2 ms·
New protection against karma bombing, damage undone
- Alex3917 19y agoAs long as we're having a meta-thread, is there any way to incorporate the site traffic into the decay function. The problem currently is that if you post something off-peak, a lot of time elapses with no one around to vote. It sucks to finish writing a blog post at 7pm and have to wait until 11am the next day to post it.
- Keios 19y agoI totally agree. This also effects people who are in different timezones.
- pg 19y agoThat's the main way the current plan isn't optimal. Paul Buchheit suggested I scale votes by recent activity, and I probably will do that.
- Alex3917 19y agoIt'll be interesting to see if this change would affect the content on Reddit at all. Normally if you want to ride the aggregation train the ideal strategy is to wait until you hit the top of news.yc before submitting to Reddit, and then wait until you make the front page of Reddit before submitting to Digg. If good stories start hitting the #1 spot on this site during nights or on the weekends, it could potentially have some interesting ripple effects further up the chain.
- ivankirigin 19y agofloating point karma.
- pg 19y agoI'm considering adding an additional layer of protection against grumps: to only allow users as many downvotes as they've made upvotes. That way each user's net contribution to the global karma would be at least neutral.
- Dauntless 19y agoThat's an interesting idea. Another idea would be that they would "consume" some of the karma they made, when they downvote.
- Keios 19y agoWhy don't you publish the top 3 or 5 folks who up vote and down vote the most, maybe as an additional section on the leaders page. It might effect behavior interestingly.
- pg 19y agoI'd rather just make the system quietly do the right thing. Never do through social pressure what you could do through software.
- Keios 19y agoI understand. I hope news.yc doesn't become an overly serious place though. PS: As an after-thought, social pressure may be more adaptable than software.
- aston 19y agoI thought it was the other way around: never try to solve a social problem with software. The karma-neutral idea sounds like a good one, but then you remember that it's easy to create new accounts... Ultimately, you just have to depend on people to do good or leave.
- Dauntless 19y agoI wasn't able to downvote since I made an account. But it has its benefits; not being able to downvote or see your comments downvoted makes it a lot less stressful experience.
- mynameishere 19y agoOnce you come up with a really, really good way to correlate karma with a user's quality of posts/comments, maybe try to come up with a purpose for karma.
- pg 19y agoThe purpose of karma on any site like this (all the way back to slashdot) is to motivate people by giving them a measure of what their peers think of their contributions.
- mynameishere 19y agoI mean a purpose that would, for example, prevent reddit from turning into digg.
- pg 19y agoI actually have a plan for this. It's built into the current sw but not turned on. It hasn't been needed so far, and may never be because of Startup News's narrow focus. If I reuse the code to make a general news site, as I've been thinking I might, I'll certainly turn it on.
- brianmckenzie 19y agoWhy not let us see who has upvoted/downvoted our comments? It's frustrating when someone downvotes without explanation, especially if it's not an obviously stupid comment. But all posters are not created equal - what if we could consider the source? If some guy with -27 karma downvotes my comment I could care less. If it's someone like Paul Buchheit, on the other hand, I have to consider the possibility that my comment was really stupid.
- palish 19y agoIt's anonymous by design, not by side effect. It's the same reason no one really knows if you voted for Bush or Kerry.
- brianmckenzie 19y agoHmmm...yeah, that makes sense. It keeps things from getting overly personal.