4 ms·
You'd be surprised... But actually, fizzbuzz is just the bottom level. You also want to do basic coding exercises for whatever specific area you are hiring for
by kstenerud 15y ago
You'd be surprised...
But actually, fizzbuzz is just the bottom level. You also want to do basic coding exercises for whatever specific area you are hiring for, such as:
- Set up an extremely basic web app that lets the user enter a name and echoes it back to them.
- Make a sprite move across the screen.
- Display a 3d cube with different colors on each side and make it rotate.
- Make it play some music.
- Aggregate the data in this simple database.
- Here's some naive producer-consumer code. Make it thread-safe.
- Debug this code that has memory issues.
- Critique this (flawed) design.
- Update the CSS to make this page look nicer.
Basically, you never want to get into a situation where you've hired someone who has managed to talk his way through life. It's far less headache to just use a few sanity checks on every potential hire.
- kragen 15y agoI wonder if there's a harder equivalent to FizzBuzz — one that doesn't take any longer to explain or do, but requires a much higher level of skill to pass. One we used at http://airwave.com/ http://airwave.com/ was "Write a Perl subroutine to determine whether a string is a valid dotted-quad IP address," which is something you can do in various reasonable ways in one to five lines of code.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mseebach 15y agoThere are plenty, and yours is a good example of one. In fact I think actual FizzBuzz is not used much in the wild any more as it's too well known and thus drillable.
- Natsu 15y agoIs that really so much harder? Somehow, I expect you'd get a lot of opaque regexes like: sub isIP { return (shift =~ m/^((\d{1,2}|1\d{2}|2[0-4]\d|25[0-5])\.){3}(\d{1,2}|1\d{2}|2[0-4]\d|25[0-5])$/)? 1 : 0; }
- kragen 15y agoI failed to note in my earlier comment that yes, it is so much harder. Fizzbuzz requires that you write a loop, print some strings, and either maintain a couple of counters or use the modulo operator. Your solution requires: - writing a subroutine - understanding Perl parameter passing - understanding Perl regexps, including =~, anchoring, alternatives, metacharacter escaping, character classes, and repeat counts; - the ternary operator. And then you could probe things like: - Do they know how to fix the bug in your version where it incorrectly accepts an IP address with a newline appended to it? - Do they know it would still work without the return and the ?1:0? - Can they figure out that they could simplify and clarify the code substantially with qr? - Do they understand why someone might prefer a non-regexp-based approach? :)
- kragen 15y agoI think we did get someone solving it that way once, and modulo Unicode, it's arguably a reasonable solution. But there are other one-line solutions that are more transparent. The Stanford CS Ph.D. candidate whose solution included a Perl function for converting decimal numbers of up to three digits to binary was rejected.