7 ms·
I don't think it's accurate to call this a price. You are not purchasing a product when you fund something on Kickstarter. You are investing in them, and if the
by scott_s 15y ago
I don't think it's accurate to call this a price. You are not purchasing a product when you fund something on Kickstarter. You are investing in them, and if they succeed, you get the thing you signed up for. I think that most people who invest in projects on Kickstarter now understand this, but I'm not sure that will continue to be true as it grows in popularity.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ibdknox 15y agoeven with Light Table it's been a bit of a battle fighting that mentality. I think that's why the physical products are doing so well - it feels like a natural "shopping" experience where what you get is tangible.
- mbreese 15y agoWith really delayed gratification...
- evincarofautumn 15y agoYeah. Actually, it’s less even like an investment than a private non-charitable contribution, akin to giving to a public television station.
- jgmmo 15y agoOriginally, I thought people were doing microlending, and were earning interest on funds they gave out on kickstarter. Imagine my suprise when I learned it was simply donations, with the promise of some kind of gift in return should things go well.
- bostonvaulter2 15y agoI consider it more of a modern-day system of patronage divided amongst many people (instead of a singular wealthy individual).
- jamesaguilar 15y agoIt's basically one way of solving the Coasian problem.
- heyitsnick 15y agoYou mean one way of implementing the Coasian _solution_ to solving the _free rider_ problem?
- jamesaguilar 15y agoRight. Btw, use * for italics on this site.
- JackC 15y agoI think Kickstarter can be either a purchase, or an investment, or both. From their site: Copies of the thing: the album, the DVD, a print from the show. These items should be priced what they would cost in a retail environment. ... Kickstarter isn’t charity: we champion exchanges that are a mix of commerce and patronage, and the numbers bear this out. ... So what works? Offering something of value. Actual value considers more than just sticker price. If it’s a limited edition or a one-of-a-kind experience, there’s a lot of flexibility based on your audience. But if it’s a manufactured good, then it’s a good idea to stay reasonably close to its real-world cost.[1] So their platform is flexible. It works as a way to take pre-orders for a speculative new product (with no guarantee product development will succeed), or as a way to seek patronage for your art. As far as I can tell they're not too opinionated about which of those you go with, as long as you're creating something. I think the key when you're running a project is to be clear about how you're using the platform. People think very differently about buying products and patronizing art, so you need to structure your offers and your story differently. As I said in the last thread, I think the Light Table project got off on the wrong foot because it wasn't clearly positioned as either a product or an artistic endeavor -- it was more like, support my cool project, and then I'll own a nice product I can sell to you later. Offering a license at every contribution level went a long way to clarifying the message. I threw in $50. :) [1] http://www.kickstarter.com/help/school/creating_rewards http://www.kickstarter.com/help/school/creating_rewards
- JackC 15y agoAnother way to think about this -- when I get my copy of Light Table, will I be allowed to give copies to my friends? If not, then I'm buying a product. I may also be supporting an artist (I think so), but I'm buying a product.
- scott_s 15y agoMy point is that Kickstarter is not a store, and it's not a simple money-for-goods-or-services exchange. People who give money need to understand that. If they don't, they'll feel cheated if the project fails and they don't get the item that they feel they "purchased."
- FrankBooth 15y agoIt's not an investment, please don't kid yourself.
- arandomJohn 15y agoInvest? Hardly. If it is an investment then I'm a VC and should have a stake in the resulting company. Frankly, I think that Kickstarter should head towards this model and fund companies and give equity rather than being an oversized tip jar for projects. I could imagine a Kickstarted financed feature film that paid the investors. They could call it The Producers...
- AlexDanger 15y agoThe Kickstarter distinction between investment/purchase is a bit blurry sometimes. What if I pledge $80 and Light Table becomes vaporware or development ceases? Do I still get the t-shirt? At some point its inevitable that a big Kickstarter project will fail spectacularly. Those who gave money will be understandably angry. People will demand action from Kickstarter when in reality they have nothing to do with it. Will this change pledging habits and reward structures? Undoubtedly. Kickstarter themselves seem to be still testing the waters when deciding what projects are appropriate for their site. The approval process is done manually in house. Will this scale? I think eventually we'll see a number of smaller crowdsourcing sites pop up that are particular to certain product niches or investment types. GameKickStarter, MusicKickStarter, TravellingCircusKickStarter, MyStartupKickStarter. If this comes to fruition I think it will be great and allow consumers a better understanding and flexibility about how they want their money to be used. I look forward to seeing how new startups innovate in the crowdfunding space.
- ricardobeat 15y agoThis already happened (not the biggest of projects, but still). The guy took $80k after asking for $6k, and completely blew it. One year later and he is still "doing research" and hints at not having any money left.
- ricardobeat 15y agoThis talk about being an "investment" is a bit misguided. Being an investment would suggest that you are expecting a return greater than what you put in, sharing the project's success, so from this view point you should be even angrier when a project tanks... And considering that the majority of successful kickstarters are for physical products, and pricing is naturally always higher than market price, it wouldn't make sense anyway. You're paying above market price; you can consider the early access/support as having a greater value, but then you're still buying that status. For me it's clearly a donation slash purchase that involves lots of risk - crowd-sourced patronage. The words patronage or sponsorship should be given the spotlight, not investment.