2 ms·
Repair also serves companies better in the long run because one of the big results is that it ends up training the next generation of builders. If you talk to e
by godelski 3y ago
Repair also serves companies better in the long run because one of the big results is that it ends up training the next generation of builders. If you talk to engineers it's pretty common to hear about how they loved to take things apart as a kid and learn how things worked. You don't get the equivalent of a child restoring a classic car or fixing the plumbing with their parent with software. Not to mention that companies themselves will get bug fixes or upgrades from the community who are doing things with the product that the creator never thought of.
Not having the software open and right to repair just seems to me like a classic benefit in the short term, detriment in the long run. And like you say, worse for the public at any timescale. I do want to protect developers, but I think we can do this in a way that doesn't produce so much fucking junk.
- AlexandrB 3y ago> Repair also serves companies better in the long run because one of the big results is that it ends up training the next generation of builders. While I totally agree, this benefit is impossible to quantify on a quarterly report, so I expect it will not move decision makers. That's not to mention that MBOs and not engineers run many modern companies so their conception of engineers is "that cost centre I want to minimize", not a resource that needs to be nurtured.
- godelski 3y ago> this benefit is impossible to quantify on a quarterly report Well I think this is a more precise version of the short term long term dichotomy I expressed. So much of our world is dictated by quarterly reports and it's incredibly destructive. Isn't one of the key things that makes humans unique is our ability to do future planning? I guess quarterly is more than most animals, but it still seems incredibly short sighted considering we learned to prep for winter millennia ago.
- silexia 3y agoThe concept of limited liability is the source of many of America's societal ills. If people were liable forever for the actions and could not contract it away, especially when concerning actions that can harm the public, you would see executives and boards of directors behave very differently do today. Limited by ability socializes risk and harms and prioritizes profits. They both should be privatized.
- PeterisP 3y agoYou could say that it serves the industry better in the long run, however, for each specific company arguably it's not a benefit - there's no competitive advantage if the same new builders are available to their competitors, and they already have some builders and capacity for making more, so if it's more difficult for new ones, well, that's just a higher barrier for entry that allows them to extract higher margins; having higher costs doesn't necessarily mean lower profits if you can just raise prices as no potential competitors have lower costs.
- godelski 3y agoI'm not sure this is true. Meta seems to be doing pretty well with everyone hacking on LLaMA. Same with Stability and Stable Diffusion. Plus there's the whole set of jobs that are not software based, where they are naturally "open source".