2 ms·
> Could you imagine the outcry if a fracking induced earthquake took down a 13th century church someplace? No one wants that. Seems like an straightforward cas
by eru 3y ago
> Could you imagine the outcry if a fracking induced earthquake took down a 13th century church someplace? No one wants that.
Seems like an straightforward case of externalities?
Coasian bargaining and/or Pigovian taxes can deal with them.
Yes, 13th century churches have value, but so do a lot of other things, like convenience or reducing CO2 emissions.
You can fix teetering systems with money.
Politically, you'd want to be careful to align who benefits from fracking (eg via taxes) and who bears the burden (eg from minor earthquakes). So if the dangers of fracking extent to about, say, 30km from the side of where the well sits, you'd want to make sure that the tax revenues and authority to decide on whether to allow fracking and what obligations to put on frackers should also roughly occur on that level of 30km. Eg within a county perhaps.
This way the voters in different counties can make up their mind about what they want to allow, and what they ask for in return.
Perhaps they want the frackers to post a billion dollar bond underwritten by a major re-insurance company as insurance for that 13th century church, before they allow fracking. Write the contract in such a way that any earthquake damage to that church would be covered, without need for proof that fracking was to blame.
- bigfudge 3y agoThis is so wonderfully naive to the realities of contract negotiations between large corporates and governments. There is an asymmetry here which works agains the public good. Corporations tend to only have to corrupt an offici or capture a regulatory body once to extract long term concessions, which rarely if ever get rolled back. The same is not true in reverse. In practice this means governments aren’t able to effectively exert democratic mandates over policy areas like this.
- eru 3y agoThe government is vastly more powerful than companies. The government can make arbitrary rules (= laws) that the company has to abide by. The company has no such power. > In practice this means governments aren’t able to effectively exert democratic mandates over policy areas like this. How did the Germans ever shut down their nuclear power plants? They were already up and running, so they were literally printing money for their corporate owners? How did GDPR pass in Europe? Why can't Google build housing for their employees in Mountain View? I would like to live in your utopia where companies are all powerful!