4 ms·
> In fact, we don’t even care about chord names, we just care about the relative differences, which is why we use Roman numerals to analyze instead of note name
by eru 3y ago
> In fact, we don’t even care about chord names, we just care about the relative differences, which is why we use Roman numerals to analyze instead of note names.
Btw, that's a pretty modern thing and requires equal temperament to really work.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bach_Temperament https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bach_Temperament for some speculation about what Bach might have used.
- beautron 3y agoThese are orthogonal concepts. Roman numerals can describe scale degrees and harmonic function in any temperament. They do not require equal temperament to "work"; they work just as well in just temperament. The numerals describe the degree/chord's relationship to the tonic. The difference is that in just temperament, you cannot switch which degree/chord is tonic (Roman numeral I) without re-tuning, while in equal temperament you can switch freely. The Roman numeral notation did come a little while after Bach, but I believe the concepts the notation represents are older (though some of the concepts may have been more implicit in the past).
- eru 3y ago> In fact, we don’t even care about chord names, we just care about the relative differences, which is why we use Roman numerals to analyze instead of note names. I mostly reacted to this sentence. Yes, I agree with the gist of what you are saying.