4 ms·
While they need not, you will often want that. Humans will naturally shy away from someone who doesn't look 'normal' (a term I didn't define). I often catch my
by bluGill 3y ago
While they need not, you will often want that. Humans will naturally shy away from someone who doesn't look 'normal' (a term I didn't define). I often catch myself doing this even though all evidence says the other person is fine despite missing limbs.
- maxglute 3y agoSentiment probably shifting with cyberpunk media. If I see cool prosthetics I probably couldn't resist to stare, which is also annoying I imagine.
- paulpauper 3y agohmm there is the uncanny valley phenomenon
- danielvaughn 3y agoYeah I've seen some artificial limbs that have a cyborg-ish look to them. I'm aware that not everyone will want to go for something like that, but at least it doesn't give off the uncanny valley vibe.
- standardUser 3y agoSort of. We certainly seem to have adapted rather rapidly to an ever-increasing variety of hairstyles, clothes, tattoos, piercings and accessories. We'd probably all "shy away" from the average goth or punk rock kid if it was 1940. But who still scoffs at those extreme looks these days when they serve you coffee or stop you on the street for directions?
- satvikpendem 3y ago> But who still scoffs at those extreme looks these days when they serve you coffee or stop you on the street for directions? Lots of people, depending on how extreme.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoDepends on where you live and which people you will be hanging out with that day (you can have multiple limbs - see this talk where Aimee Mullins shows off her 12 pairs of legs and discusses the context for each [1]. Limbs for Olympic running already don’t look “normal.”) I’m queer and trans and I live in Oakland and I hang out with almost all queer anarchist people. You can bet I’d wear a tentacle from time to time and they’d all think it’s rad as hell. I’m a robotics engineer and I tend to like to be a bit loud at times and go against the grain. If I lost a hand or an arm I’d almost certainly build myself a fire shooting tentacle. (I could do this now but motivation goes up if I’ve lost a limb and I’ve begun working on replacements.) I learned long ago that trying to appease the normative views of others simply isn’t going to work for me, so I trained away the part of my brain that worries what other people think as long as I’m not actively harming others. In doing so I’ve found a lot of people that appreciate this, and I’ve learned the value in leaning into it and building community with the weirdos. If I’m going to my normie friend’s wedding I might bring a normal prosthetic and keep the fire shooting tentacle in the car for all the nerds that want to see it after the ceremony. [1] https://youtu.be/JQ0iMulicgg?si=kPDy_VcRtJbQPuCb https://youtu.be/JQ0iMulicgg?si=kPDy_VcRtJbQPuCb
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoAlso the attitude matters a lot. If it comes from creativity, joy, fun, etc., it will work way better than if it comes with distanciation, opposition and awkwardness. Context is important, but what you bring as well. I have friends that can make a new pair of glasses uneasy, and some that can rock devils horns on a tuesday.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoYeah. I certainly understand that losing a limb is a big deal emotionally and many will not want to stand out. However as someone who has been interested in robotics since I was 11 years old my plan has always been that if I lose a limb I will build my own replacement. That gives me a lot of clarity on how I would proceed after the initial grieving and acceptance period.
- ben7799 3y agoOur limbs evolved to be efficient for life on earth. Then we built all this artificial stuff and designed it to be as optimal as possible for human hands. So intentionally making prosthetics really different from the human norm might make things less convenient for the wearer.
- thfuran 3y agoThat's something only someone who has never played N64 could say.
- hinkley 3y agoOne of the examples is an extra thumb. That prosthetic is clearly meant to be available for able-armed people. This is very hypothetical, but if a prosthetic becomes a tool rather than a replacement for organics, then it's possible that products will change to be compatible with the tool. Coffee cups probably won't change, but power tools might, if there's something about having an extra thumb that makes them easier to operate. My cordless drills can go from forward to reverse by moving my thumb twice, but other transitions require more repositioning of the hands. You could move the torque controller to be reached by the extra thumb, for instance, reducing the steps to countersink a wood screw.
- s0rce 3y agoSimilarly, this issue occurs with your eyes. When you wear a vision pro you can see flicker issues with tons of displays that were designed to be visible by people and not machines.
- pixl97 3y ago>Our limbs evolved to be efficient for life on earth. Eh, then why don't most other mammals have digital hands (having 10 fingers that is) like humans? It may be better to say that human society and products are developed around us fingers, but there may very well be specialist jobs that allow prosthetics to be more efficient.
- melagonster 3y agothis is a common advantage of primates
- jdietrich 3y agoUntil recently, hearing aids were almost exclusively available in "skin tone" colours that didn't particularly match anyone's skin. Now all of the major manufacturers offer hearing aids in a range of consumer electronic-like metallic and gloss colours; this is especially true for hearing aids for children. There's a major generational shift, driven partly by changing social attitudes to disability but also because people are just much more used to seeing people with electronic things in their ears. A new generation of hearing aid users see their hearing aids as a gadget rather than a medical device; the choice to wear a "discreet" hearing aid is increasingly seen as a symptom of internalised stigma. The same thing is happening with prosthetic limbs, driven to a very large extent by parasports. We're increasingly used to seeing prosthetic limbs that were designed purely for performance, where form follows function. Prosthetists used to assume that everyone would want the most "normal-looking" prosthetic limb, but that's no longer a safe assumption; to many younger people with missing limbs, the thought of wearing a prosthetic designed to mimic a natural limb is actively repellent. They're much more comfortable wearing something made of raw carbon fibre than something covered in beige rubber.
- szundi 3y agoAnd the world of Cyberpunk and Shadowrun has officially started now.
- bobthepanda 3y agoif the "normal looking" thing doesn't look very good there's not much point bothering. this is like how it took a few decades for us to get "nude" undergarments matching certain skin pigments in the United States.
- deafpolygon 3y agoI got mine in white! I Love it, and wish I had color options as a kid.
- chrismcb 3y agoProbably had more to do with the fact that all the cool kids are supporting air pods or something. So now a skin tone hearing aid looks like a hearing aid. While anything else looks like a cool air pod.
- hinkley 3y agoThe subject of this article has a woman with a tentacle arm front and center. Some of the others are more human+ or human-adjacent. An extra thumb will get looks and be a conversation piece. The tentacle is a little too deep into the uncanny valley.
- s0rce 3y agoseems like a limb trying to look human but ending up creepy is in the uncanny valley. A non-human tentacle limb is simply that, its not mimicking human like characteristics in a slightly off way.
- hinkley 3y agoIn a sleeve, in a glove, or with a matched silicone cover, you'd have a hard time telling.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoI think an argument is it's better to be completely different than close but not close enough. As in uncanny valley. If it can't actually be a perfect human arm, it's better to have a clearly not-even-trying robot arm. It probably has several different roots. Two at least are: One is the uncanny valley, which has to do with fitness for reproduction and avoiding disease etc. I'm talking at the animal brain level. Any animal will avoid a deformed version of itself. A human will be revolted by another human who's appearance is barely any different from their own, seen from an outside perspective like an alien, but they will love a dog to pieces, even though the dog looks infinitely more different than the human with a slightly too big forehead or something. Another element I think is probably based on deception. If you can do a perfect fake, then ok, but if it's only close, then at both subconscious and conscious levels you don't like being deceived, because that is manipulation, someone else taking control that you didn't voluntarily give them. A steel pipe arm does not deceive, or more importantly does not attempt to deceive anyone. It ends up being as emotionlly neutral as the same person holding any other tool. Instead of holding a hammer with their hand, they are holding an arm with their shoulder.