2 ms·
Wow, this actually looks like something better than either old disqus or fb comments. I'm tempted to finally get around to setting up a blog again to try it ou
by rdl 15y ago
Wow, this actually looks like something better than either old disqus or fb comments. I'm tempted to finally get around to setting up a blog again to try it out. (I had kind of given up on the idea of a blog comment network once disqus semi-stagnated, and fb comments became more common).
I'm amazed at how much worthwhile comment (albeit with a horrible SNR) is still trapped in phpBB forum sites, blog comments, and other basically painful to access places. Within startups and technology, generally quora or hn or stack overflow or blogs themselves seem adequate, but whenever I search for info about my car, firearms, legal, DIY, etc., it feels like a bad version of 2003.
There's still no good solution to the "local newspaper comment quality problem", though.
- citricsquid 15y ago> is still trapped in phpBB forum sites I really don't agree with that. Standard internet forums have a very important role in internet community, they can't just be replaced by blogs. If you approach forums as just a source of information then sure, they could be replaced by a blog because "why not put all the information I want in blog posts?" but internet forums are so much more than just a source of information. They're about sharing, community and discovery, if you only ever use forums because google search results contain links to them then your opinion is very skewed.
- rdl 15y agoI like forums and community discussion, I just don't like the forum software widely used. phpBB and similar are a colossal step backward from what we had before (USENET). HN is better software than any forum-type software I've seen, but isn't used anywhere else. Reddit might be the second best, but despite trying many times, I really can't get into it, even with subreddits.
- Jimmie 15y agophpBB bugs me too. I have two problems with using HN or reddit to fill the void though. Posts drop off the front page after a day. I've never seen a way to prevent this happening, there really needs to be a way to sort by "most recent comments" on the post pages. The comment threading would need a small overhaul so it isn't mostly nested anymore. So the first response to a comment stays flat and the second response braches to a new comment node. Comment threads only growing to 8 comments deep before "continuing on a new page" is a bummer, this would keep almost all the discussion on a single one.
- rdl 15y agoThis is the product I wish Google would build, rather than a shitty Facebook knockoff. Google Groups has gone through two major iterations, and is now basically useless. People might not want Google to have their personal information (I'd say people probably trust Facebook more than Google with "sharing social information" -- this isn't entirely rational), but forum posts are basically things you want to have public. It's got a "community management" piece which Google probably couldn't get right, but they could provide tools to people/groups to run forums. The big plus for users would be aggregating content (RSS++), anti-spam, etc. Facebook Groups is probably the best "small group sharing info" tool right now, and it's inherently non-indexed.
- Jimmie 15y agoI wouldn't want it integrated with current sites though. I'd like it self-hostable and with separate account signups. "Login with facebook/gmail" is ok but for some people that's a privacy barrier that they won't cross.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoI have long longed-for a reddit styled forum. Threaded, lightweight comments (kill "signatures", whoever thought that was a good idea), with the same sort of new-post-bumps-topic forum style. It looks like Disqus is part of the way there, depending on their API you could maybe even hack together this functionality without having to write much of this yourself.
- codinghorror 15y agoNone of the 10 year old forum communities I can find use threading. Are you aware of any? To me, this indicates that threading isn't sustainable in the general case of online communities that type paragraphs to each other. Programmers love it as a data structure, but it's just too confusing for everyone else.
- Jimmie 15y ago
- starwed 15y agoI honestly can't think of a single way HN's software is superior to reddit's from my standpoint (as a user), so I'm curious -- what is it you like better about it?
- rdl 15y agoIt's less ugly. It's simpler.
- codinghorror 15y agoI agree that Reddit has a terrible user interface (IMO, obviously) and it's amazing it has the traction it does. Of course we could also say the same thing about the vast majority of forum software, too. Apparently human communities are very, very good at getting software to fit their social needs even when the UI is suboptimal.
- starwed 15y agoHow specific of you...
- codinghorror 15y agoAgree completely. I can't say much more other than, uh, "stay tuned".
- rdl 15y agoWow, if you kill the expert-sexchange of forum software, you'll be 2 for 2. Thanks in advance!