3 ms·
This is one of my nightmares... I have 800+ repos on GitHub and I dread the thought of some weird machine learning algorithm somewhere deciding that my account
by simonw 3y ago
This is one of my nightmares... I have 800+ repos on GitHub and I dread the thought of some weird machine learning algorithm somewhere deciding that my account should be banned.
A lot of the stuff I care about on there is backed up elsewhere, but not everything. I even have a tool for this: https://datasette.io/tools/github-to-sqlite https://datasette.io/tools/github-to-sqlite - which exports issues, issue comments etc to a SQLite database via the GitHub API.
I do at least trust GitHub not to delete everything, but to instead put my account in some kind of soft-deleted state - and I'm reasonably confident I could get it reinstated via my network. But still, scary.
Why do I have everything on GitHub? Because I genuinely do trust them - they have a 15+ year track record of NOT breaking, and I know that my repos are backed up to three different continents automatically.
- smivan 3y agoI have the same nightmare, so to mitigate risk I run a self hosted instance of Gitea [1] and set up nightly mirroring. The folder with the mirrors is then uploaded to a backup provider, in my case Borgbase [2] 1. https://github.com/go-gitea/gitea https://github.com/go-gitea/gitea 2. https://www.borgbase.com/ https://www.borgbase.com/
- flowck 3y agoI stopped reading at "I have 800+ repos on GitHub". DUDE, it's time to back up your account to some other service. Anything can happen.
- weikju 3y agoYou should’ve kept reading.
- JohnFen 3y ago> This is one of my nightmares... I have 800+ repos on GitHub This is one of the reasons I don't use Github: I am deeply uncomfortable putting so much power over me in their (or most companies') hands. Even if they're entirely trustworthy and reliable right now, any company is just an acquisition away from that no longer being the case.
- yodon 3y agoI'm pretty sure Microsoft getting acquired is a considerably lower probability event than the other risks you're mitigating. If not, you might want to assess your risk tolerance.
- JohnFen 3y agoAcquisition was just an example, and true, it's not likely with Microsoft. More likely glitches with Microsoft are that it sells Github, or there's a change in management priorities or personnel. I was really addressing the larger case of depending too much on any company for this sort of thing, not Github specifically.
- yodon 3y agoIt's a tradeoff between concentrating your risks in a very low-risk-probability monoculture or distributing your risks across a large statistical sample of (generally) much higher risk individual providers (smaller companies shut down or get acquired at much higher rates, and are frequently still high value targets for attackers even though they have much smaller budgets to spend on security and defense). Distributing your risk among a large number of vendors is not necessarily better, and even if it's "just backups" can still multiply your risk of ideally non-public information getting disclosed. Denial of service risks exist but are rare and, for example with the myriad complaints about "stripe is evil" tend to trace back to "account in question was doing something a rational unaffiliated observer would predict as a likely account cancellation driver for stripe." We don't know the circumstances here. If the circumstances were benign, it will likely be corrected, if not benign, we may never know the details. EDIT ADDED (since HN is rate limiting this): self-hosting doesn't eliminate risks, it just changes them. You still face denial of service risks from loss of power, fire, natural disaster, theft, component failures, etc. If there were a zero risk path, everyone would take it. We tend to prefer risks we feel we have "control over" (eg. Self-hosting), but at the incident rates of most other corporate hosting risks you're into the territory of an earthquake took out both your house and your rented storage locker.