5 ms·
Interestingly, in the years before the US managed to do more about their CO2 emissions than Europe. That's because thanks to fracking the US move a large share
by eru 3y ago
Interestingly, in the years before the US managed to do more about their CO2 emissions than Europe. That's because thanks to fracking the US move a large share of their energy generation towards natural gas, which burns 'cleaner' than oil and coal. The EU has (almost?) no fracking.
And in an even greater tragedy: the Germans had turned their back on almost emission free nuclear power, and in practice had turned towards very dirty coal.
- trilbyglens 3y agoI honestly do not fault Europe for not pursuing fracking. If you haven't spent much time over here it's not easy as an American to appreciate just how little "empty space" there is on the continent. There is really no where that doesn't impact communities of people. The us can easily afford to basically throw a few little towns in Oklahoma under the bus and no one really notices or cares. That's just possible here. Too many damned humans, and too many teetering systems. Could you imagine the outcry if a fracking induced earthquake took down a 13th century church someplace? No one wants that.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoPlenty of empty space to do fracking in Europe. This is a case of ideology over strategic thinking for Europe, IMHO, and we've seen, and are seeing, the consequences of relying of foreign imports instead.
- wkat4242 3y agoWe just care more about pollution in Europe. Greenhouse emissions aren't the only environmental problems (and those are also worsened by fracking of course as it's still a means of producing fossil fuels) I totally support our stance against fracking. And the dependency on Russia was a bit of an issue for the first winter of the war but prices are back to normal now.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoDependency has not gone away. We still import plenty but now from US and Qatar (I.e US are again winning while we are again losing). It's not even about pollution. To say banalities like "we care more about pollution" means nothing and is not aligned with reality. Again, the issue is ideology. This is failing Europe in many areas, not just this.
- wkat4242 3y agoWe do care a hell of a lot more about pollution that most of the world. In the Netherlands half the country is at a standstill because some Nitrogen levels are too high. Building projects are stopped, farmers have to reduce fertilising etc. Even the maximum speed was reduced nationwide, not because of CO2 emissions but because of nitrogen messing with local ecosystems. I support that, but it's very important to realise that this is pretty unique in the world. "Green parties" are a huge thing and often even part of governments, is there even one in the US? :) And yeah we still import but you can't change things from one day to another.
- bigfudge 3y agoYou are wrong. Paris literally this week voted to tax SUVs from the city, in part because of pollution. It also speaks to a wider concern here not to allow commerce to dominate other public goods.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoThe Paris' mayor has very poor approval ratings and has organised a populist referendum on a dubious proposal to try to prop herself up... not a very good example, IMHO. "Not allow commerce to..." thrown left and right: if that's not a typical ideological stance in Europe, I don't know what is.
- wkat4242 3y ago> "Not allow commerce to..." thrown left and right: if that's not a typical ideological stance in Europe, I don't know what is. Yeah but that's a good thing in my book. The US tends to be very unbalanced in this regard, commerce all the way and not much attention to externalities, both environmental and societal (e.g. welfare and labour rights) Europe is substantially different from an ideological perspective and that provides us with a much better quality of life (much lower violent crime, much better public transport, no crazy healthcare prices, greener cities etc). Of course the US does better economically but economy isn't everything. And it's a self-defeating goal anyway, the more money people have, the more they spend on scarce housing and other goods which means the housing crisis is just as bad in the US as it is here despite the higher salaries there. > The Paris' mayor has very poor approval ratings and has organised a populist referendum on a dubious proposal to try to prop herself up... not a very good example, IMHO. Paris is far from the only city in Europe banning the most polluting vehicles. Almost every major city does this now. And the air quality really did improve due to this. And our cities are just a lot more smaller scale due to the longer history - there's a reason the smart was invented here :)
- mk89 3y ago> we've seen, and are seeing, the consequences of relying of foreign imports instead. In my opinion, you're confusing bad political choices (=let's get addicted to Russian gas, then we will see about it in 10 years) with everything else. Germany could have done more in the past 10 years to not get to the point in 2022 to be threatened by a country - they didn't, now they have to brute-force innovation/renovation. I would just like to remind you that US is still buying a quarter of necessary enriched uranium from Russia, and US doesn't seem a country of "ideology" as you claim. If Russia wants to retaliate today, it's really bad news.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoGermany's energy policy is the best example in Europe of ideology over pragmatism. The most glaring example is how they decided to exit nuclear with no clean alternative for ideological reasons. Ban of fracking is not pragmatic, either. If gas isn't imported from Russia, it is from the US or Qatar, which is the same in terms of foreign power dependency and balance on foreign payments, when shale gas/fracking provides an alternative.
- mk89 3y ago> The most glaring example is how they decided to exit nuclear with no clean alternative for ideological reasons. I would have said fear rather than ideology, to be honest. It was the times of Chernobyl and later Fukushima gave the last blow. It's a bit unfair to "forget" what happened 40 and 20 years ago - things must be contextualized. > If gas isn't imported from Russia, it is from the US or Qatar, which is the same in terms of foreign power dependency and balance on foreign payments, when shale gas/fracking provides an alternative. It's different in the sense that you don't depend entirely on a single country for your gas (like it was before), so that particular country cannot threaten you like they did. The goal of this governement is to drastically reduce energy consumption and use renewables, while at the same time "buying" gas from wherever else. This was for a political reason, otherwise they would have kept on buying gas from Russia and implemented slowly their green/eco program. The issue is not fracking yes or no, but the fact that in the previous 10-15 years it wasn't done enough to avoid what happened in 2022.
- imp0cat 3y agoThey put their churches on rails and move them out of the way as required instead. No, seriously. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnJwbhos9eM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnJwbhos9eM The heaviest building ever moved on wheels Between September 30 and October 27, 1975, the church was moved a distance of 841.1 meters at a velocity of 13 centimeters per minute to the vicinity of the old hospital, and it was set on an iron-concrete two-storied foundation. A small church of St. Ghost was also moved during October. After the move was completed, restoration work went on until 1988, and the church was solemnly blessed again in 1993.
- eru 3y ago> Could you imagine the outcry if a fracking induced earthquake took down a 13th century church someplace? No one wants that. Seems like an straightforward case of externalities? Coasian bargaining and/or Pigovian taxes can deal with them. Yes, 13th century churches have value, but so do a lot of other things, like convenience or reducing CO2 emissions. You can fix teetering systems with money. Politically, you'd want to be careful to align who benefits from fracking (eg via taxes) and who bears the burden (eg from minor earthquakes). So if the dangers of fracking extent to about, say, 30km from the side of where the well sits, you'd want to make sure that the tax revenues and authority to decide on whether to allow fracking and what obligations to put on frackers should also roughly occur on that level of 30km. Eg within a county perhaps. This way the voters in different counties can make up their mind about what they want to allow, and what they ask for in return. Perhaps they want the frackers to post a billion dollar bond underwritten by a major re-insurance company as insurance for that 13th century church, before they allow fracking. Write the contract in such a way that any earthquake damage to that church would be covered, without need for proof that fracking was to blame.
- bigfudge 3y agoThis is so wonderfully naive to the realities of contract negotiations between large corporates and governments. There is an asymmetry here which works agains the public good. Corporations tend to only have to corrupt an offici or capture a regulatory body once to extract long term concessions, which rarely if ever get rolled back. The same is not true in reverse. In practice this means governments aren’t able to effectively exert democratic mandates over policy areas like this.
- eru 3y agoThe government is vastly more powerful than companies. The government can make arbitrary rules (= laws) that the company has to abide by. The company has no such power. > In practice this means governments aren’t able to effectively exert democratic mandates over policy areas like this. How did the Germans ever shut down their nuclear power plants? They were already up and running, so they were literally printing money for their corporate owners? How did GDPR pass in Europe? Why can't Google build housing for their employees in Mountain View? I would like to live in your utopia where companies are all powerful!
- nehal3m 3y agoI happen to live in a very old European village that is being damaged by fracking to the point where homes became uninhabitable. I’ve been fighting the government for the money to replace the house they’ve forced me out of for the past 5 years. There are some who respond to you by saying this can be solved with money but that ignores a significant humanitarian cost. Responsible parties will do whatever they can to shirk responsibility and affected parties will have to waste years of their lives trying to regain safe shelter through bureaucracy. Sometimes it feels hopeless.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's just the local version of the resource curse. Imagine living in a whole country like that. The world economy is when you look at it rationally completely bonkers, we dig stuff up in one place to burn it elsewhere, we make stuff here to use it thousands of km away. Without all that cheap transportation, which in itself is a big contributor to the emissions we'd be forced to solve our problems locally. All that we do today is to destroy the planet whilst pretend externalizing the costs. But it is one planet, and there is no externalization happening so in the end it all goes down, the only thing we are doing is to lower the lows and to raise the peaks temporarily at the expense of the future.
- amatecha 3y agoWell, Europe isn't exactly saintly, unfortunately. Germany is literally tearing down entire towns to make way for lignite ("brown coal") mining: https://www.npr.org/2018/08/06/635911260/germany-turns-to-brown-coal-to-fill-its-energy-gap https://www.npr.org/2018/08/06/635911260/germany-turns-to-br... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hambach_surface_mine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hambach_surface_mine "Nearly 50 villages in this region have been evacuated and destroyed for the ever-expanding mines, and Winzen's village of Keyenberg — more than a thousand years old — is set to be next.": https://www.npr.org/2021/06/28/1010956116/a-coal-mining-monster-is-threatening-to-swallow-a-small-town-in-germany https://www.npr.org/2021/06/28/1010956116/a-coal-mining-mons... Just as an aside, apparently the company doing this, RWE, was the #1 producer of CO2 emissions in Europe in 2018 ( https://archive.is/Qe9KJ https://archive.is/Qe9KJ ). All I can say is, the sooner renewable energy takes over, the better.
- oezi 3y agoThe 4 last old nuclear plants which were switched off last year wouldn't have been switched to coal if it wasn't for Putin's war of aggression in Ukraine. Coal in Germany will end in 2030 anyway and the renewables are built at a pace to support that.
- eru 3y agoWith nuclear power (especially with new plants) Germany could transition off CO2 producing fuels faster. Remember: renewables are not actively good for reducing CO2. They don't suck CO2 out of the atmosphere, they are at best neutral. Renewable are good insofar as they allow us to move away from fossil fuels.
- lysium 3y agoIt takes decades to build new nuclear plants. This won’t solve anything until they are built. Renewables /are/ good for reducing CO2, as every kW produced by renewable is not produced by CO2-emitting alternative. Plus, they make you independent from foreign energy sources.
- timthorn 3y agoGermany didn't need to build new plants, it already had some. The "it takes decades" argument was used as the reason for not significantly renewing nuclear in the UK - over a decade ago.
- mk89 3y agoYou need energy now. Nuclear was phased out. That's it. That was the decision. And in 2021 was "barely" producing 13% of electric energy with the last 6 reactors. So either you follow one approach (= mix between imports and solar/wind) or the other (=import until 2032, then import and produce with nuclear energy), with the first approach being oriented to the long run (=independent from other countries, less co2 emissions, etc.).
- eru 3y ago
- xeyownt 3y agoNatural gas is not "clean". Moreover, it is well known that the biggest problem with gas is the production of methane during extraction that is MUCH more dangerous than CO2. Regarding Germany, the switch is temporary (geopolitical), and they still produce less CO2 every year as planned and have a strong CO2 phase-out plan.
- dtech 3y ago> methane ... MUCH more dangerous than CO2 Eh, it's a more powerful greenhouse gas, but it's also gone after ~10 years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- XorNot 3y agoIt's still CO2 emissions at the end of the day. The issue is nuclear power is right there as the better option. At the end of the day natural gas is still liberating carbon which was locked away and won't be put back anytime soon.
- Scarblac 3y agoIts half life is about 9 years says Google, so "gone" takes a lot longer than that.
- danans 3y ago> but it's also gone after ~10 years It breaks down to CO2, so as a GHG, it's not gone at all.
- tsimionescu 3y agoMethane has approximately 28x the warming effect of CO2 in those 10 years, and ultimately it breaks down... To CO2 and water. So every ton of CH4 is like 28 tons of CO2 in the medium term, and like 1+ tons of CO2 in the long term (since water vapor is also a GHG).
- sampo 3y ago> US managed to do more about their CO2 emissions than Europe. That's because thanks to fracking the US move a large share of their energy generation towards natural gas, which burns 'cleaner' than oil and coal The climate benefits of the lower CO2 emissions from burning gas, instead of coal and oil, are partially offset be the greater methane emissions. Then again, you can't compare natural gas CO2 + CH4 emissions to only CO2 from coal, as coal production also releases CH4. As long as methane leaks from the natural gas supply are below 4% or 5%, gas is better than coal. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-90839-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-90839-7
- antupis 3y agoMethane stays only 12 years in the atmosphere versus CO2 which stays 300 to 1,000 years.
- danans 3y agoHowever, it has 28x the global warming potential of CO2.
- cesnja 3y agoMethane breaks down into CO2.
- tsimionescu 3y agoOver those 12 years, methane "decays" to CO2 and water vapor, both greenhouse gases in their own right. And before it decays, it has a much stronger warming effect than either. So a ton of methane is strictly worse than a ton of CO2 in absolutely every way.
- gambiting 3y agoSure but in those 12 years it does an incredible amount of damage(and then it decays into CO2 anyway). Methane is a huge problem.
- wkat4242 3y agoFracking is bad not only because it generates CO2 but it's very polluting as well. This is why it's not popular here. Emissions aren't the only thing. The Netherlands just shut down their gas fields because it's causing too many earthquakes. And I really applaud Germany's decision, the coal is temporary and will be replaced by renewable too. Nuclear is just too expensive, long-term dangerous and sensitive to mess with. Again, emissions aren't the only thing that counts. And this also plays into the nuclear discussion because nuclear advocates often claim very low death tolls from nuclear, but ignore environmental pollution problems.
- littlestymaar 3y ago> but ignore environmental pollution problems. What “environmental pollution” are you talking about here?
- stephen_g 3y agoFugitive emissions of methane (a more potent greenhouse gas than CO2) [1], other gasses which are presumably the reason that people who live near gas fields have higher incidence of cancer, asthma, etc. [2,3], and various chemicals being released into groundwater [4,5], which could also be the causes of the cancer instead of the atmospheric emissions, I don't think there is a strong consensus yet as to which one is responsible and in what proportions. 1. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/fracking-boom-tied-to-methane-spike-in-earths-atmosphere https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/frack... 2. https://www.publicsource.org/fracking-proximity-cancer-asthma-southwestern-pa-pitt-wolf/ https://www.publicsource.org/fracking-proximity-cancer-asthm... 3. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/children-born-near-fracking-sites-have-an-increased-risk-for-leukemia-180980641/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/children-born-near... 4. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fracking-can-contaminate-drinking-water/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fracking-can-cont... 5. https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/news/story/study-links-fracking-drinking-water-pollution-and-infant-heath https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/news/story/study-links-fracki...
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- photochemsyn 3y agoRegarding the US switch to natural gas electricity and the closing of coal plants - it seems that a good fraction of the US-produced thermal coal is still being shipped overseas, particularly to India(36%) but also The Netherlands(13%), Egypt(9%), Morocco(7%), Japan(6%) and China(5%): https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/us-thermal-coal- https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/us-thermal-coal-... > "The thermal coal export earnings were the second-highest since 2017, following 2022's $5.7 billion. The total volumes were the highest since 2018 and came as U.S. power producers cut the amount of coal used in electricity generation to the lowest this century." Someone probably needs to explain to the green clean energy enthusiasts setting policy these days that it really doesn't matter where you burn the coal, at least from a global atmospheric standpoint (though not for local pollution fallout of sulfur and mercury and arsenic). However, hindering fossil fuel exports appears unlikely for any US government, see the LNG exports to Asia and Europe over 2023: https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-was-top-lng-exporter-2023-hit-record-levels-2024-01-02/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-was-top-lng-expor...
- wkat4242 3y ago> Someone probably needs to explain to the green clean energy enthusiasts setting policy these days that it really doesn't matter where you burn the coal, at least from a global atmospheric standpoint (though not for local pollution fallout of sulfur and mercury and arsenic). True but sadly these things are measured by country. Which is unfortunate because if you're going to burn the stuff anyway, shipping it across the world does add significantly to its emissions of course.
- FrojoS 3y agoThe US government has now paused approval for new LNG exports [1]. This was big news in Germany because their government is betting on US LNG to replace Russian gas imports and wants to expand natural gas use to complement renewables (peaker plants) and phase out coal. [1] "Biden pauses LNG export approvals after pressure from climate activists" Reuters, January 26, 2024 https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/biden-pauses-approval-new-lng-export-projects-win-climate-activists-2024-01-26/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/biden-pauses-approva...
- nextlevelwizard 3y ago[dead]
- postepowanieadm 3y agoGermany tried to do the same using russian gas, but then the war happened. Europe really needs nuclear.
- hef19898 3y agoIt always pizzles me, when people seem to think German gas imports from Russia are a recent thing. They are not, they date back to the 70s, the hight of the Cold War, when the imports came from the USSR (!). Reliably and cheap, I might add. And none of that had anything to do with climate change back then.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fulafel 3y agoComparing 1980 to current according to https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-co-emissions-by-region https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-co-emissions-by-re... : Europe had ~8 billion tons of emissions vs vs 5.5 for North America, and the recent numbers are 5 for Europe and 6.3 for NA. I think they managed to do more in the wrong direction.
- skrause 3y agoNorth America's population has grown since 1980 though while Europe's hasn't: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_population_(UN).svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_population_(UN).svg A per capita comparison would be more fair.
- RamblingCTO 3y agoYeah, not sure about this graph, it hides convenient facts. Germany is growing ever steadily and is the biggest country people-wise, and also the one with one of the biggest climate/energy impacts in Europe. No one cares about Montenegro shrinking in population size. Or Norway, Iceland with their water-powered energy grid. It depends on the countries shrinking or growing, doesn't it?
- eru 3y ago> Germany is growing ever steadily and is the biggest country people-wise, [...] Interesting, I was under the impression that the German population is declining. But you are right, it is slowly growing. In eg 1990 they had 73 million people, and nowadays it's 83 million (according to Google). Apparently that's all driven by net migration, because the birth rate is so low.
- RamblingCTO 3y agoThere were a few pretty big migration waves. Kosovo/ex Yugoslavia in the 90s, Ukraine, 2015 (middle east) etc. Where each brought > 1 million new people. So Germans are on the decline, but we're adding a lot of migration via the asylum system in. edit: data here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Germany
- staunton 3y agoThe Germans had very little nuclear power (and would probably have taken decades to build a single new one even if they had wanted to). The German decision to quit nuclear had basically no impact on EU energy generation. (It had an effect on German emissions, but even that effect is small).
- RamblingCTO 3y agoIt had on grid stability though. Our neighbours still hate us for that ;) the grid has to capture our instability due to renewables and it's a point of debate.
- adrianN 3y agoOur neighbors love selling us energy.
- Symbiote 3y agoIsn't that just catching up? The EU moved to natural gas decades ago. The gas reserves in Europe mostly don't require fracking to extract, neither do those in Russia. Click the larger countries on the electricity map. All but Germany have significantly more gas capacity than coal. https://app.electricitymaps.com/map https://app.electricitymaps.com/map
- jillesvangurp 3y agoThis myth keeps on perpetuating. But if you look at the numbers, coal generation in Germany has basically been in a slow decline since it peaked about fifteen years ago, which is also when they started getting rid of nuclear, which was never a big part of their energy generation. Coal usage could have been declining faster of course without that. And recent events have made Russian gas a bit less attractive and they burned a bit more coal. But now that the gas crisis is contained, they'll get back on track cleaning up the energy economy. Winter is coming to an end here and absolutely nobody is talking about cold showers and lowering the heating here anymore like last year. LNG is expensive so they have some incentive to get rid of their dependency on that. It doesn't really make sense to use that for electricity generation. I'm not super hopeful they will be able to completely get rid of coal by the 2030s like they have been insisting they will. But it will eventually get done. And it's one of those things where the more coal gets shut down, the more attractive it gets to get rid of the rest as well. That's also why they got rid of their last three nuclear plants. I agree, not their wisest move, but on the other hand it kind of focused them on a future without nuclear. Which, like it or not, seems what they've committed to. I don't see that change anytime soon. Those three plants disappearing is in the past. It's done. Next up is shutting down brown coal. That's something some parties are still resisting. But they are under a lot of pressure to get rid of this embarrassingly dirty industry.
- eru 3y ago> That's also why they got rid of their last three nuclear plants. I agree, not their wisest move, but on the other hand it kind of focused them on a future without nuclear. Which, like it or not, seems what they've committed to. And I don't even blame politics: it's what voters want.
- timeon 3y agoThat's good US has lot catching up producing 14.8t CO2 per capita in 2022 while for Germany it was 8t.
- flohofwoe 3y ago> the Germans had turned their back on almost emission free nuclear power, and in practice had turned towards very dirty coal. Before Russia invaded Ukraine, coal was shrinking even faster than nuclear in Germany. Coal usage only temporarily went up in 2022 as emergency measure.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoAmerica has 2x the German per capita CO2 and 3x the UK per capita. All have reduced this stat over the last few decades so the US might have reduced more absolutely, because they were so high in the first place, but the EU appears to be outpacing them and extending their lead. So it's weird, but unsurprising to see this painted as a triumph for fracked gas, and used to attack Germany's progress.
- kakaz 3y ago[dead]