5 ms·
In 1950, a U.S. troop plane vanished without a trace in the Yukon
- irrational 3y agoLidar can find ancient ruins under dense jungle canopies. Could it do the same thing for a missing plane in the evergreen forests of western Canada?
- brazzy 3y agoI doubt that very much. Lidar "finds" ruins by showing large, regular (round, rectangular) structures which then stand out very much to human analysts. But an airplane that crashes at high speed results in a field of relatively small, irregular debris.
- foota 3y agoIf part of the fuselage was intact it seems like that might show up with high enough resolution? Most things in nature aren't that smoothly curved
- kaliqt 3y agoWell sure, if you're lucky. Therein lies the problem, hard to tell until you try and actually find it, because we've no idea what condition it's in and where it ended up.
- justsomehnguy 3y agoYou won't get a nice 3D model of everything in the area. You would get a bunch of dots on a plane with a lot of noise. Edit: reworded.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoDocumentary (2022) https://www.redtrilliumfilms.com/skymasterdownhomepage https://www.redtrilliumfilms.com/skymasterdownhomepage
- ChrisArchitect 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1950_Douglas_C-54D_disappearance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1950_Douglas_C-54D_disappearan...
- behnamoh 3y agoIncidents like this remind me just how vast the planet is. Zooming out on Google Maps, you might think that compared to our body size, the size of our houses, cities, counties, etc. isn't that large after all; sure you look like ants in comparison but the surface area seems traversable. And even if it's not, we have radars that can scan vast swaths of the surrounding areas, no? Wrong. The Earth is unmeasurably huge compared to any human-made technology (and that includes radars, cities, etc.), and that's just the surface of the planet. Add the third dimension (and much more difficult to scan, no less) of the oceans and air, and you'd wonder how the heck we can still find our way on flights. It's a fragile tech, and when it crashes (literally), it's almost impossible for us to find where it happened.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zormino 3y agoEverything we do and everywhere we go is inside the skin of an apple
- rad_gruchalski 3y ago> The Earth is unmeasurably huge compared to any human-made technology Our species has made some rather accurate calculations of Earth. Far from „unmeasurable”.
- jvm___ 3y agoWe're just the green stuff that grows around shower drains. Humanity lives immediately next to water sources and almost nowhere else. We're just really advanced pond scum.
- bruce511 3y agoI'm gonna go with it's in a lake. A) it's big, but in a lake it varnishes easy. B) lake isn't forest. In winter, it makes an obvious landing option when things go wrong. C) chances are it crashed, not landed. Perhaps a fire weakened the ice, hot engines etc. If it landed one would expect radios to work. D) it hasn't been found since (but others have), so I eould suggest it's "not easy to see". The Yukon is big, and population is sparse, so its possibly on land, but speaking as a golfer, if there's water around, it's likely in it.
- brazzy 3y agoDoesn't even need to be in a lake. The Yukon is HUGE, covered in forest, and has a bunch of mountains. It's very easy for a plane wreck to be very hard to see in a gorge or among trees. Survey technology was very limited in 1950, and after a few seasons of plant growth, a debris field can become almost invisible from the air. And if it's in rough territory, nobody might ever come near it on the ground, or walk right past it without noticing.
- Mistletoe 3y agoBut if you’ve read the article, over 500 other planes have all disappeared in the territory and they’ve all been found. So no matter how vast the forest, is they’ve all been found. There seems to be some anomaly with this one.
- AmVess 3y agoI was in AK when a twin engine plane vanished. It was found a year later, it crashed next to a main road. Planes can be next to impossible to spot, even when they are next to a motorway.
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 3y agoA Mooney was lost in the Rogers Pass along the Trans Canada Highway. A couple years later EMS in a helicopter spotted it some 50 yards off the highway. The local conifer trees are huge.
- __loam 3y agoIce on the wing but it's "not a problem" is how a lot of general aviation accidents happen too.
- lovecg 3y agoNot that many nowadays thankfully, much better forecasts and technology seems to help.
- fransje26 3y agoTrue. Nowadays we have de-icing system that need to be turned off within 5 minutes of encountering dry air, to avoid catastrophic disintegration. "We encountered dry air, but otherwise, all is well." You cannot stop progress! https://archive.is/9BWCD https://archive.is/9BWCD
- lloeki 3y agoYeah, although AF 447 would like to have a word. ~ one minute freeze of Pitot tubes caused a jump out of normal law and then the dramatic event unfolded.
- MichaelRo 3y ago>> There's a database of over 500 known airplane wrecks in the territory. Well, this was unexpected. On the one hand, Yukon is larger than the surface of Germany. On the other hand, were there 500 plane crashes in Germany, excluding wars? Turns out far from it: almost 10x less with 62 fatal crashes since 1945: https://www.statista.com/statistics/262867/fatal-civil-airliner-accidents-since-1945-by-country-and-region/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/262867/fatal-civil-airli... Now maybe not all the 500 plane wrecks were fatal but still that's a disturbing likelihood of a crash. With Germany having some 100x-1000x more intense traffic than Yukon, that's easy 1000-10'000x times more likely to crash in the Canadian wilderness. I think I'll pass visiting that in a plane :)
- echoangle 3y agoThe crash statistic you got is only counting airliners though, I’m pretty sure the 500 crashes in the Yukon would not appear there, because they aren’t all civilian airliners. The statistic only has 191 for Canada.
- Zigurd 3y agoBack country aviation is way higher risk than general aviation as a whole, which is in turn much riskier than commercial aviation.
- 0RQ2kaTBBlQp 3y agoIt is stupid to say "vanished". Please be serious on this kind of things.
- christkv 3y agoReminds me of the lost russian family https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lykov_family https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lykov_family
- kdowns 3y agoWhen my grandfather finished his ROTC program for the army core of engineers him and one other classmate got assigned to go to France to rebuild destroyed bridges. I asked him once what his other classmates ended up doing and he had told me they all died in-route on a transport plane headed to Korea. I wonder if this is the one? I didn't ask for more details at the time because it was clearly something he didn't like dwelling on.
- wkat4242 3y agoDon't think so because it was headed from Anchorage to Montana
- nickdothutton 3y agoI’d encourage anyone who doesn’t know the area to check out quite how large the Yukon is in comparison to other places you know. For example: http://www.comparea.org/GBR+CA_YT http://www.comparea.org/GBR+CA_YT
- biscuits1 3y agoI'm gonna go with they were abducted by aliens.
- 486sx33 3y agoAn unfortunate name , “skymaster”
- grecy 3y agoI lived 4 years in the Yukon, and it is impressively big with very, very few roads. Even today, there are twice as many moose as people in the Yukon. We would go on 10 canoe trips and not only not see other people, but not see evidence of people - no "campsites", no roads, no power lines, nothing. And that wasn't even remote by Yukon standards at all.
- coding123 3y agoIt's in the Lost island
- captaincrunch 3y agoSometimes I like to think that this plane was landed in anyone of the 10's of airfields around Snag and the men were the first batch for the MKUltra Project, which started in the early 1950s and officially sanctioned in 1953. It involved illegal activities, including the use of U.S. and Canadian citizens as unwitting test subjects, aiming to develop techniques and substances for use in interrogations and warfare
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 3y agoA Lancastrian (bomber design conversion to airliner) disappeared in the Andes. Decades later bits were found on a glacier. A Trans Canada North Star (same Merlin engines as the Lancastrian) flew into Mt Slesse in 1956. Fragmented debris was discovered by climbers the next spring. Scattered pieces blend in very well on talus slopes.