4 ms·
> In fact, throughout much of our nation's history, law enforcement had no idea what kind of communications criminals had. The universe did not explode. Somehow
by crazygringo 15y ago
> In fact, throughout much of our nation's history, law enforcement had no idea what kind of communications criminals had. The universe did not explode. Somehow life went on.
Not really. Crime rates have been going down. Murder rates have been going down. People's lives have been saved, that wouldn't have "gone on" before.
This is due, in part, to better policing. To what extent this has do to with wiretapping abilities can be debated/analyzed, but a "somehow life went on" attitude is pretty much a blunt argument for "let's never change anything then", and is therefore irrelevant to the discussion.
- mapleoin 15y agoThis is due, in part, to better policing. That's... debatable. I think it's due to Disney movies.
- crazygringo 15y agoWell I didn't say it's entirely to better policing, hence the "in part". For a citation, why not look at the last part of this article which was very popular on HN a few months ago: http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2012/01/30/120130crat_atlarge_gopnik http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2012/01/30/120... 273 points: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3691372 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3691372 You're going to have a hard time debating that improved police techniques haven't made a difference at all, regardless of your personal opinion of Disney movies.
- kbolino 15y agoCrime rates could be going down because... 1. The methodology of collecting and reporting crime statistics has changed; 2. The use of said "improved police techniques" has discouraged people from reporting crimes; 3. The "justice" system has favored reducing its rate of Type I errors at the expense of increasing its Type II errors; 4. Enforcement of the laws is no longer consistent across and within jurisdictions; 5. There are more corrupt legal officials, and they are in better positions than ever before; 6. Social conditions and individual motivations have changed, and people are less inclined to commit crimes. I'm not saying any of these are true, but they are all equally plausible explanations (as is any combination of them). You cannot establish a causal relationship by correlation (and "common sense") alone; you must identify all of the variables and control for them.
- typicalrunt 15y agoAccording to Freakonomics, low crime rates are due to birth control and/or the ability of couples to decide when and where they want to have kids. [edit: birth control and the Rowe vs. Wade abortion ruling]
- crazygringo 15y agoThat argument is one theory, highly controversial. I'm certainly not saying it doesn't play a part, but it's still a hotly debated question among experts as to what is ultimately responsible for the crime drop. Most likely, it's due to a combination of factors, for the basic reason that social phenomena like crime tend to be very complicated. We would be extraordinarily lucky if it could be pinned down a single, simple explanation. And while the socioeconomic distribution of the population would be expected to play a part (which is certainly affected by family planning), it would be highly unlikely for progress in policing techniques not to play a part at all.
- crazygringo 15y agoDownvoted?? Really?! I'm pretty sure this is contributing to the discussion, no matter how unpopular it may be. I'm disappointed.
- gergles 15y agoIt's being downvoted because you're drawing an illusory correlation solely to be contrarian. This does not contribute to the discussion. I think the decreased crime rate is due to global warming! There's a perfect negative correlation between crime rate and average global temperature, so clearly the data support my opinion.
- crazygringo 15y agoNot at all. It's pretty far-fetched to say that any link between policing and crime rates is illusory. It's certainly not the only causation, but it would be ludicrous to say they weren't related. It is rather ludicrous to talk about global warming and crime, unless you can come up with a truly plausible mechanism for it. And I'm certainly not being contrarian either. I'm saying that the argument that "life went on" even when the government had no wiretapping ability, has no relevance here. You might as well say that life went on in the gulags in Russia. That's the point I'm arguing -- that "life went on" is not a valid argument in any context, because it's generic and doesn't address any of the actual issues. Oh well, go ahead and downvote away... it's only numbers! :P