3 ms·
I really like my SII but the toy feeling is obvious next to my Lumia and iPhone. It's a great phone and of my phones, outside app testing, I use it the most. Ho
by tluyben2 15y ago
I really like my SII but the toy feeling is obvious next to my Lumia and iPhone. It's a great phone and of my phones, outside app testing, I use it the most. However for the cheap plastic feeling the intuition says it should be at least $300 cheaper. Seems SIII is the same that way, so i'm wondering if only techies notice this as the SII did so well everywhere.
- danielhunt 15y agoI'm a techy, on a bill plan (Ireland) and have moved from the SI to the SII not so long ago. I don't get the 'cheap' feel from the SII at all. It's considerably better than the SI from a look/feel point of view, and genuinely feels good to me. I've never really understood the fascination with build materials though. If it feels good in my hand, I'm happy. If it doesn't, I'm not. And the SII is definitely a winner in my book. Also, I am looking forward to seeing what the SIII is like in person - I'll upgrade to that if I have the option. (note: I haven't paid outright for a device in a few years. Not a single one of them represents good value to me, when paid for in a lump sum)
- Tichy 15y agoHow does upgrading work in Ireland? You probably pay for it even if you upgrade, right? As an example, I am currently shopping around for a new operator in Germany, and one I looked at offered the Galaxy Nexus. However, summing the base fee over 24 months it would cost >540€, whereas the Galaxy Nexus is already available for 360€ on Amazon. So the operators might not always offer the best deal. (In Germany you can actually find operators with a monthly fee of zero, obviously no phone included).
- danielhunt 15y agoUpgrading usually means you pay some fee (around the 100e mark, maybe 150e if the device is highly desirable), and then you renew your contract with your carrier for another 12/18/24 months (again, depending on your own situation) Adding up the total cost of the bill is, in my eyes, the wrong calculation to make. A phone (particularly a smartphone), by itself, really isn't worth all that much. You need a data plan, and to a lesser extent, a call/text(sms) plan too. If you pay the (say) 360e for the Nexus on Amazon, how will you use it to receive calls while walking through Dublin city centre? How will you check your emails on it while on the bus? You'll need to take that 360e, and add the cost of a plan that will suit your needs. Lets say it's 20e per month (a common pre-pay plan in Ireland). That's 20 * 12 (yes, I know, no obligation to stay for 12 months), which is 240e. Added to the 360e, you're looking at 600e for 12 months usage. Please, don't use the bill amount as the main part of an argument here - it really shouldn't be. There's a massive draw to specifically not spending 5-600e up front on a device.
- dagw 15y agoI don't know what it's like in Ireland, but in Sweden you generally pay a lot less pr month for the same plan if you bring your own phone, compared to if you accept their 'free' phone. So a 30 euro plan with a free phone, might only cost 8-10 euros if you bring your own phone.
- danielhunt 15y agoAh, I see what you mean now. In Ireland, it's only 5e less. So a 30e plan becomes 25e
- Tichy 15y agoThe way I do it is to compare the costs of the no phone plan to the phone plan. The difference times 24 is the cost of the phone. I've heard that in other countries (like the US) there is not much difference between phone and no-phone plans, which I find rather puzzling.
- danielhunt 15y agoIt's important to remember the difference between an upfront cost/purchase, and an ongoing (considerably cheaper) cost/subscription. edit not an argument, just a statement!
- Tichy 15y agoOk, I did not usually include that calculation, as inflation/interest is usually around 2% - probably wouldn't amount to much? Personally I tend to avoid subscriptions because they make my finances less tractable, and all the little costs add up. Good idea to do that calculation for "actual worth of the money" (don't know what to call it in English). Goes to my TODO list :-)
- tluyben2 15y agoIt is a winner and I will get the SIII, but as app builder (and, consequently, tester) I DO pay for them and it simply does not feel $300-500 'better' than some of the lightinthebox or aliexpress Androids I have. Better, but not that much.
- bookwormAT 15y agoI think this "cheap plastic" meme is completely fabricated by competitors with heavier and less durable products. Plastic is more elastic than metal, so if your phone falls on the floor, it takes some of the shock and significantly reduces the chance that the screen breaks. Samsung's "cheap" plastic is also lighter than metal. The Galaxy S2 for example is much, much larger than the iphone 4s, yet the iphone feels like a brick in your pocket compared to the Galaxy. Why do we associate "heavy" with "valuable" all of a sudden? Shouldn't it be the other way around? After all, a coin is not more valuable than a bank note, and a heavy bike is not better than a light one, right?
- gnaffle 15y ago"Cheap plastic" is not a meme. People have compared build quality as long as manufactured goods have existed. Many people associate heavy with valuable because traditionally, making things out of metal cost more and increases durability. Maybe the use of composites will change this perception. Does using a glass display instead of a plastic display increase the chance that the display breaks? Yes. Does it increase weight? Yes. But glass is more scratch resistant and has a better feel to it, so most people think it's a worthwhile tradeoff (Samsung seems to agree).
- tluyben2 15y agoPeople have been connecting heavy with expensive/valuable for a long time for some goods; watches for instance; a heavy Rolex. Cars; if you drive a light car you are one of those environmental turds. I overheard a group of guys in an expensive restaurant saying things like; 'yeah of course, but then my car weighs 2500 kilos hahahaahaha'; a lot of senseless weight-dropping to show value and wealth. I do agree with you on some levels, but PERSONALLY I find the SII feeling like something cheap compared to the iPhone 4. Like a lot of people thought the 3g felt cheap compared to the 4 as well because of the plastic. I guess Apple thought that as well? I like my 3g more in a lot of ways; I dropped it on concrete a lot of times and it has a few cracks in the plastic; I dropped the 4 once and the screen is gone (might be bad luck, but this is the perception I have now). My Lumia, which feels actually better in many ways than the 4 or SII, but it scratches really easy and has a lot of other bad things I talked about before. The feeling of flimsiness has nothing to do with my usage; as I said above; I use my SII far more than my other phones. I build apps/games for a living so I need A LOT of phones (especially Android testing is hell; you'll get negative reviews for all the phones you skip buying/testing on often; it's like going back 10 years for mobile dev :) and I currently do like the SII best esp with ICS. For pads the iPad still wins though, although the Prime is a close 2nd. Both feel rock-solid to me.