3 ms·
> your goal shifts ever so slightly from "making a great product" to "getting the next round of investment" FWIW, at the last YC event I intended, the partners
by dang 3y ago
> your goal shifts ever so slightly from "making a great product" to "getting the next round of investment"
FWIW, at the last YC event I intended, the partners were talking about how it's their job to get founders to stop thinking that way, and to think instead about making a great product, as you say.
- hobofan 3y agoI think YC can say/do that, as with the YC stamp of approval you are already on the A-tier track of VCs. So for their portfolio companies having a shoddy product will be the main reason of not getting follow up funding. Meanwhile, if you started out with a "lesser tier" accelerator/incubator, you'll have to prove that you have a good product _plus_ you have to fight an uphill battle and convince A tier VCs to even take a look at you.
- jedberg 3y agoYou'd be surprised at how hard it is for YC companies to get follow up investment, even with the YC stamp. I think YC tells that to their startups because they believe it. YC has always been about elevating founders and making "start my own business" a viable alternative to "get a high paying job". And from day one their motto was "make something people want". And when you exit they give you a shirt that says, "I made something people want". They've always been product over everything else.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoEven YC VCs don't understand that founders who take investment still have to shift their goal from "making a great product" to "exponentially growing their product" which in most cases is at odds with just "making a great product" YC doesn't invest in companies who aren't aspiring for valuations in the 8 or 9 figures (even if mid/high 7 figures would still be profitable). In the recent thread "Ask HN: Those making $500/month on side projects in 2024 – Show and tell" a user posted https://convertcase.net https://convertcase.net which is making $20K/month[1]. A traditional VC would never touch that, and if the user had sought VC investment, there would need to be plans for user sign-up, a SaaS dashboard where users can manage their projects and the different kinds of entities they would need to convert, integration with CI.. who knows what else. At that point they'd be building a completely different business, and would no longer be able to build the sustainable version that might not ever get $50,000,000 valuation. And that business would likely require them to hire more people and raise more funding [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39119230 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39119230
- robocat 3y ago> YC doesn't invest in companies who aren't aspiring for valuations in the 7 or 8 figures False. YC even has a non-profit track: https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/what-y-combinator-looks-for-in-nonprofits/ https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/what-y-combinator-looks-for... But yes, YC is VC and YC wants to create unicorns and has little interest in small businesses or bootstrapping. Joining YC is giving yourself a median outcome of failure - $0 for your common shares is the expected outcome (albeit likely true for bootstrapping founders too?). VC incentives and rules mean that VC virtually always takes more than 50% ownership over multiple rounds. So even if founders backed a winning business, founders will usually have lost control. VC will often kick founders out (it's allowed in the contracts and is part of the game).
- tptacek 3y agoMy sense of it is that YC feels its strength is in having and growing a huge luck surface area, because their dollars are worth more to founders so they get to make lots of bets, and they have a systematized process that meets founders where they are and can do a lot with super-motivated teams that want an intensive engagement while not getting in the way of teams that are more fire-and-forget. Which is to say: their investing is interesting but it doesn't have that much to do with long-term investing in startups. If you need plural millions to reach orbit, you're going to need to pitch a 9-figure company, because big-ticket investors have portfolio math that only works for those kinds of companies. So, to me it doesn't make too much sense to talk about what a "traditional" VC will or won't touch. For most YC success stories, both kinds of VC are involved.
- pmontra 3y agoMaybe the goals of founders and of VCs are sometimes misaligned. If founders start with the idea of working super hard for a few years (counted on the fingers of one or at most two hands), get an exit and retire, then why build a product that outlasts the end of venture capital? They could just try the VC roulette pivot after pivot and hopefully win an exit. This is not necessarily what happens in reality, hence some VC's focus on solid products, but it's a tempting, possibly naive, idea.
- sanderjd 3y agoSure, but the road to hell is paved with good intentions overwhelmed by the reality of incentive structures. This is like the venture capitalism version of "real communism has never been tried". Both of these things are true: founders (and leaders of VC-funded businesses in general) have an incentive to focus on investment rounds and runway, and VCs have an incentive to tell them not to do that. I think this mismatch is fundamentally due to the asymmetrical cost of failure. For VCs, it's a bummer if the goals of the current round are not met, leading to the company folding or an acquisition on disappointing terms, but it's arguably even worse for the company to sputter along, barely staying afloat from round to round, but never really catching fire, because they have to keep funds tied up in it, without ever getting the return multiple they're looking for. But the people who actually work at the company have a much more concentrated investment in it simply staying alive, even at the price of short-termism. It's just fundamentally different risk profiles! Maybe VCs should gift founders enough wealth up-front to be financially independent. This would go a long way to align their risk profile :)
- splitstud 3y ago[dead]
- vinnyvichy 3y agoProblem is, by that point YC have already filtered out the founder who is naturally inclined towards product over ponzi. Yes, it's still not entirely a gamble but remember that a person who has enough self-awareness of her product potential will still prefer to bootstrap over getting into YC, so one might suspect that's not inherently a low bar. (Or else the partners would not have such a distracting job in the first place) What should YC do then? I'd say, demonstrate to a producteer how willing and able YC are to help her explore side markets, a bit like HN's commitment to curiosity :)
- dang 3y agoI'm a bit confused - YC doesn't filter out founders, it champions them. That's been the underlying principle the entire time. But perhaps I misunderstood you?
- vinnyvichy 3y agoI meant that a founder who is already confident of her product or her ability to grow her business without the YC cachet, or, more substantially, a founder who is already acutely aware of the dangers of premature (fundability) optimization, would naturally not feel the need to apply to YC. If she does not apply, then by virtue of YC's positioning, she has been filtered out in favour of founders who prioritize looking impressive.
- dang 3y agoI don't think that logic quite works. YC funds quite a few amazing repeat founders. Having been around a lot of the batches, I don't think the majority prioritize "looking impressive". It's true that such types exist, and that they try to get into YC, but YC's application and interview process is designed to filter them out. If they get in anyhow, that's considered a failure on YC's part. But you're right in the sense that some first-time founders who want to build a great product can be lacking in confidence, or aren't clear on some of the steps they need to take, and those are areas where YC can help a lot. For seasoned repeat founders, those presumably aren't the urgent issue anymore.