3 ms·
(if you are a suspect). there are a multitude of legitimate reasons to talk to police without a lawyer. e.g. you are a victim, you are helping a victim, you ar
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
(if you are a suspect).
there are a multitude of legitimate reasons to talk to police without a lawyer. e.g. you are a victim, you are helping a victim, you are being friendly.
The real advice is not to try to talk your way out of a crime because it rarely works.
- jandrese 3y agoHow do you know if you are or aren't a suspect? The cops aren't going to tell you.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoReasonable inference/ common sense. If I called them for a home break IL in at my house, I'm probably not the suspect. If they're asking for a description of a car after I watched a hit-and-run, I'm probably not a suspect
- 20after4 3y agoIf you call them for a break in you 100% are a suspect. They suspect you're up to something. They might even find evidence of another crime while they are investigating the break in.
- gs17 3y agoThe article is about the story of a guy who tried to talk his way out of a crime he didn't commit. He thought he was there ''to help with a case.''
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSure. Do you think that is representative of the majority of police interaction and a good basis for a universal rule? Does it negate the utility you can get from talking to the police?
- gs17 3y agoIt certainly makes "you are helping a victim" not a safe time to talk to them. He thought he was helping a victim, instead he was made a new one.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoNothing in life is perfectly safe. like I said above: 1) Do you think that is good basis for a universal rule? 2) Does it negate the utility you can get from talking to the police? Anyways, it is impossible they thought they werent a suspect and helping a victim after 9 hours when he was signing a confession.
- 20after4 3y agoYes it negates any (negligible) utility you might hypothetically get from them. Here's a different example: Police have a policy of shooting aggressive dogs, under basically any circumstances. So if you have a pet that is slightly protective of their territory, then any situation that brings the cops within shooting range of you pet can get your pet killed.
- int_19h 3y agoEven if it's not protective, that's not enough. In the case of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berwyn_Heights,_Maryland_mayor%27s_residence_drug_raid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berwyn_Heights,_Maryland_mayor..., one of the dogs that was shot was literally running away from the officers.
- VanTheBrand 3y agoin several of these situations you may become a suspect by talking to the police. Plenty of instances of people being killed or injured by the police also begin with them calling the police for help. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Linden_Cameron https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Linden_Cameron
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSure. There are low probability risks inherent in all all parts of daly life. That doesn't mean never call/talk to the police. That is a crazy viewpoint driven by hyper focus on risk mitigation. It is like refusing to leave your burning house because you might be hit my lightning.
- ambigious7777 3y agoPlenty might be an overstatement, but the case you linked is quite ridiculous. The boy was for one, unarmed and they decide to start shooting (eleven times!!) at him? I cannot imagine what those people were thinking.
- int_19h 3y agoThe huge problem with cops in US is the prevalence and popularity of Dave Grossman's theories about "sheep", "wolves", and "sheepdogs". Some PDs pay big sums of money to have all their officers attend a "killology" training. Look that up and judge for yourself as to what it trains them to do.