3 ms·
I'm considering adding an additional layer of protection against grumps: to only allow users as many downvotes as they've made upvotes. That way each user's ne
by pg 19y ago
I'm considering adding an additional layer of protection against grumps: to only allow users as many downvotes as they've made upvotes. That way each user's net contribution to the global karma would be at least neutral.
- Dauntless 19y agoThat's an interesting idea. Another idea would be that they would "consume" some of the karma they made, when they downvote.
- Keios 19y agoWhy don't you publish the top 3 or 5 folks who up vote and down vote the most, maybe as an additional section on the leaders page. It might effect behavior interestingly.
- pg 19y agoI'd rather just make the system quietly do the right thing. Never do through social pressure what you could do through software.
- Keios 19y agoI understand. I hope news.yc doesn't become an overly serious place though. PS: As an after-thought, social pressure may be more adaptable than software.
- aston 19y agoI thought it was the other way around: never try to solve a social problem with software. The karma-neutral idea sounds like a good one, but then you remember that it's easy to create new accounts... Ultimately, you just have to depend on people to do good or leave.
- dood 19y agoA fair point, but there is a downvote threshold (20 points). Easy to overcome, but also easy to detect.
- rokhayakebe 19y agogood one.As a matter of fact I know who went around and down voted other users, but giving his username will not help my startup or any1s so (B....) I hope you have learned your lesson.
- staunch 19y agoI think the grumps might just upvote something random to get points to use against something they don't like. The result of upvoting something that's at 10 points is weaker than downvoting something at 1 point. Maybe take current score into account. Or possibly just put a limit on the number of downvotes you can do per day/week. We don't need nearly as many downvote points as upvote points to get good results. Viewing and not upvoting something is like half a downvote anyway. Maybe if you reply when past your limit you can then also downvote if you want.
- mark-t 19y ago> Viewing and not upvoting something is like half a downvote anyway. This statement depends a lot on your habits. I open up 5-10 links at a time and then read through them all. I rarely remember to go back and upvote, and I reserve that for _really_ good articles, anyway. And of course you can't say anything about comments, since there's no telling whether somebody even reads all the comments when he opens a page with comments on it.
- vlad 19y agoYes, somebody can just upvote 10 random things to get 10 negative 'credits.' How are they going to use all 10 on one article? Both arrows disappear after the first vote. And, the old articles can't be voted down any more. Finally, if the person decides to wait for somebody to post 9 more comments over the next 2 weeks or however frequently the user posts (so they can downvote them) the comment will still be current and the rest of the YC community will vote up the comment back to a positive number. It seems like a good solution to me.
- rokhayakebe 19y agoThank you, I just got 44 points back.
- rams 19y agoI am glad you're taking this seriously - reddit went down the tube (in terms of quality) mainly due to the better contributors getting tuned off by all the anti-social behaviour. advogato.org is a different kind of site - but they have a trust metric that seems to have withstood attacks pretty well - the reason I mention this is to point out the formal trust metric based approaches out there.
- dood 19y agoIs there value in karma-neutral interaction? Perhaps some users are better at up-voting and some better at down-voting.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]