3 ms·
Is this evidence for: A) Marketing efforts aimed at getting people to spend are far better-funded and more effective than those aimed at getting people to sav
by bell-cot 3y ago
Is this evidence for:
A) Marketing efforts aimed at getting people to spend are far better-funded and more effective than those aimed at getting people to save
B) Relentless increases in the cost of living, vs. steady-at-best sources of income, have pushed most Americans into net-spending mode
C) The long-term future is regularly portrayed as being bleak enough that many people have stopped caring much about their long-term solvency
D) All of the above
- burkaman 3y agoNone of the above, it is evidence that the US Bureau of Economic Analysis Personal Income metric "does not include realized or unrealized capital gains or losses." So for example if you sell some stocks for a profit and then spend that money on something, this blog post would consider that "dissaving", because the money you made on the sale isn't part of your Personal Income.
- bell-cot 3y agoI'm thinking that "sell some stock for a profit" is really not an option for most of America's less-well-off. Similar for unloading one of their nice houses, or part of their art collection, or ...
- burkaman 3y agoWell something like 50% of working age Americans have some kind of retirement account, and taking money out of that usually involves capital gains. Two thirds of households own their own homes, and it doesn't matter how nice the house is, if you sell it and move that's a big chunk of money in your bank account that didn't come from Personal Income. You're right that a lot of people don't have any kind of investments or houses to sell, and I think most of them are in the 20% here that spends less than their Personal Income.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lr4444lr 3y agoMaybe just rational behavior: very few people in the USA have experienced the kind of long-term calamitous change in fortune since the Great Depression. While many today may believe (with good reason) that it's harder to build wealth, our government also steps much with many more stopgaps to prevent the kinds of losses that can really put someone out on the streets. Perhaps they just would rather enjoy consumption with money while they have it if they won't really sink or rise in any tangible way by saving and investing (or for lack of doing it).
- HPsquared 3y agoIn a world of cheap money, nobody wants anyone's savings.
- jhp123 3y agoE) This factoid is a tautology because any bucketing by income will put more savers in the big income bucket and more dissavers in the low income bucket. People have periods of saving and dissaving over any typical life course, most notably a long period of dissaving at the end called retirement.
- InitialLastName 3y agoE) The headline is misleadingly written and this is actually mostly people living off of asset appreciation in a society that is swiftly tilting towards a surplus of retirees.