4 ms·
This is a completely misleading site. On one side you post a picture of a road with high traffic, and on the other side you post a mostly-pedestrian street. Of
by cyberax 3y ago
This is a completely misleading site. On one side you post a picture of a road with high traffic, and on the other side you post a mostly-pedestrian street.
Of fucking course asphalt will look more damaged. If you try to use Roman roads for buses and trucks, they'll be destroyed completely within a couple of years (road damage scales as the fourth power of the axle weight). Cobblestone is also slippery when wet or iced.
Paving stones might look nice, but they can get dislodged, or the road can warp if drainage is not done properly.
Everything in engineering is a trade-off. You can use concrete for paving and for a small neighborhood road it'll last for decades with little maintenance. But it's much more cost-effective to use asphalt on a gravel bed, and just periodically do spot repairs.
As asphalt becomes more expensive with the winding down of fossil fuels, we'll switch to more concrete roads. But we sure as hell won't be using paving stones.
- maicro 3y agoI like your general comment (nothing against the others of course, but your point about engineering trade-offs is always important to keep in mind), so I'll throw this note here: As far as I understand it, asphalt is also highly recyclable. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/344252166_Asphalt_Pavement_Industry_Survey_on_Recycled_Materials_and_Warm-Mix_Asphalt_Usage_2019_Information_Series_138_10th_Annual_Survey https://www.researchgate.net/publication/344252166_Asphalt_P... , referenced from the Wikipedia page about "Asphalt concrete" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asphalt_concrete https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asphalt_concrete ), includes this quote in the abstract: "The asphalt industry remains the country’s most diligent recycler with more than 99 percent of reclaimed asphalt pavement being put back to use."
- lucasmullens 3y ago> 99 percent of reclaimed asphalt pavement being put back to use Can't that be interpreted as them just not reclaiming asphalt they can't reuse? Genuinely asking, since things like this are often optimally worded for good publicity.
- maicro 3y agoFair point, and I don't have enough background to really answer that. I'll look for any information on "reclamation" rates of asphalt - there's got to be some amount that's just lost in general (ground up into fine particles that blow away, fall into drainage systems, etc.), and places where it's just not reasonable to tear it up to bring to a recycler vs. dump it somewhere convenient, but it does _sound_ like they are pretty good about reclaiming and recycling it. The next chunk in the abstract I quoted is: "The average percentage of RAP used in asphalt mixtures has increased from 15.6 percent in 2009 to 21.1 percent in 2019. In 2019, the estimated RAP tonnage used in asphalt mixtures was 89.2 million tons. This represents 4.5 million tons (24 million barrels) of asphalt binder conserved, along with the replacement of more than 84 million tons of virgin aggregate." That gives some context as to how much is actually being reused.
- traviswt 3y agoThe alternative to reclaiming would be to leave it in place and pave over the top (asphalt overlay). That has limits, though, so reclamation will be a requirement over time. The claim and wording is valid and correct, though. You cannot recycle asphalt if you leave it in place. And what is removed is recycled at a rate of 99%. If you don't reclaim the asphalt, then it's still in place, and technically still in use.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoI think maybe some of the confusion is over how asphalt works. It's really easy to reclaim because it is essentially just a phase change operation. I forget the exact temperatures but you heat asphalt up past a certain point and it turns into basically a slurry of whatever hydrocarbon (plus additives) that is doing the phase change and stuff like sand, small stone, etc. The sand and small stone is infinitely reusable so when they resurface they are often scraping up the old, loading it into a machine that heats it up, adds a small amount of the hydrocarbon (and additives) plus some more filler (think sand) and putting it right back down to cool down and solidify. Cement is a chemical process that can't be easily undone so once you use cement you are hooped, very limited recycling options other than grind it up and use it as filler in the new batch.
- timw4mail 3y agoAsphalt can be recycled, though. It's more reusable than basically any other option, and I doubt it will disappear any time soon.
- hinkley 3y agoLooks like they're starting to recycle concrete as well. Though one of the uses seems to be... making asphalt.
- throwitaway222 3y ago[flagged]
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoYeah I live in a quaint little cobblestoney old town, and it's true what you say about trade-offs. For the last decade or so many busses through the heart of town were forced to use a cobblestone street for about 200 meters, resulting juddering that was unpleasant for both passenger and bus. One time I saw a handrail rattle loose and start donging around. So in the final cost / benefit analysis of the optimal street surface, we also need to calculate the increased wear and tear to vehicles and dentstry. Fortunately someone higher up saw sense and asphalted over that section of road, much to everyone's relief.
- brewdad 3y agoHopefully they did the job right. My hometown had old brick streets downtown that behaved similarly to your description. The city paved over them with asphalt but did a poor job on the prep work. Within a few years the road was in worse shape than if they had done nothing at all.
- Doxin 3y agoDo mind that it's not black magic at all to get a smooth paved road. Where I live they are all over the place.
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoYes, I have heard of such places. The problem with old cobblestoney towns like mine is that the urge to preserve every shred of the past, often so tourists can get a nice Instagram shot, is at conflict with what the locals require to live in the 21st century.
- vdaea 3y ago+1, I live in a place where many streets are made of paving bricks/stones and I would rather drive through asphalt with potholes. Those stones completely destroy your suspension (and your entire vehicle if your suspension is hard) and get slippery and dangerous if you drive a motorcycle.
- pixl97 3y agoAnd they don't address why asphalt has potholes... Either frost heave or drainage issues that allow crocodile cracking. If you put those bricks/stones in the same environment you'll get the same pothole.
- hinkley 3y agoAbout once a year I ask myself why they don't recycle cobble streets. We recycle asphalt, we're trying to recycle concrete. If you look at the cobbles it's relatively clear that the wear patterns have something to do with the hardness of the stones/bricks. If you sorted the recovered stones by height, and built a new road with matched cobbles, you would still get wear of course, but the variance would be less, right? Take three city blocks of cobble. Sort them into three groups, one containing the softest and the broken cobbles, then use each of the remaining to pave one block each.
- nemo1618 3y ago> road damage scales as the fourth power of the axle weight Is there a theoretical basis for this? It looks like the "fourth power law" comes from an empirical test conducted in the 50s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AASHO_Road_Test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AASHO_Road_Test However, that article says: > ...critics point out that its data is only valid under the specific conditions of the test with regard to the time, place, environment, and material properties present during the test. Extrapolating the data to different situations has been "problematic".[3] Other studies have attempted to refine the results, either through further empirical studies, or by developing mathematical models, with varying success. I have some intuition for why certain physical systems would scale quadratically or cubically, but where on earth is the quartic scaling coming from here??
- cyberax 3y ago> I have some intuition for why certain physical systems would scale quadratically or cubically, but where on earth is the quartic scaling coming from here?? Two quadratic processes working at the same time, perhaps? My guess: increased weight pushes tires deeper into the pavement, allowing them to grab and dislodge larger particles. At the same time, axle weight is a good proxy for torque, so a vehicle with a larger weight can also exert more force on the particles that it grabbed.
- mcmoor 3y agoYeah I remember searching to mathematical justification because it sounds like it'd be interesting, only to come up empty. Disappointing especially when I've seen some suggestions to base tax on it.
- bequanna 3y agoBefore fossil fuels “wind down”, won’t we see asphalt actually get cheaper as transportation shifts to electric?
- maicro 3y agoMy super rough understanding is that asphalt, like many plastics, are actually made with otherwise scrap byproducts of the fossil fuel refinement process. So if electric vehicles become far more common, and fossil fuel refinement decreases, asphalt and petrochemical plastics might actually _increase_ in price as their raw materials become more scarce. It's my pet theory that this is the opposite of what happened with energy drinks - decaf coffee became popular, so suddenly we had a surplus of relatively pure caffeine (once you let the hexane boil off).
- somerandomqaguy 3y agoIt's been a while since I did anything relating to construction so forgive me if I'm getting something wrong. Bitumen is the byproduct, and it's cheap because of that. But IIRC it wasn't just the cost that made it attractive. It's easier to work with then concrete, and maintenance via resurfacing is easier as well. It's a fair bit more flexible as vs concrete which can be desirable as the soil under the road settles and shifts over time; a concrete road will crack under those circumstances.
- hinkley 3y agoI had read somewhere that supercritical carbon dioxide was used to extract caffeine, but when I went to cite sources last year, I couldn't find any. I don't know now if that was misremembered on my part or someone's wishful thinking getting the better of them. "Everybody's doing it." Well, you and three other people isn't 'everybody'.
- maicro 3y agoEh, from what little I know about chemistry, there are often many ways to achieve the same goal - hexane was just the chemical I remember for decaffeination. I looked it up just now as well, and it turns out _my_ memory was a bit off - it's neurotoxic, but seems to be safe(r) in small exposure amounts than I remembered.
- ren_engineer 3y agoit's just the classic: >person in tech spends 5 minutes looking into a subject and thinks they know more than the collective knowledge of every person in the industry
- throwitaway222 3y agoThis is so common in our industry. If I had a dollar every time I heard "they should have software engineer run company X" or be president.
- astrobe_ 3y agoThis is basically an argument from authority (or popularity, maybe a bit of both), doubled with an ad hominem attack.
- NoPicklez 3y agoEspecially this > We need to stop planning project primarily by spreadsheets, where the dominating inputs are costs you can measure easily. There are factors that are not reflected in those calculations that not only affect the quality of the place you're creating, but also the financial burden that the community will have to bear for decades down the line. Did they just completely assume that this is the case? There are very talented people who develop modelling for urban planning and infrastructure that do look into these costs and their impacts. But there is no perfect solution, only tradeoffs.
- JohnFen 3y ago> with the winding down of fossil fuels, we'll switch to more concrete roads. Maybe, but now that everyone is becoming more aware of how terrible concrete is for the environment, maybe not. Work is ongoing to find a less damaging alternative to concrete.
- youngtaff 3y agoConcrete roads are noisy for both drivers and people who live nearby
- SergeAx 3y agoMoscow, Russia, paves many pedestrian sidewalks with stone (or faux stone?) tiles. It is a nightmare in winter when it is slippery like hell, and in wet demi-season, water gets under tiles and squirts up when you step on them. It also looks more like cobblestone paving after 1-2 years because they cannot figure out how to prevent individual tiles from skewing and sinking.