7 ms·
Nuclear power saved Armenia
- BMc2020 3y agoAn environmentalist movement sprang up, calling for the shutdown of the Metsamor reactors. The authorities backed down, and the two reactors were turned off on February 25 and March 18, 1989. Environmentalists defeated the Soviet Union? You would think that would have made the newspapers. Areg Danagoulian is an associate professor of Nuclear Science and Engineering at MIT
- polotics 3y agoThis was a green movement perceived as useful idiots by the empire, that was in its death throes already. Accepting this pressure was a way to save face, by feigning to accept the lie that all power plants were dangerous, in spite of differences in design and management.
- throwbadubadu 3y agoHow save? Chernobyl's exclusion zone today is 2600 km², it initially affected 150000 km², Armenia is what? 40000 km². One well planned sabotage or airstrike, and the energy independence is not only gone but also an eventual long term disaster for much percentage of that land.. > It is now clear that Western use of natural gas and petroleum from aggressive dictatorships—which use cash flows from oil and gas sales to reinforce and expand their hold on power—has backfired badly. This feels awkwardly over repeated today. Embargos as always of course don't work, still most of the West more easily than all doomsayers expected reoriented (while they ideally could have been off that much dependence already longer).. there is enough market to other countries and also circumventing embargos. Do the Armenians btw dig the uranium out of their soil and refine it?
- polotics 3y agoYou choose to ignore one key difference between Chernobyl and the Armenian plants: the size of the exclusion zone in Ukraine was large because of the mad graphite combustion. As the plants in Armenia didn't have an insane design, no matter how well placed a strike the worst you'd get is a meltdown, like the Fukushima situation that killed nobody except collaterals of the rushed evacuation...
- serf 3y ago> like the Fukushima situation that killed nobody well, that's wrong.[0] that disaster will continue killing people far into the future with the way it was handled at nearly every step of the recovery. Tepco was great at playing the victim and spinning every facet of PR at their disposal to avoid looking like jerks. the 'Fukushima situation that killed nobody' comment is a direct reflection of how well Tepco played it reputationally, even if they did a piss-poor job of handling it practically. Thankfully the whole thing wasn't entirely unjust[1]. I agree with your points w.r.t. Chernobyl. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disaster_casualties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disa... [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jul/13/fukushima-nuclear-disaster-ex-bosses-of-owner-tepco-ordered-to-pay-yen-13tn-tokyo-court https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jul/13/fukushima-nucl...
- zer00eyz 3y agoTepco: We need to put a fine point on this. https://apnews.com/article/japan-fukushima-daiichi-radioactive-water-release-75becaaf68b7c3faf0121c459fdd25af https://apnews.com/article/japan-fukushima-daiichi-radioacti... There is still melted reactor in the ground, nothing is "cleaned up" we just dont really talk about it. Much like Chernobyl this is going to be a "generational" project for Japan. Its handling of contaminated materials remains "questionable". The reason we get less coverage than Chernobyl is that Japan doesn't have its hand out for money and technical support as Ukraine did to get the latest covering built.
- mpweiher 3y ago> well, that's wrong.[0] Last I checked, Wikipedia is not entirely accurate here. Yes, the worker had worked at the Fukushima plant since 1980, and his cancer was regarded as a work-related injury for insurance purposes. However, it was not actually linked to the accident and such a link would be very difficult to prove. "A decade after the triple tragedy that occurred in Japan in March 2011, the United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR) said that future health effects, e.g. cancer directly related to radiation exposure are unlikely to be discernible, in its 2020 Report launched today." https://unis.unvienna.org/unis/en/pressrels/2021/unisous419.html https://unis.unvienna.org/unis/en/pressrels/2021/unisous419....
- culebron21 3y ago> perceived as useful idiots by the empire The empire is not a person to perceive something -- inside the communist party and government, there were many of points of view on the eco-movements. The "empire" had no single stance on the question.
- Fnoord 3y agoFukushima reestablished this green movement. Who benefitted from the green movement then and now? Fossil fuel. Putin and his cronies, just to name an example.
- culebron21 3y agoYour sacrasm reveals your ignorance, not an exaggeration or a hole in the story. Yes, environmentalist movements in 1989 were all across the country, and were significant. It was 2 years into Perestroyka and Glasnost [1] policy, and such things were not restricted from discussion, and 1989 was the year when a lot of non-CPSU new local politicians were elected in local councils and the soviet deputy council [2]. In my region, people would protest a projected Katun river dam [3]. It's not clear, whether the pressure stopped it, or financial shortages, but it was noteable -- at least I as 1st grader saw it discussed everywhere. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glasnost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glasnost [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Soviet_Union_legislative_election https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Soviet_Union_legislative_... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katun_(river) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katun_(river)
- orbital-decay 3y agoTo add to that, Chernobyl disaster and the subsequent coverup attempt clearly showed that Glasnost lacked actual substance. It was the one of the main reasons behind lifting the censorship regime (since the 1987 the press was essentially free to write about anything, and did so), and a major contributor to allowing competing factions inside the party. Nemtsov in particular became a prominent figure after his Chernobyl-related activism. However, claiming that environmentalists took down the whole Union is downright silly. Yes, the fears of the crumbling infra and coverups, Chernobyl nuclear disaster, Spitak earthquake, and Ufa train disaster dominated the media of the late USSR (and especially Armenia, due to the Spitak earthquake), but that was only a small factor, the reasons were much more fundamental.
- culebron21 3y ago> showed that Glasnost lacked actual substance. What do you mean? Glasnost (policy of open discussions) started in 1987, a year later than Chernobyl disaster and the coverup attempt.
- orbital-decay 3y agoIt's been discussed since 1985, with implementation attempts in 1986 before the Chernobyl disaster, but only accepted as the official policy (Glasnost-Perestroika-Acceleration) in 1987. I still have a Uborevich-Borovsky's satirical comic book published in 1986 with Glasnost taking probably one third of it.
- lawgimenez 3y agoWe have a dormant (scrapped because fears of Chernobyl) nuclear power plant which politicos are currently looking to revive. This might be a good case study. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bataan_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bataan_Nuclear_Power_Plant
- senectus1 3y agoA very good video on how much of a huge waste of money that plant has been is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjxZwbg69Fc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjxZwbg69Fc *note, this is not anti nuc power, its all about how corruption, politics and really bad engineering have screwed the project from the beginning
- 7734128 3y agoNever found that person to be accurate or actually informative. Go watch something he has made about something you already know a lot and ask yourself if you want his view on matters where you do not.
- panick21_ 3y agoHe is just the face of a massive content farm spitting out lots and lots of low quality videos on like 10 different channels.
- lawgimenez 3y agoSimon Whistler is a nutcase.
- AcornGrower 3y agoPlease elaborate
- lawgimenez 3y agoThe YouTube video above is inaccurate. Simon says we tend to pursue nuclear weapons back then, it’s not true. It’s in our constitution that specifically states we don’t intend to pursue nuclear weapons. Plus, that plant is not designed to create weapons grade nuclear weapons.
- roenxi 3y agoThe part I find most interesting is that the current political elite of ... I don't quite know what to call it. The US clique? Places that speak English + Germany + Japan and maybe a chunk of the EU. Global North perhaps. Anyway, whoever they are seem to have limited interest in energy security. Much like someone who has no interest in food security, that is going to change at some point. The anti-nuclear lobby has done terrible things and should be ashamed of the position they've put us in. We'd be so much better positioned if they had been rational instead of panicked. It is trivial to make people better off when the energy supply is growing. It is much harder (or impossible) to improve lifestyles at an industrial scale when it is shrinking.
- rightbyte 3y ago> It is much harder (or impossible) to improve lifestyles at an industrial scale when it is shrinking. The abundant consumerism wrecks peoples lifestyles. I don't see the need to jump through hoops to support planned obsolescence consuming of widgets and eating so much food obesity becomes the major health concern. The growth worship need to stop.
- asystole 3y ago> You make them sound like some terrorist sect. Well, is that entirely unreasonable?
- rightbyte 3y agoI did put words in his mouth, so I need to drop that.
- Geisterde 3y agoDefine growth. I dont think you know what that term means, I dont blame you because its misused nearly 100% of the time in media, but its important to be clear.
- rightbyte 3y ago
- thriftwy 3y agoSo the path of a small nation in the shadow of petro dictatorships seems to be getting that petro dictatorship to build you a nuclear plant and supply fuel, so that you can continue to badmouth them from warmth and safety.
- justsomehnguy 3y agoYou forgot "behave like a teenager in puberty and then suffer from the own actions".
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoRussia also supplied the majority of their energy as gas and oil, quote from IEA: > Lacking indigenous resources, Armenia imports natural gas and oil for most of its energy needs (78.6% of total energy supply in 2020), mainly from the Russian Federation (hereafter, “Russia”). Natural gas is imported from Russia via pipeline through Georgia, but also from Iran through a barter agreement under which it exports electricity in exchange. So the digs at Germany seem hypocritical.
- Krasnol 3y ago> The world is currently in the process of reevaluating its past rejection of nuclear power and is increasingly starting to view it as a reliable source of power that allows for greater energy security. I would love to see a source on that since the statistics don't show that [0]. Production actually fell by 4% [1] and even China, THE country with the most ambitious plans for nuclear, rather goes for renewables[2]. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-fossil-renewables-nuclear-line https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-fossil-renewa... [1] https://oilprice.com/Latest-Energy-News/World-News/World-Report-Shows-Nuclear-Energy-Production-Fell-by-4-Last-Year.html https://oilprice.com/Latest-Energy-News/World-News/World-Rep... https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/nuclears-share-world-power-output-multi-decade-low-report-2023-12-06/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/nuclears-share-world... [2] https://cleantechnica.com/2023/02/06/renewables-in-china-trend-upward-while-nuclear-trends-flat/ https://cleantechnica.com/2023/02/06/renewables-in-china-tre...
- fsflover 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26673987 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26673987 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26603464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26603464
- Krasnol 3y agoHow is this supposed to be related? The only thing this policy does is to guarantee EU taxpayer money for rotting fleets. Especially in France where national taxpayer money has to jump in where former Governments failed to establish a diversified energy infrastructure.
- loeg 3y agoYou can see how "starting to view" and "actual construction dollars" are different claims, right?
- Krasnol 3y agoSure. One is an implication in the lack of evidence and the other one are actually related facts.
- Synaesthesia 3y agoThe Soviets not only ruined the image of socialism, they also ruined the image of nuclear power with Chernobyl.
- mschuster91 3y agoWhat permanently sealed off nuclear power in Germany was Fukushima and prior to that, the Brits with Sellafield.
- adrianN 3y agoEven before Fukushima Germany had decided to abandon nuclear power. Fukushima sped up the process by about two or three years.
- EasyMark 3y agoCommunism. America's take on socialism (or democratic socialism) is largely unreasonable and they falsely equate socialism with soviet style communism, mostly because we've failed at teaching our children history and basic types of government.
- thriftwy 3y agoInteresting, because I have another person on a HN thread scolding me for calling Soviet regime communism. I would like people to either reconcile this between themselves or stop pretending like they can correct on well-defined term usage.
- EasyMark 3y agoI suspect the person is an actual communist and not one fond of dictators? no? :) . I still stand by the idea that real communism as professed by Marx can't survive in groups bigger than the hunter-gatherer groups of old for much more than a generation before it will self-immolate. Most people are "greedy" and will only truly sacrifice for their loved ones like family and their "best of" friends. I will dive to push my child out of the way of an oncoming vehicle without regret or pause (or at least hope I would) and would stand back in a similar situation happening to a neighor and hope my neighbor "survives that" or ponder "that's gonna hurt"
- rob74 3y ago> People in Armenia, despite living more than 2,000 kilometers away from Chernobyl, started perceiving radioactive threats everywhere TBF, radioactive threats were pretty common in the (ex-)USSR. One example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lia_radiological_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lia_radiological_accident
- saturatedanalog 3y ago[flagged]
- _v7gu 3y agoThe comparisons with Russia and Ukraine feel really weird; wasn’t Armenia the country occupying Azerbaijani territory for about 30 years? Do we now expect Ukraine to not cut off Russia’s access to resources?
- fipar 3y agoI think if we fill in the ellipsis it adds a bit more context: “ feeling marginalized and discriminated against, had long been fighting to protect their civil rights.” Further, looking at Demographics under https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nagorno-Karabakh https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nagorno-Karabakh It seems “Armenian minority” may have been meant in the context of all of Azerbaijan, not of that particular region, where it seems Armenians were a majority.
- saturatedanalog 3y agoIt "may have been", but the text itself does not say so. Also, I mentioned "neutral perspective" but you are trying to disprove it using a biased website. If you want to see the bias, do what I did: Edit that page and include a made-up accusation(s) for both sides of the conflict at different times. Your accusation for the Armenian side will be removed within minutes if not seconds. On the contrary, your accusation for the Azerbaijani side will stay there for months. This clearly shows, the very same people who are in charge of that page (any other highly politicized page) has significant bias. Now I feel guilty further politicizing HN, but I just cannot help it after being exposed to political content in not-seemingly political posts.
- fipar 3y agoNo need to apologize, plus, I think energy is always a political issue, though not always involving more than one country, much less countries at war. I feel you did politicize this when editing your quote from the article, which prompted my response. I am well aware Wikipedia is open to moderation abuse, but I stand by my use of it as a reference for the demographical distribution of population in that area. For what it’s worth, I think this conflict is yet another leftover from the collapse of the Soviet empire and I suspect things may have turned out better for both sides if that enclave has been split into its own republic once the USSR no longer existed.
- AtlasBarfed 3y ago"The world is currently in the process of reevaluating its past rejection of nuclear power and is increasingly starting to view it as a reliable source of power that allows for greater energy security." This thing only gets written on sharply pro-nuclear sources. Yes incumbent nuclear has a role in grid balancing. Sure, lets keep the lights on for say another decade. But nuclear is just being eviscerated by wind/solar and storage in LCOE, aka the metric you use to plan whether to get new power sources or keep existing ones. And there is basically no way to drop the costs in the future with current commercial designs to close the gap. Even if you started nuclear power construction, the 10 year delay is 10 years of solar/wind dropping in price (they have a LOT of runway between simple economies of scale, and solar still has the perovskite evolution to come), so nuclear projects can't even target a price to compete with (with a straight face, that is). And as usual the pro-nuclear article whines about regulations, environmental activists, and the like. Of course the rise of ACTUAL environmental sources like wind solar destroying by a huge margin the economic basis of nuclear power just raises the zealotry. They are doing the nuclear industry no good spouting all this propaganda. I want you to keep in mind that I am a LFTR/Orion nuthead, and nuclear power is really really COOL. It is my opinion that solid rod nuclear plants will go the way of the dodo, that once wind/solar have reached some degree of price stability there may be complete rethink nuclear power designs that might compete. It might take a generation of people with memories of Chernobyl, Three Mile, and TEPCO dying so the regulatory framework gets a bit more sound. Or maybe China will get a good Thorium reactor going and we have to do it out of competition (which is why there are suddenly Thorium projects cropping up again in research labs). Anyway, yeah, keep the existing plants going while we work on swapping out coal with alternative energy. But solar/wind/storage will probably come for the nuclear plants in the "soon" sense of a decade or two.