4 ms·
We built Fly.io resume-blind and without interviews, hiring people at every level of experience without having to make decisions based on that experience. We di
by tptacek 3y ago
We built Fly.io resume-blind and without interviews, hiring people at every level of experience without having to make decisions based on that experience. We did it by throwing away all this stuff, ditching interviews, and replacing them with work-sample tests. Some of the best people on our team, the best I've worked with in my whole career, are working here in their first job in our field.
I'm a little grumpy about this "diamonds in the rough" shit. I'm more concerned about what's lurking in the diamond mines. If people can demonstrate that they can do the work, I don't much need to know if "they have a chip on their shoulders". More generally: I have zero faith in anyone's ability to learn much from psychological interviews.
- strich 3y agoIn a world where chat gpt exists I think even work samples are untrustworthy sources of excellence unfortunately. It would seem one has to either watch the process or devise unique and difficult to game tests.
- tptacek 3y agoWork samples aren't all straight coding; in fact, only a small subset of ours are. Later I want to add: I fully believe LLMs can reliably knock out the code for most programming challenges, but a good coding work sample is as much about what you choose to code as it is about the code itself. If you're asking people to invert binaries trees or whatever, that's not a work-sample test, it's a coding quiz. Work-sample tests mirror the actual work you're doing; that's what makes them predictive. Writing a function to do X, Y, or Z is usually the easy part about building software; the hard part is deciding which X, which Y, and which Z, and how they fit together. We didn't deliberately set out to design work samples where the decisions we're grading are things LLMs don't just do for you; we do a lot of systems programming work and those kinds of decisions just dominate systems programming.
- xena 3y agoAs a fly.io employee, I can tell. I can tell fairly quickly.
- BadHumans 3y agoIs this how Fly still operates? If you're hiring Rust developers, are you open to someone who has never touched Rust in their life?
- tptacek 3y agoWe wouldn't know if you've never touched it, only whether you can solve problems in it today.
- mcguire 3y agoSo, no?
- tptacek 3y agoI don't think this is a question with a yes/no answer? If you apply for a role that involves writing Rust and can't demonstrate the ability to solve problems in Rust, you won't make it far. But we don't even collect resumes, so you get to make that call for yourself; we don't divine it from signs and sigils.
- dentemple 3y agoI wish more companies hired software engineers like you.
- randomdata 3y agoImplying that those who have never touched Rust cannot solve problems?
- mcguire 3y agoImplying that those who have never touched Rust cannot solve problems in Rust.
- randomdata 3y ago
- swozey 3y agoSo you communicated via email and the only consideration was the quality of their sample? Nobody at any point literally spoke to this person? We've had a ton of issues at my corp of people having other people handle their interview questions, code, or having AI listen to the conversation and answer questions by text as if we prompted it. Then they show up online after being hired and they have webcam problems or never go on cam, talk as little as possible, basically never communicate to anyone really, miss a lot of meetings, etc. We've had probably 5 instances of this last year we're absolutely super strict about things now. Our assumption is that they want to get in, potentially get any bonuses if there are any, get a few huge (for their call center) paychecks until they get caught. Do no or almost no work. And it's a call center you can sometimes hear tons of convos going on in the background so they're just doing this en masse. This is happening ALL over since covid. I think some of them may have even filed unjust termination sort of things to the workforce commission but I may be wrong. Huge companies are dealing with this at a really rough scale.
- tptacek 3y agoOur process runs mostly through email until the last challenge, which is interactive (for every role in the company we simulate some kind of design or problem solving exercise on Slack with an random member of our team, which is then rated based on a rubric by a panel that reviews the transcript; it differs from an interview in a variety of ways, most notably that the team member delivering the exercise doesn't ever interrogate the candidate). Most of our work sample stuff is design/architecture based. I'm not worried about how LLMs impact it. This is the sole way we've hired engineers at Fly.io since 2020 and we have never once brought someone on who turned out to be 3 raccoons in a trenchcoat. Raising the bar further on ourselves: we hire globally, at SF scale salary worldwide.
- potamic 3y agoThat's an interesting approach. In an interview, you generally drive the discussion a certain way to gather data points for your rubric. Wouldn't this happen in your case? If yes, how is it different from an interview? Otherwise, how do you evaluate candidates who solve the problem but don't seem to communicate much about it.
- mplanchard 3y agoDo y’all have any blog posts on this? Would be curious to know more about the work sample tests, and about the process in general.
- tptacek 3y agohttps://fly.io/docs/hiring/ https://fly.io/docs/hiring/
- jefc1111 3y agoI don't know if I would hire like this, but I do think a lot about the current hiring landscape is pretty broken, so maybe I should! I expect an employer needs a certain amount of cachet before being able to do this or anything else similarly left-field. Side note - I started down two paths of significant new learning early last year: Security & Elixir / BEAM. I love Security Cryptography Whatever and had no idea you crossed over into the Elixir world (fly.io). Cool!
- tptacek 3y agoI've been at Fly.io since 2020. I wouldn't describe us as an Elixir company so much as a company that appreciates Elixir. Some of our backend is in Elixir but the majority of it is Rust and Go.
- jefc1111 3y agoSome significant names from that world on the fly.io roster :) Like a lot of people I feel like Elixir / BEAM has a real value proposition that is unrealised in the wider IT landscape ... but maybe that's not such a bad thing from some perspectives.
- TylerE 3y agoIt’s a really a shame that Java poisoned the GCed JIT Runtime well. Now everyone assumes that a runtime means it will take 30 seconds and 8GB of RAM to show a loading screen.
- geor9e 3y agoPlus you get a bunch of free work out of every applicant if you delegate real issues out as work-sample tests :P I'm pretty sure the new Audi A8 cup holders are from my mechanical design engineer third round volkswagen interview a couple years ago
- tptacek 3y agoYou do not in fact get free work.
- gwbas1c 3y agoIt's nearly impossible to scope useful, shippable work that can be accomplished in a job interview. Otherwise, you're asking for 20+ hours of work, which means that only fools / suckers will do your interview. Do you really want a company full of fools and suckers?
- geor9e 3y agoShippable, goodness no, but a 1-hour-limit prototype already solving a problem you haven't even begun thinking about? I'd take that. I tend to start over from scratch after the first prototype anyway. You're interviewing people anyway, your choice is either real issues or fake issues, and fake issues get your nothing.
- i_h8_lc_grind 3y agoThis is good to know. I think a lot of people are tired of wasting their lifespan on grinding lc-medium/hards. Is there a website with a list of companies that don't participate in the leetcode/FAANG interview process? I feel like there is a need for one.
- em-bee 3y agoi seem to remember an HN post about such a site, or at least one about a site that evaluates companies hiring processes. also related, about companies development practices. try searching the HN post history. (and report back if you find something :-)
- swifthesitation 3y agohttps://github.com/poteto/hiring-without-whiteboards https://github.com/poteto/hiring-without-whiteboards
- i_h8_lc_grind 3y agoBeautiful. Thank you.
- gwbas1c 3y agoJust remember that all interview techniques have bias; what works well for one company / role may not work well for your company / role. That being said, it sounds like your interview technique works well for you.
- tptacek 3y agoThat may be, but I don't believe interviews work well for anybody.
- firstplacelast 3y agoI started an interview at fly like 1.5 years ago. Figured I’d give it a shot, they were very responsive, gave me the challenge and I spent more time than was suggested. They had a few core technologies I was not familiar with at all, but figured I could hack it…I could not. Anyway, I really appreciated it. Walked away with nothing but positive feelings. I have spent enough time applying/interviewing over the last decade that I am often in a dilemma when I get an offer that I don’t want bc the process is so fucky/I already have negative feelings. From HR setting expectations and then not meeting them, the laid-out interview process not lining up, remote/hybrid changing, inability to describe actual projects I would work on, not meeting people I would work under/with, made to feel like I lack intelligence by interviewers, etc. I’m not a “rockstar” programmer and never have tons of offers, but I have turned down offers because of screwy interview processes/interviewers just to stay at the evil I know.
- gwbas1c 3y agoDon't feel bad about saying "no" to a job you don't want. I've walked away from a few. Sometimes it's money, and sometimes it's just a bad smell. I did get a decent offer once, declined, and later learned I dodged a bullet. Another time I was impatient and took an offer against my better judgement, and it turned out poorly.