3 ms·
What I hate most is when companies insist that my (Google Voice) number "can't be used for authentication" or, even more crass, "isn't a valid phone/mobile numb
by lxgr 3y ago
What I hate most is when companies insist that my (Google Voice) number "can't be used for authentication" or, even more crass, "isn't a valid phone/mobile number".
Some have even done this after initially allowing me to sign up using it, changing their policy sometime after I've signed up, and I usually only notice when I end up locked out of my account.
Fortunately it's mostly been store apps or payment services that I can just avoid going forward, since they clearly don't value my business, but I'm concerned that one day, my bank will do the same and just lock me out of my account.
- thanksgiving 3y ago> Some have even done this after initially allowing me to sign up using it, changing their policy sometime after I've signed up, and I usually only notice when I end up locked out of my account. Viber did this to me. My Viber account is from 2012. I only found out when I switched phones.
- AnonC 3y agoBased on my experience with Google Voice, I think of not allowing Google Voice as a positive that could help people. I’ve written a little bit about why not to use Google Voice in this comment (on this same post) here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39270503 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39270503 My experience may not apply to you, but it is still a risk, IMO, to rely on the “free” Google Voice.
- lxgr 3y agoThat's not a good reason to block Google Voice at all. Regular phone numbers also get recycled by phone providers after a few months of not paying the bills (or not topping up a prepaid account). The chance of me losing my regular prepaid number after a few months of traveling internationally is significantly higher than losing my Google Voice number. I also seriously doubt that blocking VoIP numbers is anything other than companies making their own lives marginally easier (because VoIP numbers can be used by people generating multiple trial accounts in case they're used as a (bad) "proof of personhood").
- AnonC 3y agoGP here. Maybe I should’ve worded it differently. I wanted to say that it’s better for the users not to rely on an unsupported and poorly designed platform like the free Google Voice service. I’m not in favor of companies blocking VoIP numbers.
- rrr_oh_man 3y ago> Maybe I should’ve worded it differently. I wanted to say that it’s better for the users not to rely on an unsupported and poorly designed platform like the free Google Voice service. But that Romanian SIM card I bought at a roadside kiosk on a boozy weekend in Timisoara without any ID is fine?
- Liquix 3y agohoovering up users' phone numbers for profit is so widespread because - everyone has a phone - most people rarely change their numbers (if ever) - many people are more likely to give out their phone number than their social security number they couldn't care less about the security of your account or the fact that it's a valid number you control. they want the number that will uniquely identify you and already resides in the db of whichever adtech company bids the highest for your data.