5 ms·
A famous climate scientist is in court, with big stakes for attacks on science
- Georgelemental 3y ago"Science" that can't stand up to a few expressions of opinion is not deserving of the name. If your claims are supported by evidence, you shouldn't fear the speech of critics, no?
- greeko4792 3y agoPolitics doesn't defer to the scientific method
- tovej 3y agoPropaganda is a powerful tool. With a loud enough megaphone and a big enough wallet funding it, a lie can easily replace the truth in the minds of laymen.
- Georgelemental 3y agoWho decides who are the "laymen", and who are the privileged cognoscenti who get to shield the "laymen" from incorrect thought? And how do I opt out if I'd rather not be shielded?
- hydrogen7800 3y agoAm I misinterpreting you by reading this as "all opinions are equally valid"? It's not "who", but "what". That is, the scientific method, not the scientist.
- jfengel 3y agoWhen those "critics" are accusing you of child molestation, yeah, you have something to fear.
- gary_0 3y agoWell, technically they're using it as an analogy to make accusations of gross scientific misconduct, but same diff. If an Alex Jones-style criminal is sending their mob after you, you have a much bigger problem than someone just disagreeing with you.
- gumby 3y agoYou should see what Mann went through. It was hardly "a few expressions of opinion".
- strawberryfie 3y agoI’m curious how we can know the average global temperature +/- 0.8 degC in AD1000 (linked graph).
- tovej 3y agoThe ratio of oxygen and hydrogen isotopes in water molecules. Both elements have two abundant and stable isotopes: one heavier and one lighter. The quotient of the heavier isotopes in land ice is a linear function of the temperature, because it takes more energy to evaporate the heavier isotopes from icean water.
- zamadatix 3y agoMore than one way. The linked graph cites the paper it was generated in which has all the details https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1029/1999GL900070 https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1029/199...
- strawberryfie 3y agoInteresting, especially the Conclusion section.
- EgregiousCube 3y agoThis appears to have big stakes for free speech in general, not just climate science. We need people to be allowed to disagree - yes, even in the face of data.
- tovej 3y agoHmm, so no legal responsibilities for companies spreading harmful propaganda?
- EgregiousCube 3y agoYes, it needs to be legal to be wrong, and it needs to be legal to lie when not under oath.
- trehalose 3y agoI don't want advertisers and shopkeepers lying to me about their products. I don't care if they're not under oath. I'd rather they not be allowed to scam me into buying their worthless goods.
- gary_0 3y agoBeyond that, if "free speech" trumps proof of harm or criminal intent, then all forms of fraud would be legal. Fortunately, the legal system is not that stupid.
- gary_0 3y agoVirtually every country on Earth has laws that apply when you make false accusations that cause real-world harm, and there is a long history of such trials in the US, so I fail to see how this has "big stakes for free speech".
- keithalewis 3y agoYou are making an assumption as big as the Ozone Hole. Er, I mean as big as it used to be. /s
- westcort 3y agoI hate to say it, but at this point, we need a pseudonymous publication system with some type of proof of authorship to maintain the safety of scientists while keeping the scientific credibility of peer reviewed publications intact. The data that is coming out is so concerning, it suggests several immediate courses of action. Those who know would wisely keep it to themselves. The ignorant will reap their reward.
- Georgelemental 3y ago> keeping the scientific credibility of peer reviewed publications intact What credibility? https://www.experimental-history.com/p/the-rise-and-fall-of-peer-review https://www.experimental-history.com/p/the-rise-and-fall-of-...