to convince non-militants to unwittingly support a cause. It doesn't matter if it's arbitrary or outlandish. The goal is to sway you to do the militant's bidding.
- metta2uall 3y agoQuite odd to label people trying to end horrific violence as "militants"... And is it really outlandish to want to stop hurting animals that really are similar to cats, dogs and yes, us humans, at least as far as the ability to perceive pain and basic emotions. Perhaps the propaganda is actually that it is okay for non-human animals to endure horrific suffering, just so that some humans can spend a few minutes "enjoying" the taste of their flesh or breast-milk.. (the production of which also requiring huge amounts of plant-based feed, which significantly contributes to deforestation & methane emissions)
- 4b11b4 3y agoThis begs the question about pigs level of intelligence
- Log_out_ 3y agoWith knowledge power is gained and the power to commit atrocities is lost.
- nxobject 3y agoTruly, when I read "too smart for that", my mind went to "too smart to be kept in a farm", and "they're going to find creative ways to escape". And down that path lies a supermax masquerading as a farm...