9 ms·
States, including CA and NY, sign heat pump memorandum
- timeimp 3y agoWait, that style of air-con isn't common in the US?
- RHSeeger 3y ago> Despite the name, heat pumps do not generate heat – they move heat from one place to another. Literally nothing about "pump" implies it generates heat. That being said... > In colder climates, an electric heat strip can be added to the indoor fan coil for additional capabilities. That would just be... electric heating, but with more steps? I mean, at that point you just have a heat pump _and_ electric heating; a hybrid system. It's better, sure, but it's not really just a heat pump anymore.
- jayofdoom 3y agoIn those hybrid systems, you only need the electric heating elements when the temperature outside is extremely cold. In the average winter season, my auxiliary heat, the electric furnace, runs less than a dozen times a year. The rest of it is all handled by the heat pump.
- voisin 3y ago> when the temperature outside is extremely cold Thanks to improving refrigerant technologies, the “extremely cold” threshold is getting lower and lower over time.
- nfriedly 3y ago> That would just be... electric heating, but with more steps? I mean, at that point you just have a heat pump _and_ electric heating; a hybrid system. It's better, sure, but it's not really just a heat pump anymore. I have a geothermal system (a ground-sourced heat pump) that also has electric resistive heating as a backup. I I've had to use it twice in the ~5 years I've lived in this house. The first time it was something like -15°f outside, so we just figured that was beyond what the system could handle. The second time, a year later, it wasn't quite as cold out and we had someone come look at it who found that it was low on refrigerant. (I've only been here 5 years, but the system was at least 15 years old.) So, I've been happy it to have it there as a backup. From what I understand, it's also fairly straightforward and inexpensive to add to the system.
- jhauris 3y agoIt's ubiquitous in some regions in the US. I suspect where it's not is both very mild climates where you hardly ever use it, and severe cold where until recently heat pumps were not sufficient. Also probably old buildings.
- amluto 3y agoI wonder if CA has noticed that electricity prices in the investor-owned-utility regions are so out of whack that a heat pump with a COP of 4 is no longer economical compared with a reasonably efficient gas-fired appliance. The solution isn’t more regulation or incentives, IMO. It’s to fix the utterly broken electricity market. (This is a great example, BTW, of how public-private partnerships can be dramatically worse than full public control. Palo Alto, Santa Clara, and Los Angeles are doing quite a bit better.)
- Aloha 3y agoYeah, in a parallel comment I noted that in most of the country an 80% gas furnace is cheaper to operate.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoEven when you include the cost of carbon emissions in that fossil gas being burned?
- riskable 3y agoThe subsidies on the gas drilling, production, purification, transport, and infrastructure should also be accounted for.
- Aloha 3y agoHow do you calculate policies specifically for gas? There are tax advantages allocated to fossil fuel exploration, but not specifically for gas - and mostly just exploration.
- cma 3y agoYou would need a tax or heat pump allowment to adjust for that.
- Aloha 3y ago
- Slava_Propanei 3y agoHeat pumps are nice and efficient, but expensive to build and reliant on grid. Makes you more dependent and at the exact moment things get bad - during a weather emergency. Nobody, especially in NY state, should be without a fuel- burning heater.
- chucksta 3y agoUh or a generator..
- voisin 3y ago> Heat pumps are nice and efficient, but expensive to build and reliant on grid Expensive but falling as scale increases and government subsidies help drive scale. Reliant on the grid - natural gas relies on the grid to move the air too. Not sure if this is the case all the time but mine won’t run at all without power, so unless you are referring to wood fired stove, natural gas furnaces are also reliant on the grid from what I can tell.
- unshavedyak 3y agoYea.. mine does. I have water heat during power outages iirc, but no gas furnace heat. I've always assumed it's due to the thermostat though - if i knew how to manually run the furnace i always assumed i could have it start pushing air during a power outage.
- pokeymcsnatch 3y agoMy strategy is a deep cycle car battery and harbor freight inverter to run the blower motor. You get a long enough extension cord and you can use your car as an emergency generator.
- brk 3y agoI have done exactly that - car as generator, during a long power outage in NH. We had 2 oil furnaces, and ~350 gallons of oil left in the tanks, but no power to run the blower motors to move the air. A Harbor Freight inverter and our Ford Explorer kept things running for 30 hours, until Amazon could deliver me an 8,000 watt portable generator. The blower motors are pretty power hungry, on the order of about 330 watts, give or take. For a 12V system that is about 30 amps, or about 2 hours of output from a typical deep cycle batter before you risk depleting it to the point of damage. An ~$300 12V Lifepo4 battery might get you 4 hours of runtime, but not much more than that. In most cases, an outage of less than 8 hours won't get things so cold in a decently insulated house that you need to worry about it, and IME, an outage that lasts more than 8 hours has high probability of lasting much much longer. TL;DR - Your deep cycle battery approach may not prove to actually be worthwhile, consider working out the car-as-generator hookup plan in advance.
- Aloha 3y agoHeat Pump + 80% Gas Furnace is the best combination for most of the country. Both in terms of cost and efficiency. You get all the advantage of heat pump, and the cheaper defrost cycle from gas furnace. Consider how much of power generation wherever is gas. If you can get residential power below 10c/kWh then HP always wins in cost, but most of the country has high electricity costs, low gas costs, and the ability to use gas when the grid is stressed.
- amluto 3y agoI’ve never seen a heat pump with gas-assisted defrost. Have you?
- Aloha 3y agoYes - defrost means turning on Aux heat with the HP in A/C mode.
- amluto 3y agoAnd can it do that by itself at the correct time?
- Aloha 3y agoYes, in the same way your Electric Furnace is turned on to do defrost with a Heat Pump, it just fires up the furnace for 3-5 min.
- amluto 3y agoMy heat pump defrosts itself under its own internal control.
- lsllc 3y agoIt just switches to cooling mode and activates the AUX heat to dump heat into the outdoor coils for a minute or two and then goes back to heating. The AUX heat is just a thermostat relay closing, so it can activate an electric-resistive coil (as is typical) or it can turn on the circulator pump for a gas fired boiler for a hydronic loop in the air handler.
- yanslookup 3y agoMy dream is that municipal ground source heat pumps become popular. Let the municipal put and maintain wells (the major contributor to adopting ground source heat pumps) along streets and allow homeowners to tie in to the wells. Ground source is much more efficient, requires less space, creates less noise pollution, and is equally decentralized compared to air source.
- supertrope 3y agoDigging is fundamentally expensive. This is why above ground power lines are not buried, and fiber optic home broadband is not more common than reusing existing cable TV and phone lines. If utilities are buried from initial construction the cost is reasonable. Dig once. Retrofitting a neighborhood after the fact is too expensive. Geothermal has very long ROI like 50 years so usually only institutional building owners who will be around in 50 years bother to buy it.
- yanslookup 3y agoDigging is expensive the way it is done today, which is essentially artisanal scale. We get economies of scale at the municipal level. At least 2 neighborhoods in neighboring cities are doing it locally, more as tests but still doing it. Also, I can get ground source heat pumps installed including vertical wells for about 50k out of pocket, at current energy rates I'd recoup in about 12 years. Not sure where 50 years comes from, unless you are talking about geothermal and not ground source, in which case I have no insights in to as it's not a reasonable option around here.
- giantg2 3y agoNot legally binding. Market adoption is already rising. Seems like a good way for the states to get good PR riding on the back of existing momentum.
- lsllc 3y agoThe problem with heat pumps in the colder states is that they only work with forced air and also don’t produce (enough) domestic hot water. Particularly in the North east you are going to find steam or forced hot water systems fired by gas or oil (most likely #2 heating oil or possibly kerosene). In a new build yes. A forced air with (air or ground source) heap pump should be required (although it still doesn’t really solve the DHW issue).
- itsoktocry 3y agoI live in the north north east (Canada). Our house had an oil furnace, we added an air source heat pump. There are periods in the winter where the heat pump can't keep up, but in the months early and late winter it's all we need. The net result is that it has significantly reduced our oil consumption. Add to that fact it's an A/C unit in the summer, and it's wins all the way around.
- Aloha 3y agoHeat Pumps absolutely blow both Fuel Oil and very nearly Propane out of the water in run cost, even when electricity is high. At 30f - until you exceed 15-15.5 cents per kWh, heat pump is cheaper to run than median oil price.
- lsllc 3y agoPropane is no better than oil in terms of cost per BTU (except propane boilers are usually slightly more efficient). Natural Gas (from the street) is significantly cheaper than either oil or propane per BTU and particularly if used with a modern condensing boiler. It’s not that a heat pump isn’t more efficient it’s that if you have forced hot water or steam radiators you are looking at an additional $40K to retrofit forced air ducting to your house. Oh and you still need a solution for domestic hot water, probably you’ll just end up with a resistive heater (or a hybrid/heat pump unit like the Aerotherm but the heat has to come from the room).
- Aloha 3y ago