4 ms·
I agree that these are straw man arguments. I also reacted to them at first. But then he doesn't seem to rely on them too much. He admits that they are a metaph
by netcan 18y ago
I agree that these are straw man arguments. I also reacted to them at first. But then he doesn't seem to rely on them too much. He admits that they are a metaphor.
To be really convinced I would have liked to see him address issues like the likely major food shortage (technology will probably not solve this) & the likely major regional problems caused by mass migrations and/or wars over resources. However, his general argument is that a lot of money is being spent stupidly, very stupidly. I think that he is correct & that he makes that point.
I am still hesitant to take his side on this. I have some major problems with this approach:
(1) World Government - At the best of times governments are inefficient. For normal maintenance issues like how to run infrastructure, hospital systems, school systems & such they make mistakes, but they get by. Once issues become election winning issues, the debate gets really dumb. this is not only a central focus issue, it is a very technical issue. As he suggests, this is complicated & technical & every action needs to be weighed up. It's inefficient to simply take an ideological stance (renewable energy, energy efficiency, hybrid cars, etc) & get behind anything that promotes it. It is exponentially more rational to make this decision like an accountant creating a cash flow strategy.
Unfortunately, it is impossible for a political process such as this to take on an accountant like decision making process. Political debates need to be much more dumbed down to be possible. In this case, this process can be seen as being conducted by the 'Government of the World,' a body very weak in the existence department, never mind the efficiency department. So in a real sense, if a policy can't be chanted by a mob, it cannot be pursued. Certainly not over the 50+ year period necessary. I just don't think that his 'plan' is a possibility. The political structure & decision making process here is our tool. We have a wood. He is proposing building a house from bricks.
(2) Maybe panic is Necessary - Many predict that there is indeed a need for panic. That is possibly because of point of no return due to feedback. There are two kinds of feedback: the physical kind such as methane releases from melting permafrost, the political kind due to climate related political consequences such as a Chinese famine or a Pakistan/India war related to river flows.
(3) Economic models break down at these sorts of concepts. Comparing economic outputs between two scenarios where one of them includes mass starvation is apples to oranges.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoTo be really convinced I would have liked to see him address issues like the likely major food shortage (technology will probably not solve this) This will most likely be solved by growing food in Canada and Siberia.
- netcan 18y agoThe idea that new land will become available at a perfect replacement rate is a little bit up in the air. Anyway, even if this does happen, the adjustment period could starve 2 billion people over several decades or more. Large scale grain production is pretty optimised. That means it's very sensitive to any changes in the environment. Even if melted Siberian permafrost did provide a wheat growing hectare for every hectare lost down hear in Australia, it could take decades to shift production, optimise methods, industries & crop varieties. BTW, this may be another downside of GM. A kind of 'more of the same' to monocropping.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- viggity 18y ago"I would have liked to see him address issues like the likely major food shortage (technology will probably not solve this)" We grow so much food it is absurd. In the 1940's the average yield for corn was 40-50 bushels/acre. Today it is 180, almost all of that increase is simply from better statistics used in breeding practices, an Ag companies have barely scratched the surface when it comes to using genetics to improve yields. If there is a food crisis, it won't be the lack of food that is the problem, it will be politicians and despots at the root of the problem.