12 ms·
Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory to Quantum Mechanics
- drallison 15y agoNot much content in this article. Read his books to get a feeling for the breadth and depth of his thought.
- Flow 15y agoAre any of his book suitable as casual on-the-tram reading? Could you recommend one of his books? Thanks.
- ktizo 15y agoAll books are suitable for casually reading on trams, apart from really old and delicate or oversized ones. I loved 'The Emperors's New Mind' and 'Shadows of the Mind', and did read some of those two while on train journeys, if that helps at all.
- jessriedel 15y agoThe Road to Reality, while certainly not a technical work in the traditional sense, is not light reading.
- arethuza 15y agoDepends how strong you are - I have a copy of "The Road to Reality" on my desk at work, but not sure I'd want to carry it about!
- te_platt 15y agoI wouldn't say any of his books are exactly casual reading. The Large the Small and the Human Mind is probably the most casual in that it merely requires thinking and even then some of that is done for you the responses from Abner Shimony, Nancy Cartwright, and Stephen Hawking (contributing authors). The others require active engagement to work through. Especially Road to Reality - there is nothing casual about that one.
- evoxed 15y agoI started reading Road to Reality very casually– bought the book one day, next day I was in a Starbucks enjoying it and my tea. 10 minutes later one of the employees takes a break and the only table open is next to mine near the back. After a few minutes of sighing, stretching, and looking at the door to see if any new customers were coming in he turned to ask what I was reading. The next 30 minutes was the first and only time I have ever had a discussion about particle physics with a barista.
- ilitirit 15y agoThis quite an old article. > From the September 2009 issue; published online October 6, 2009
- gwern 15y ago> And yet the 78-year-old Penrose—now an emeritus professor at the Mathematical Institute, University of Oxford—seems to live the humble life of a researcher just getting started in his career. His small office is cramped with the belongings of the six other professors with whom he shares it, and at the end of the day you might find him rushing off to pick up his 9-year-old son from school. Wonder if that's his kid? If I were feeling particularly sour today, I'd look up how much extra risk of birth defects etc using 69 year old sperm (rather than a more normal 30-40s) entails.
- mike_ivanov 15y agoI guess that's none of your business.
- stefantalpalaru 15y agoYou might want to start by looking up the way sperm is being produced. It will help you clear the confusion with the link between the mother's age and birth defects.
- ceejayoz 15y agoAge of the father does have an effect, actually. http://www.webmd.com/infertility-and-reproduction/news/20030701/dad-age-down-syndrome http://www.webmd.com/infertility-and-reproduction/news/20030... edit: Also, as someone who's had to use sperm donation to conceive... > Wonder if that's his kid? is pretty offensive. It's his kid, whether he's the genetic father or not.
- jessriedel 15y agoIt certainly does, especially for genetic (rather than developmental) defects. Wikipedia has a good summary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternal_age_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternal_age_effect Still, the mother's age is a lot more important, all things considered.
- Create 15y agoAlthough citation is needed, if I remember correctly, because of lacking healthy young Japanese men after WWII, ageing fathers' sperm contributed to at least as much to newborn malformations as the nuclear fallout. But the thread also tells you about the euphemism under the guise of 'ego' in the article, and how society today is structured (ie. power of the old vs. youth in our times). At his age, he should clearly let go, by all standards, even if it so difficult. To quote a famous speech from another control freak who at least knew all about this, luckily Nature has provisions because it "clears out the old, to make room for the new. Right now the new is you. But you won't always be."
- zmj 15y agoIt's so sad to see old age claim a great mind.
- maxharris 15y agoI don't understand what you mean. His intellect certainly shines through in the interview, especially in the latter part where he talks about physics.
- Symmetry 15y agoReally? I thought that the parts about physics were really disappointingly fuzzy. Especially: "physicists have to say, well, somehow your consciousness takes one route or the other route without your knowing it." I think that its sort of shocking that he could fail to understand the arguments of his opponents so badly as to end up saying something so ridiculous.
- pjscott 15y agoI have a generally negative opinion of Roger Penrose's ideas, but let's be fair: the fuzziness here was probably inevitable, given the popular nature of the magazine interviewing him. If you judged scientists harshly for sounding like handwavy simpletons in condensed interviews for reporters, you would end up drastically underestimating most scientists who have ever had such an interview.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- adharmad 15y agoCare to elaborate?
- jasonwatkinspdx 15y agoIt's sad to see judgmental certainty claim a young mind.
- mike_ivanov 15y agoNote this: "I was unbelievably slow ... we had to do this mental arithmetic ... I was struggling away to do these tests ... I was at least twice as slow as anybody else."
- Craiggybear 15y agoI admire Penrose greatly. And speaking as someone with a physics degree, I can say I've always had serious misgivings about the standard model and a lot of QED myself.
- aidenn0 15y agoOf course by this definition of wrong, Newtonian mechanics is wrong, which didn't stop me from taking a 400 level course on it.
- diminish 15y agoRoger Penrose has fundamental thoughts about the physics and AI, not simply callling them wrong wrong in the sense of falsifibility..Read his books.
- nollidge 15y agoI don't think the aidenn0 is talking about falsifiability, but accuracy. As in, Newtonian mechanics is not 100% accurate, but it works well enough for macro-level calculations. Like Asimov said, "when people thought the earth was flat, they were wrong. When people thought the earth was spherical, they were wrong. But if you think that thinking the earth is spherical is just as wrong as thinking the earth is flat, then your view is wronger than both of them put together." - http://chem.tufts.edu/AnswersInScience/RelativityofWrong.htm http://chem.tufts.edu/AnswersInScience/RelativityofWrong.htm
- natep 15y agoThat is what aidenn0 seems to be talking about, but that's not what Penrose is talking about. Penrose is very clear that the predictions of QM are extremely accurate. His contention is that the implications of QM cannot be true (that there must be parallel worlds or "it doesn't matter what's really happening in a superposition of states, just that the predictions are accurate"), therefore QM as it is today cannot be a part of any single unified theory.
- majmun 15y agoSo basically equation helps you to make your measurement more accurate. (on some scales) what happens underneath is known but can't be accurately measured because it interferes with physical process. (wich comes to no suprise because the measurmenst are done from whitin the universe while it's "running", and that is why your measurment will have effect on future state of universe, ) Seems like Penrose is claiming that different interpretations of this measurement interference are not necessary. thats what i get from article. at least.
- snowwrestler 15y agoOf course it's wrong; all scientific theories are provisional approximations, and the conflicts between quantum mechanics and general relativity are well known. The hard part is proposing an alternative theory that fits all the known evidence. Quantum mechanics and general relativity both match a ton of observations; anything that is going to replace them will need to at least match the same set of evidence at least as well. Put another way--when one theory replaces another, it must be fully contain the previous theory. General relativity, when applied to everyday human experience (i.e. not super fast, super big, super heavy), produces Newton's law of gravity. Personally I think the next step in scientific understanding is in information theory. It has the possibility of unifying chaos theory, computer science, physics, and biology. I think this is how we'll develop an description of consciousness for example. We've already seen some preliminary reports that information theory can reproduce gravitation theory for instance. http://www.technologyreview.com/blog/arxiv/24975/ http://www.technologyreview.com/blog/arxiv/24975/
- jessriedel 15y agoRoger Penrose believes quantum mechanics will fail long before it conflicts with general relativity, which is a bold claim. In addition, the conflict between general relativity and quantum mechanics is popularly overstated. My understanding is that no one knows yet whether the non-renormalizability of gravity in QFT near the Planck scale is necessarily a sign that the theory breaks, rather than just a problem with perturbation theory. It's conceivable that non-perturbative effects will save the day.
- planetguy 15y agoYou seem to be engaging more with the headline writer than with Penrose. They're both, perhaps, wrong, but Penrose is wrong in a far more interesting way. Penrose doesn't just think quantum mechanics is wrong in the sense that it can't quite be lined up with general relativity, he thinks that quantum mechanics and consciousness are the same problem and that we can't understand one without the other. Now, to me this smacks a bit of the old argument: 1. I don't understand baseball 2. I don't understand women 3. Therefore, women and baseball must be related somehow but he has slightly better reasons than that for believing what he does. Consciousness and quantum mechanics are both fascinating problems to understand; personally I don't think they're the same problem but I don't mind if some smart folks want to think carefully about the possibility that they are. If consciousness is a property of quantum mechanics then this ought to be at least partially measurable. All you have to do is to construct an intelligent non-quantum computer and ask it "Hey, are you conscious?" Of course this doesn't really help you, because what if the computer just thinks it's conscious but doesn't have real consciousness the way we do? What would this even mean? What is it like to be an intelligent but non-conscious mind? In my own opinion the question is meaningless which is why I think consciousness is some kind of inevitable emergent property of intelligent systems; but of course there's thousands of philosophers out there tackling this very question so I won't pretend to have any original thoughts on it.
- Whodi 15y ago"Is it true that you were bad at math as a kid?" "I was unbelievably slow... I always got lost... I was at least twice as slow as anybody else. Eventually I would do very well. You see, if I could do it that way, I would get very high marks." Speaking as someone who still struggles with math, and was generally the dumbest kid in the most advanced classes, it's a huge relief to hear that someone as brilliant as Penrose experienced the same difficulties.
- planetguy 15y agoI don't know how old you are, but I'm pretty sure Penrose overtook you by the time he was your age.
- Whodi 15y agoHaha, that's an understatement, I'm sure he was light years ahead of me as early as 10. It's just inspiring to know that one can struggle with some of the basics and rebound to do great things.
- lusr 15y agoI always felt I was slower than the other kids, but later I realised I was attempting to structure and understand the information whereas they were just regurgitating it. Once I did understand the information I could apply it far better than the others in class, and extend my understanding into new areas. That's just one reason someone may be "slower".
- pradocchia 15y agoPlease be charitable.
- planetguy 15y agoI thought I was. There's only a few dozen people on the planet who should be insulted by being told that they're not as good at mathematics as Roger Freaking Penrose.
- guscost 15y agoI agree!
- lkrubner 15y agoIf anyone is interested in the earlier Hacker News discussion of this article, it is here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=925539 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=925539
- Symmetry 15y agoA rather depressing interview. I enjoyed a lot of the explanations of Physics in *The Emperor's New Mind", but even there I could see big holes in his arguments about consciousness. For example, he talks about how its impossible to make an algorithm tile a grid in a certain way, but I had a screensaver which in fact did what he was saying was impossible. Here I just feel sort of sad and lost. I think my least favorite line was probably this: "The trouble is, what can you do with it? Nothing. You want a physical theory that describes the world that we see around us." If you're going to use that to reject theories about the reality of the wave function, astronomers in the Renaissance would have been equally justified in rejecting the heliocentric system on account of it being at odds with what they saw around them, or Greek astronomers rejecting the notion that the world was round.
- maxharris 15y ago> astronomers in the Renaissance would have been equally justified in rejecting the heliocentric system on account of it being at odds with what they saw around them False. Sights observed through a telescope were also part of "what they saw around them." A true theory accounts for all the evidence (and if it's not ultimately reducible to or based on something you can get from the five senses, it's not evidence).
- Symmetry 15y agoTelescopes don't show you that (contrary to what your inner ear is telling you) its the Earth that moves rather than the sun. At best they tell you that Jupiter has things orbiting it.
- planetguy 15y agoAlso, astronomers in the Renaissance didn't have telescopes, so the moons of Jupiter weren't part of what they saw around them anyway.
- regularfry 15y ago
- flom 15y agoDue to the inconsistency between quantum and relativity, I'm more inclined to believe that the problem is with relativity. The idea that physics is fundamentally non-deterministic satisfies me philosophically. If physics were deterministic, than I should be able to theoretically build a computer, input the state of the universe, and then be able to know what will happen in your life (assuming I don't tell anyone the computer output, because that would perturb the dynamics). I find that prospect far more unsettling than having to account for a superposition of states until I obtain more information in the future.
- CrLf 15y agoYou would never be able to predict future states of the universe, simply because you cannot represent such states within the universe they represent. Without the ability to predict, the universe is effectively non-deterministic (literally, no one within it can determine its future states).
- flom 15y agoYou make a good point. In my earlier post, replace "universe" with "solar system." Then, I can represent the states of the solar system in some subset of the universe, and I'll place this computer sufficiently far from the solar system so it doesn't interfere. Now I should be able to predict what happens on earth, unless you think that variables outside of our solar system significantly affect activities on earth, right?
- olalonde 15y ago1) Don't underestimate the butterfly effect. 2) We can already predict the future to a certain extent. 3) What you wish the universe was like is irrelevant. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wishful_thinking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wishful_thinking
- flom 15y agoRe 2: There should be an obvious qualitative difference between being able to predict where a ball will land if I throw it, and predicting who the passengers riding a particular train in 15 years will be. Re 3: I was commenting on Roger Penrose's assumption that quantum must be "wrong" because it's "unintuitive" by expressing my opinion that I think quantum is more intuitive than deterministic theories. Indeed, Dr. Penrose and I are both using "wishful thinking," as did Einstein when he hypothesized that the speed of light is "constant in a vacuum." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_light#Special_relativity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_light#Special_relativi...
- tanvach 15y agoPersonally I like the article, and I agree with his concluding paragraph that there must be coherence preservation somewhere. You need to look at one of the pillars of quantum mechanics he mentioned, where the observables of a system are only the probability, and this is due to 'decoherence' from a measurement. What he's trying to point out is that the coherence in the system must be preserved somehow, otherwise where could it go? It seems that this is very central to the difference between quantum mechanics and general relativity, and that the tiny connections to marry these two are yet to be found. His position is clearly 'it's in the details' not 'we must change everything' of string theory. This argument reminds me very much of Thorne–Hawking–Preskill bet about information paradox. PS: fascinating development in quantum weak measurement, where trading off measurement accuracy provides a window into coherence of a system.
- rsofaer 15y agoWe have so much more to understand about brain functioning in our current paradigm, and no pressing reason to try to build a new physics to help neuroscience. The theory of mind/experience of consciousness is an output of the brain, not part of its architecture.
- eevilspock 15y agoPenrose's idea about the relationship between Consciousness and Quantum Mechanics was used by Neal Stephenson in his SciFi tome, Anathem. Very interesting concept, mediocre book.